EconoMonitor

Nouriel Roubini's Global EconoMonitor

Nouriel Roubini Ranked #4 in Foreign Policy’s List of Top 100 Global Thinkers

From Foreign Policy:

fp_image.jpg 

4. Nouriel Roubini

for accurately forecasting the global financial pandemic.

Economist | New York University | New York

Sometimes it takes a crisis to turn a madman into a prophet. And that’s just what has happened to New York University economist Nouriel Roubini, known fondly by economy-watchers as Dr. Doom. When he predicted back in 2006 that the bursting of the housing bubble would decimate global credit markets, causing a broad, international recession, he sounded crazy, IMF economist Prakash Loungani told the New York Times. Not so after 2007: “He was a prophet when he returned.”

Today, “prophet” is certainly an apt word for the gloomy man who is perhaps the world’s most sought-after economic advisor. Central bankers have come to appreciate his ability to peer around dark corners of the global economy, seeing potential busts where others see booms. As his NYU colleague Tunku Varadarajan put it, he’s “the nearest thing to a rock star among the economists.”

“Last year’s worst-case scenarios came true. The global financial pandemic that I and others had warned about is now upon us. But we are still only in the early stages of this crisis. My predictions for the coming year, unfortunately, are even more dire: The bubbles, and there were many, have only begun to burst.” –Roubini, Foreign Policy, January 2009

94 Responses to “Nouriel Roubini Ranked #4 in Foreign Policy’s List of Top 100 Global Thinkers”

PeteCANovember 30th, 2009 at 5:59 pm

Prof Roubibi:Congrats!However, I hope you will maintain a more fiscally conservative stance going into 2010. The USA does not need more stimulus spending – we are rushing headlong into a generational crisis between the “Boomers” and the young people in America … if we DON’T stop spending their future.——————On A Totally Separate Subject:MM-CA said from last post (about Black Friday Retail Numbers): “It’s too early to be certain, of course, but to me this points to a brutal trend: everyone is looking for bargains, and refusing to buy anything else. That means that profit margins are likely to be thin, and even with aggressive discounting, retailers may not be able to drive much volume.”Comment: I had stated that my family’s Christmas spending this year would be modest and we would aim for a “few good gifts”. It now looks like our Christmas spending will actually be lower than that … a direct result of inflating costs over the last few months. So … maybe only as couple of higher-end items. Reason: Costs of food, med treatment, and education have been soaring this year. Our family will also implement a plan in early 2010 to tighten our existing family budget significantly.PeteCA

gAntonNovember 30th, 2009 at 6:54 pm

When will the US stock market bubble bust? I would normally predict that it would take place after a very disappointing commercial Christmas plus a little lag time, say in February, and the event will be a commercial real estate bust similar to but greater than the recent housing bust. But things always take longer than they should. The delay is mainly due to banks and government countermeasures and deception, so inevitable events are usually delayed, Because of this, April 2010 would be a much more realistic prediction.

GuestNovember 30th, 2009 at 6:56 pm

The guy who didn’t see the crisis coming until after it kicked him in the derriere (Ben Bernanke) is ranked No. 1. So please excuse me if I am not impressed. The idiots who did the ranking clearly don’t know what they’re doing.

GuestNovember 30th, 2009 at 7:04 pm

“Nouriel Roubini Ranked #4 in Foreign Policy’s List of Top 100 Global Thinkers”…#1 is helicopter Ben! a fetid PR by TPTB

NouriNovember 30th, 2009 at 7:09 pm

You all permabears need to be taken to the nearest woodshed for appropriate thrashing. What is wrong with you all? Why can’t you remove the “Bear” coat and put on the “Bull” coat? If Richard Russell can do it with the change in wind, why you all can’t do it? Put on your “Bull” coats now, and then go back to the “Bear” coats in May 2010. Just ignore the likes of Prchters and the Sy Hardings ilks.

PeteCANovember 30th, 2009 at 7:23 pm

OK – let’s suppose you put on a nice new Bull Coat. Hey – maybe you just bought it at Macy’s for $1400 on Black Friday. I bet they were glad to see you!!Now remember Ben Bernanke? Apparently he was ranked #1 on the most-prized economists list (I didn’t check). He just said that the current projected US recovery is weak. Yet … the Dow has already priced in a spectaular recovery for forward company earnings. Seems inconsistent, doesn’t it??Maybe you shouldn’t put on that Bull Coat yet … you might want to keep it in the plastic wrapper in case you need to take it back to Macy’s.PeteCA

GuestNovember 30th, 2009 at 8:02 pm

Here is what I love about da bulls, they do not feel the needto justify their optimism with data.And no matter how much data the bears bring to the discussion,it’s somehow not enough to convince da bulls that the glassis half empty.

