EconoMonitor

Nouriel Roubini's Global EconoMonitor

The Eurozone Heads for Break Up

From the Financial Times:

The muddle-through approach to the eurozone crisis has failed to resolve the fundamental problems of economic and competitiveness divergence within the union. If this continues the euro will move towards disorderly debt workouts, and eventually a break-up of the monetary union itself, as some of the weaker members crash out.

The Economic and Monetary Union never fully satisfied the conditions for an optimal currency area. Instead its leaders hoped that their lack of monetary, fiscal and exchange rate policies would in turn see an acceleration of structural reforms. These, it was hoped, would see productivity and growth rates converge.

The reality turned out to be different. Paradoxically the halo effect of early interest rate convergence allowed a greater divergence in fiscal policies. A reckless lack of discipline in countries such as Greece and Portugal was matched only by the build-up of asset bubbles in others like Spain and Ireland. Structural reforms were delayed, while wage growth relative to productivity growth diverged. The result was a loss of competitiveness on the periphery.

All successful monetary unions have eventually been associated with a political and fiscal union. But European moves toward political union have stalled, while moves towards fiscal union would require significant federal central revenues, and also the widespread issuance of euro bonds — where the taxes of German (and other core) taxpayers are not backstopping only their country’s debt but also the debt of the members of the periphery. Core taxpayers are unlikely to accept this.

Eurozone debt reduction or “reprofiling” will help to resolve the issue of excessive debt in some insolvent economies. But it will do nothing to restore economic convergence, which requires the restoration of competitiveness convergence. Without this the periphery will simply stagnate.

Here the options are limited. The euro could fall sharply in value towards – say – parity with the US dollar, to restore competitiveness to the periphery; but a sharp fall of the euro is unlikely given the trade strength of Germany and the hawkish policies of the European Central Bank.

The German route — reforms to increase productivity growth and keep a lid on wage growth — will not work either. In the short run such reforms actually tend to reduce growth and it took more than a decade for Germany to restore its competitiveness, a horizon that is way too long for periphery economies that need growth soon.

Deflation is a third option, but this is also associated with persistent recession. Argentina tried this route, but after three years of an ever deepening slump it gave up, and decided to default and exit its currency board peg. Even if deflation was achieved, the balance sheet effect would  increase the real burden of private and public debts. All the talk by the ECB and the European Union of an internal depreciation is thus faulty, while the necessary fiscal austerity still has – in the short run – a negative effect on growth.

So given these three options are unlikely, there is really only one other way to restore competitiveness and growth on the periphery: leave the euro, go back to national currencies and achieve a massive nominal and real depreciation. After all, in all those emerging market financial crises that restored growth a move to flexible exchange rates was necessary and unavoidable on top of official liquidity, austerity and reform and, in some cases, debt restructuring and reduction.

Of course today the idea of leaving the euro is treated as inconceivable, even in Athens and Lisbon. Exit would impose big trade losses on the rest of the eurozone, via major real depreciation and capital losses on the creditor core, in much the same way as Argentina’s “pesification” of its dollar debt did during its last crisis.

Yet scenarios that are treated as inconceivable today may not be so far-fetched five years from now, especially if some of the periphery economies stagnate. The eurozone was glued together by the convergence of low real interest rates sustaining growth, the hope that reforms could maintain convergence; and the prospect of eventual fiscal and political union. But now convergence is gone, reform is stalled, while fiscal and political union is a distant dream.

Debt restructuring will happen. The question is when (sooner or later) and how (orderly or disorderly). But even debt reduction will not be sufficient to restore competitiveness and growth. Yet if this cannot be achieved, the option of exiting the monetary union will become dominant: the benefits of staying in will be lower than the benefits of exiting, however bumpy or disorderly that exit may end up being.

Nouriel Roubini is chairman of Roubini Global Economics, professor of economics at the Stern School of Business NYU and co-author of ‘Crisis Economics’ that has been recently published in its paperback edition.

30 Responses to “The Eurozone Heads for Break Up”

L’explosion de l’Eurozone envisagée d’ici cinq ans | Bruxelles ma belleJune 14th, 2011 at 5:36 pm

[…] L’économiste Nouriel Roubini connu pour avoir prévu la crise financière de 2008 estime que les pays de la périphérie européenne abandonneront l’euro d’ici cinq ans. Alors que l’agence de notation Standard &Poor’s a dégradé de trois crans la note de la Grèce qui devient ainsi le pays le plus mal noté au monde, l’éminent économiste Nouriel Roubini entrevoit la fin de la zone euro. Dans une tribune publiée dans le Financial Times mais également dans une conférence donnée à Singapour, l’homme qui avait annoncé la crise financière de 2008 estime que les pays de la périphérie européenne abandonneront l’euro d’ici cinq ans. […]

L’explosion de l’Eurozone envisagée d’ici cinq ansJune 15th, 2011 at 9:59 am

[…] Alors que l’agence de notation Standard &Poor’s a dégradé de trois crans la note de la Grèce qui devient ainsi le pays le plus mal noté au monde, l’éminent économiste Nouriel Roubini entrevoit la fin de la zone euro. Dans une tribune publiée dans le Financial Times mais également dans une conférence donnée à Singapour, l’homme qui avait annoncé la crise financière de 2008 estime que les pays de la périphérie européenne abandonneront l’euro d’ici cinq ans. […]

Josefa FutralJune 21st, 2011 at 7:22 pm

It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I’m sure you had fun writing this article.Excellent entry! I’m been looking for topics as interesting as this. Looking forward to your next post.

Euro und Facebook | codexstephaniJune 24th, 2011 at 8:00 pm

[…] Roubini: Eurozone zerbricht Weltwoche: Euro ist Konstruktionsfehler Spiegel beerdigt Euro Euro hat Inflation nicht angeglichen Finanzministerium findet Eurorettung besorgniserregend IWF: Saat für nächste Krise wurde gesät Ökonomenfront gegen größeren Rettungsschirm Dieser Eintrag wurde veröffentlicht unter zum Euro. Permalink in die Lesezeichen aufnehmen. ← Unterricht LikeSei der Erste, dem dieser post gefällt. […]

kore dizileriJune 26th, 2011 at 2:22 pm

I and also my guys have already been checking out the best guides from the website and so suddenly developed a terrible feeling I had not thanked the site owner for those secrets. All the young men were definitely certainly thrilled to learn them and already have actually been loving them. Thanks for really being simply kind and for making a decision on some very good issues millions of individuals are really needing to discover. My honest regret for not saying thanks to you sooner.

koreJune 26th, 2011 at 4:52 pm

Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn something like this before. So nice to search out any person with some unique thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for beginning this up. this website is something that is needed on the web, somebody with a little originality. useful job for bringing something new to the internet!

güncel sağlıkJune 26th, 2011 at 6:10 pm

I would like to voice my respect for your generosity giving support to individuals who really need guidance on your question. Your very own commitment to getting the message throughout ended up being certainly insightful and have without exception made regular people much like me to achieve their desired goals. Your personal useful useful information can mean a lot a person like me and somewhat more to my mates. With thanks; from all of us.

sex camsAugust 29th, 2011 at 5:55 am

Thanks for creating such a wonderful site. Your blog is not just knowledgeable but also very creative too. There normally are a limited number of professionals who are capable of create technical stuff that creatively. we keep searching for content regarding a subject like this. We ourselves went over dozens of websites to acquire knowledge with regard to this.We look forward to much more !!