GuestNovember 30th, 2009 at 9:45 pm

Peak Gold?The high cost of mining old mines and the scarcity of reserves as seen the once mighty South African gold mining industry fall from grace in recent years.South Africa’s remaining gold reserves are less than half existing estimates and the cost of bringing the dwindling resource into production may be far more than its value, a new report has found.An article in the South African Journal of Science has highlighted the plight of the country’s gold mining industry, which is afflicted by high costs, environmental damage, falling output and illicit mining. A formerly illustrious industry is in its death throes, according to Chris Hartnady, the report’s author, who predicts that the output of the main Witwatersrand goldfields could fall below 100 tonnes a year within a decade.South African output peaked in 1970, when the country mined 1,000 tonnes of gold and accounted for more than three quarters of world gold production, but production has declined rapidly since. Last year, South Africa produced 233 tonnes — about 10 per cent of world gold supply.“It must be accepted that the Witwatersrand goldfields are now 95 per cent exhausted … the glory days of South African mining appear to have arrived finally at an ignominious end,” Mr Hartnady wrote in his report.http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/markets/africa/article6928681.ece

Regan LinNovember 30th, 2009 at 10:10 pm

Professor,Congratulation. So going forward how do we profit from your prediction? If there is a U-shaped recovery, should investors start accumulating equity?

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 2:16 am

And, we’re talking economists here! As indicated by the number 1 pick, they are here to serve the status quo, the elite.

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 2:19 am

Hopium, it’s all you need, just click your heals together and the economy will return to new bubble heights (regardless of whether there are real underlying resources making this possible) and our wars will end (don’t pay any attention to that general behind the curtain ushering more troops into the New Vietnam war).

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 2:23 am

Please define “profit.”“May we look upon our treasures, and the furniture of our houses, and the garments in which we array ourselves, and try whether the seeds of war have nourishment in these our possessions, or not.” – John Woolman, mid-1700s American Quaker & an early American anti-slavery activist. In his 1770 essay, A Plea for the Poor

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 3:35 am

It’s the aim of the rich to distract all the workers for fear that the workers will notice that they (the rich) aren’t really productive…

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 6:37 am

LONDON (Reuters) – Gold hit record highs at $1,198.70 an ounce in Europe on Tuesday as the dollar weakened against a basket of currencies in the wake of policy comments from the Bank of Japan, adding to strong investment demand for the metal.Buyers have been cheered by the strength of gold’s recovery after a correction to below $1,140 an ounce late last week, which was met by strong fund buying, traders said.Spot gold was bid at $1,194.80 an ounce at 0921 GMT, against $1,179.10 late on Monday.U.S. gold futures for February delivery on the COMEX division of the New York Mercantile Exchange were up $14.10 at $1.196.40 an ounce, having earlier hit a record $1,200.50.http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20091201/bs_nm/us_precious_gold;_ylt=AkxHIWxehSxLbu_9fnf4SY1bbBAF;_ylu=X3oDMTM1MG5nMzYzBGFzc2V0A25tLzIwMDkxMjAxL3VzX3ByZWNpb3VzX2dvbGQEY2NvZGUDbW9zdHBvcHVsYXIEY3BvcwMzBHBvcwMzBHNlYwN5bl90b3Bfc3RvcmllcwRzbGsDZ29sZGhpdHNyZWNv

MM CADecember 1st, 2009 at 7:28 am

A lot more at the link…. this guy knows how to crunch the data…The Truth! The Truth? Banker’s Can’t Handle the Truth!!!User Rating: / 0PoorBest Written by Reggie MiddletonSunday, 29 November 2009I have finally updated my Alt-A and Subprime delinquency, charge-off and loss data using FDIC, NY Fed, Corelogic, First American, and Bloomberg (among others) as sources. If you thought things looked bad last year or this spring, they are getting worse – with no reprieve for the 3rd quarter despite the extreme amounts of liquidity and capital thrown at the situation by central bankers and the US government. As soon as I started writing this piece, CNBC comes out with “US to Push Mortgage Lenders To Modify More Home Loans: The US Treasury announced plans to push lenders to modify more loans after the administration’s $75 billion housing rescue plan, called Making Home Affordable, fell short and foreclosures continued rising.”Hmmm… $75 billion is a lot of money. Mayhap the problem is that the banks know how useless pushing on a string is, or mayhap $75 billion is not enough to stem $304 billion (and counting) in Alt A and subprime losses that are still in the pipeline (see graphic below).It gets worse though. Let’s glance at the non-conforming loan losses that have already occurred in comparison to the SCAP projections that justified the return of TARP in many cases. Recovery rates had the illusion of increasing ever so slightly due to an increase in prices as illustrated by the Case Shiller index. I have expressed my doubts about this housing price recovery for several reasons, the least of which is the construction flaws in the index itself which fail to capture the nature of the transient price increases, namely the activity of short term investors and flippers (see On the Latest Housing Numbers). There are some areas that have witnessed some firming of pricing though, but that firmness is the result of the Fed and Treasury trying to blow another bubble within a bursting bubble and is more than outdone by the rampant deterioration in credit quality of loans that result in the dumping of foreclosures -> REOs -> short turnaround sales/flips (via investors, which are not captured by Case Shiller, hence the illusion of a firming market in the lower end of housing prices) all over the place.http://boombustblog.com/200911291224/The-Truth-The-Truth-Banker-s-Can-t-Handle-the-Truth.html

MM CADecember 1st, 2009 at 7:45 am

Goo d luck if you plan on retiring sometime in the 5 to 15 time frame. As I said past January this is a 1-2 Trillion dollar problem.Pension Tension on the Rise?Submitted by Leo Kolivakis on 11/30/2009 20:09 -0500BankruptcyBondsCollapsecongressDeficitsDeltafundinghedgeHedge FundsInterest ratesJobsMarketsMeltdownmoneyOilPrivate EquityStock MarketTaxUnemploymentUSSubmitted by Leo Kolivakis, publisher of Pension Pulse.Colin Barr, senior writer at CNN Money reports that Pension tension is on the rise:Retirement plans are on the mend, but the healing process is going to be long and painful.In addition to taking a big chunk out of individuals’ 401(k)s, last fall’s market meltdown left 92% of corporate pension plans underfunded at year’s end, according to a study by investment consultant Wilshire Associates.As bad as that sounds, it pales in comparison to the shortfalls in public pension plans. At the end of 2006, public pension plans were already underfunded by $361 billion, according to the Pew Charitable Trusts. That was before the stock market collapse, soaring unemployment rates and tumbling tax revenues dealt municipal finances another blow.The federal insurer of corporate pensions, the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp., reported this month that it was $22 billion in the red in the most recent fiscal year. The PBGC takes over pensions when they are underfunded or when their sponsors go into bankruptcy, and makes up some of the payments due.While the bounce in the stock market this year has helped the situation, observers say more pain is ahead.Strapped municipalities will face pressure to cut back on promised benefits. Hard-hit companies will be forced to choose whether to invest in their businesses or to beef up their pension plans.”We’re going to face increasing stresses in the pension world over the next three to five years,” said Leo Kolivakis, a pension industry consultant who writes the Pension Pulse blog. “People are hoping and praying the stock market will bail them out, but they’re going to be disappointed.”There are several forces that account for the current pressure on pensions.One problem was that companies didn’t contribute enough to their pension plans. The reason: They were counting on high returns to pick up the slack, a scenario that didn’t pan out in the stock market’s lost decade.Another was that many pension funds made bad investments, embracing so-called alternative investment classes, such as hedge funds and private equity, which have performed poorly in the market unwind.At the same time, companies are now stuck having to pony up more. That’s because of the weak economy, which has led the government to commit to low interest rates for the foreseeable future.It’s also because of the 2006 Pension Protection Act, which started taking effect last year. It includes a long overdue increase in the premiums charged by the PBGC and forces companies to be fully funded by 2015.Congress moved late last year to ease some of the requirements and may yet stretch them out again. But in the meantime, numerous companies are facing higher funding requirements.It all adds up to a continuing squeeze on pension funds’ financial position.”There are no good solutions in an economic downturn,” said Alan Glickstein, senior retirement consultant at Watson Wyatt. “Everyone’s got difficult choices right now.”The bills are starting to come due in state capitols. The West Virginia legislature recently passed a bill approving the sale of $225 million of bonds to help stressed local governments close their pension gaps. The city of Huntington in the state’s southwestern corner had warned that a $125 million pension shortfall could force it into bankruptcy.The situation is less dire for big companies. But they aren’t out of the woods.Among the companies with underfunded pension plans is oil giant Exxon, whose U.S. pension plan assets were worth $6.6 billion less than the plan’s liabilities at the end of 2008. The firm has contributed $4.1 billion to its plans so far this year. And Exxon made $45 billion in profits last year and retains its triple-A credit rating, so there is more where that came from.Less certain is the fate of workers and retirees tied to companies in troubled industries such as airlines, retail and manufacturing.Goodyear, the Akron, Ohio, tiremaker that has cut thousands of jobs in the past year, said in its annual report that its U.S. pension funds were underfunded by $2.1 billion at the end of 2008. The company, which froze its U.S. salaried pension plan last December, warned that the underfunded status would “significantly increase our required contributions and pension expenses, which could impair our ability to achieve or sustain future profitability.”Goodyear says it expects to contribute at least $300 million to its pension plans this year, including $260 million it contributed in the first nine months.OfficeMax, the Naperville, Ill., office retailer, last month contributed $100 million of its stock to a plan that was $435 million underfunded at the end of 2008.Delta Airlines, the Atlanta-based operator of the Delta and Northwest airlines, said in its 2008 annual report it expects to spend $420 million this year on pension benefits.Its pension plans’ liabilities exceeded their assets by $8.6 billion at the end of 2008.While companies are surely hoping that the market rally that started in the spring will take the edge of some of those problems, pension watchers note that the past decade should have taught all of us a lesson about banking on big market gains.”Companies are in the same place as individuals,” said Steve Foresti, managing director at Wilshire Consulting. “Everyone needs to save more. The markets aren’t going to bring these balances back.”I meant what I told Mr. Barr, if plan sponsors are hoping for stock market gains to lead them out of their pension woes, they’ll be very disappointed. Why? Because the next 20 years will look nothing like the last 20 years. Given the historic low levels of bond yields, it’s simply a pipe dream to think that asset appreciation will lead you out of this mess.Pension deficits are a long-term structural problem that will require difficult choices ahead. I’ve been writing about global pension tension for over a year and unfortunately, I have not seen governments take this issue seriously. Perhaps they’re too scared to face the music (watch video below).

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 7:49 am

Out with this idolatryBy Julian DelasantellisHere in the wee hours on the United States West Coast, the house is, like most of the Pacific shoreline at this time of day, quiet, as if enshrouded in a gentle San Francisco bay fog, but I lie awake. My brotherhood in the worldwide guild of financial market professionals means that my body has automatically awoken me early for but one purpose – to see what kind of mood Nouriel Roubini is in today.CNBC usually moves the news fairly quickly. Is he happy? Then, “buy, buy, buy; mortgage up everything you just bought and buysome more.” Is he sad? “Sell, sell, sell, everything – except the late Louis Rukeyser’s bear market favorite investments of choice, corrugated tin and shotgun shells.”A young man is interviewed about Dr Roubini’s mood. ” I found him happy, but with a twinge of fleeting introspection as he reached for his orange peel, maybe a bit of lugubriousness when he chose the Sweet ‘n Low over the Equal.” Yes, the obsession with Roubini is now so great that they’re interviewing the barista, who obviously is brewing coffee only until he gets a starring role on a reality TV drama, who poured the now famed economist’s morning moccachino.Nouriel Roubini, is, of course, the former Bill Clinton era official at the International Monetary Fund and White House Council for Economic Advisors, who, after taking a faculty appointment at New York University’s Stern School,of Business, made predictions in 2005 and 2006 that many feel presaged the current global economic crisis.Just as the bubble was bursting, in a September, 2006, address to the International Monetary Fund, Roubini predicted a “global hard landing” arising from out of “a glut of housing stock” leading to a “US housing bust”. Roubini said that, even if the US Federal Reserve Board did cut interest rates that year, the US would not avoid a recession.For the most part, Roubini does not receive his accolade for the extent of the damage he was predicting, but their timing. In actuality, many of his 2005-2006 era predictions have turned out to be spectacularly understated.But not all the predictions of the Man Who Saw were golden. The US Fed would not ease for another year, yet the stock market kept rising, until October 2007. Anybody shorting the stock market immediately upon hearing Roubini’s initial predictions would soon see his brokerage’s margin call desk number flashing hard and often on his caller ID.Perhaps most importantly, there is nothing in any of his increasingly Nostradamus-like black vaticinations that would indicate he had any special talent or insight that last spring allowed him to possess prior cognizance of 2009′s most impressive, and potentially most profitable story in the markets – the huge rally, up 61% in the case of the US Dow Jones Industrial Average, in world stock averages that followed the market bottom this past spring.Still, in much the same way old-time newspapermen treated ink and newsprint, modern editors are handling Roubini with electrons. Google News reports 1,600 references with his name over the past 30 days, many with ledes such as “The US and the global economy will experience massive deflationary forces through 2012″ or “Market surge heading for big fall, says Roubini”, or “Roubini: Many Jobs Gone Forever”. Particularly interesting is Roubini’s frequent presence on the Page Six celebrity gossip page of Rupert Murdoch’s New York Post, or on the web pages of the New York celebrity interest /stalker site, Gawker, most often in club attire along with pretty, shiny young nubile things on each arm – obviously, his graduate assistants taking all the time necessary to deal with a problem student.Playing the part of Robin, the Boy Wonder to Roubini’s Batman, is one Meredith Whitney, up until last February a bank stock analyst at Oppenheimer, and since then the principal at the investment advisory firm that bears her name. Much like the American baseball player Bobby Thomson, who lived a life of fame wholly on the basis of one home run hit in the 1951 playoffs, Whitney arose out of the media analyst mush on October 31, 2007, with a call on Citigroup.

MM CADecember 1st, 2009 at 7:56 am

This will be the US at BEST, for the next 20 years at least…. I suspect though our worst will be a lot worse than Japans!BOJ to Provide 10 Trillion Yen in Emergency Credit (Update1)Dec. 1 (Bloomberg) — The Bank of Japan said it’s ready to pump more money into the financial system after unveiling a 10 trillion yen ($115 billion) program to help an economy battered by falling prices and the yen’s surge to a 14-year high.“If there is a shortage of liquidity we are prepared to provide more funds,” Governor Masaaki Shirakawa said after an emergency board meeting in Tokyo today that decided to offer three-month loans at 0.1 percent to commercial banks.Bond yields fell the most in 13 months, lowering borrowing costs for companies whose profits are being threatened by deflation and the yen’s advance. Today’s action constitutes “quantitative easing in the broad sense” said Shirakawa, who earlier today faced demands from government ministers to complement a stimulus package that Prime Minister Yukio Hatoyama will release this week.“The BOJ was facing a lot of pressure from the markets and the government, so it wanted to show that it was being proactive,” said Junko Nishioka, chief economist at RBS Securities Japan Ltd. in Tokyo. “The BOJ’s understanding is that deflation risks have increased.”The yen pared losses after earlier falling the most in more than a month on speculation the bank would take action that would limit the currency’s appreciation. It traded at 86.83 per dollar at 11:39 a.m. in London from 87.53 before the announcement. Last week the yen reached 84.83, the highest since 1995, threatening earnings at exporters including Toyota Motor Corp.Bond YieldsThe yield on Japan’s five-year bond dropped 7.5 basis points, the most since October 2008, to a four-year low of 0.455 percent. The Nikkei 225 Stock Average closed 2.4 percent higher before the decision was published.The policy board kept the key overnight lending rate at 0.1 percent, a level that Shirakawa said is already effectively zero, indicating he is unlikely to lower the rate.The bank also maintained its monthly purchases of Japanese government bonds at 1.8 trillion yen. Analysts expect the central bank to expand the bond transactions eventually.“Today’s move is only the first tentative step by the Bank of Japan to a much more substantive quantitative easing policy,” said Glenn Maguire, chief Asia-Pacific economist at Societe Generale SA in Hong Kong. “Ultimately, JGB purchases will form the bulk of that policy — and to have any meaningful effect, those purchases will have to be in excess of 2.2 to 2.5 trillion yen per month.”Asian TighteningJapan’s central bank is expanding credit just when others in Asia-Pacific are looking to tighten. The Reserve Bank of Australia today raised interest rates for an unprecedented third straight month to 3.75 percent on mounting evidence that the economy is strengthening.The world’s second-largest economy expanded at an annual 4.8 percent pace in the third quarter, the second straight expansion after the country’s worst postwar recession. Shirakawa and his colleagues maintained their view that the economy is “picking up,” adding that it will keep growing at a “moderate” pace until the middle of fiscal 2010.“Although there is no change to our assessment of the economy, the yen has been rising and stocks have been declining, which may have adverse effects on corporate sentiment,” Shirakawa said, when explaining the basis for today’s decision.The move came a month after the bank decided to phase out earlier emergency lending measures, including unlimited collateral-backed loans to banks. Shirakawa said introducing today’s program doesn’t conflict with the expiry of those measures, which were aimed at improving funding for companies.Collateral RangeUnlike the unlimited lending facility, which required private-sector debt as collateral, the bank will accept a wider range of assets including government bonds as well as debt issued by local governments. The program has no time limit.The measure will “further spread the strong effect of monetary easing and encourage a further decline in longer-term interest rates in the money market,” the central bank said.Prime Minister Hatoyama welcomed the decision.“I’m very happy that the BOJ and government share the same view” on the economy, said Hatoyama, who is scheduled to meet with Shirakawa tomorrow. “I applaud their efforts to show their resolve to stop deflation and spur the economy.”Chief Cabinet Secretary Hirofumi Hirano said the government didn’t pressure the central bank to make the move. “It was taken in step with the government’s economic policies and was an appropriate and timely action taken in response to a change in underlying economic conditions,” he said.Extra BudgetThe government said today the extra budget will fight price declines and the stronger yen. Finance Minister Hirohisa Fujii indicated yesterday that the spending would exceed 2.7 trillion yen, or the amount of money frozen from the previous administration’s budget.Fujii and Deputy Prime Minister Naoto Kan today said quantitative-easing policies of adding cash to the financial system can support the economy.The BOJ introduced a form of quantitative easing in March 2001 when it began pumping cash into the reserves that it makes available for banks. It ended that policy in March 2006.Consumer prices slid 2.2 percent in October, an eighth monthly drop, and the central bank forecasts the declines will extend into fiscal 2011.The yen’s 11 percent gain against the dollar in the past six months has exacerbated the price slump by driving import costs lower. Today’s program may not be enough to stem those gains, said Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ Ltd.“The decision to offer only three-month loans has proved underwhelming,” Lee Hardman, a currency economist in London at Bank of Tokyo, wrote today. “It is unlikely to either have a material impact on economic recovery or alter the downward momentum in dollar-yen.”To contact the reporter on this story: Mayumi Otsuma

MM CADecember 1st, 2009 at 8:02 am

Tell me something and all of us that we didnt know!CBO: The Stimulus Didn’t Fail, It’s Just That The Real Economy SucksJoe Weisenthal|Dec. 1, 2009, 5:53 AM | 186 |5Economist Menzie Chinn summarizes the latest report from the CBO on the stimulus.From CBO’s just released Estimated Impact of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act on Employment and Economic Output as of September 2009 :…Economic output and employment in the spring and summer of 2009 were lower than CBO had projected at the beginning of the year. But in CBO’s judgment, that outcome reflects greater-than-projected weakness in the underlying economy rather than lower-than-expected effects of ARRA.In other words, the continued deterioration of the economy through the first few months after the passage of ARRA was not due to the stimulus package; rather underlying conditions had deteriorated, and the economy would have been in a worse state in the absence of the package

MM CADecember 1st, 2009 at 8:05 am

Lets see who’s introuble… all these countries need more stimulus, have mounting debt, dealing with infaltion and deflationat the same time, mounting unemployment…The World is changing and there will be winners and losers i suspect…1. US2. Italy3. Dubai4. Japan5. Greece6. Spain7. UK8. France9. Mexico10. all those countries that are already living in pverty..

FEDupDecember 1st, 2009 at 8:15 am

Right on Reggie! Banks are terrified of lending for fear of producing more bad loans on top of the onesthey already have and cannot manage. With decreasing home prices, retail sales, hours worked coupled withincreasing unemployment (thanks MM)it’s going to be a real shocker to the American public that ZERO GROWTHhas become the new norm. The only “U” shaped recovery I see is a sideways “U” where we come up a little andfall back down hard to the bottom where we started. And if the dollar keeps falling, things get even worse!

MedicDecember 1st, 2009 at 8:34 am

Ding! Ding! WE HAVE A WINNER!!!!You could also add that TPTB keep the masses pre-occupied to prevent a revolution. TPTB don’t want the sheeple to know they are wage slaves and have no hope of ever getting out of that position. It’s better for the masses to believe that with some hard work and sacrifice, they too can be wealthy.How else can you explain poor, rural, low-wage earners supporting the big-business backing political parties?Pete -Spending this holiday will come in well below what they want and need. Goods are not what most people need – the masses are spending too much already on food / clothing / shelter.

Guest 42December 1st, 2009 at 9:55 am

Pete expressed his opinion, nothing more or less. Idon’t see any particular name on the comment sectioneither, so why don’t you take your own advice and letall blog visitors comment as they see fit. As long asPete isn’t verbally abusive and as long as he isn’ttrying to hawk ugg boots, I think his comments oughtto be just as welcome as anyone else’s.

CoalDecember 1st, 2009 at 10:04 am

A top global thinkerwould be clearly and insistently informing the American peoplethat they suffer the compounding effects of the financial crisis dujour precisely becausethey have unknowingly been buffaloed into allowing a few private individualsto claim legal ownership of nothing less than the full faith and credit of the nationand that the full faith and credit of a nation can only rightfully belong to the people of the nationand that the practice of giving over to private individualswhat is only achieved by all the public who laboris absurd on its faceand that a few extremely wealthy and powerful individuals are using that usurped creditagainst the people they stole it fromto rob them blind, sabotage democracy, strangle consumption, implement austerity for working Americans…Top global thinker? No.Just another well-tamed professor tossed one of the bones the pets of the wealthy getfor lending their services to the status quo.

CaponeDecember 1st, 2009 at 10:27 am

are US stock certificates lined in gold or silver? can they be pressed together and turned into diamonds or oil or fuel?just curious…are the right people short the SPX yet?are the wrong people sqeezed out yet?

cougar_wDecember 1st, 2009 at 12:05 pm

The global economy is blown.It moves forward now only on momentum and Ponzi operations. Which won’t get you very far.There is no air under the wings. There is no lift, only turbulence. This thing can bounce but it cannot fly and shortly it will eventually grind itself into shrapnel. Then maybe we can start to fix things.cougar

SoftwarengineerDecember 1st, 2009 at 12:13 pm

Statistics can make Any of Us LiarsThe Institute for Supply Management, a trade group of purchasing executives, said its indexgrew last month….LOL…compared to the last recession/depression data months.Its like saying the dead yellow plants were more plentiful during the Great Depression’s dust bowl.Let’s compare today’s manufacturing activity to say, 2006….its horrifying today then.See the proof:http://www.docstoc.com/docs/15898703/Rail-Time-Indicators-November-2009One of the charts show cargo in trains up 5% in 2006, instead of like -20% lately.Most of main stream media ignores the hoards of new desparate Americans looking for workat HomeDepot with our foreign guests, but will point at horrifying statistical trends asencouraging…..ohhh, stocks are up today and the twisted logic manufacturing index improvement[????] is given the credit, LOL.

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 12:14 pm

Why can’t Roubini and Whitney wed each other, as long as this recession lasts?They’re bearish, and they’ve been right when others were wrong. Now, their predictions give a bleak and disconcerting picture of the economy and the road to recovery, but is anybody still listening?Meredith Whitney and Nouriel Roubini are among the market’s most persistent bears. Even as traders approach the end of the year riding a rally that has lasted nearly nine months, Whitney and Roubini have held fast to their gloomy outlooks. Here’s what they’re saying now. [Link, below.]http://www.smartmoney.com/investing/stocks/tale-of-the-tape-bear-vs-bear/http://www.smartmoney.com/investing/stocks/tale-of-the-tape-bear-vs-bear/

cougar_wDecember 1st, 2009 at 12:17 pm

Gold is an element. You cannot create it outside of a supernova; every atom of gold in the universe came into existance in the center of an exploding star, and you only get about 2 seconds out of every 5 billion years in which to create it. On Earth you can mine this “fossil gold” from surface deposits and a certain amount is always coming to the surface from volcanic activity and hot water seeps. Though it takes about a million years to form a viable gold deposit that way.So what you are saying doesn’t make much sense, unless you think (as did Pizarro) that there is some sort of hidden “motherlode” or fount of all gold, hidden in someone’s backyard undiscovered. Good luck with that one Sparky. Oh and can I have your TV while you are gone looking for it? Thanks.cougar

cougar_wDecember 1st, 2009 at 12:25 pm

The most immediate profit would be that you will have learned something meaningful and of lasting importance.As for monetary gains — all profit is theft, of one kind or another, and the aching reality of this is beginning to sink in. The observation that all money flows via innate magnetism into one place like a slim mold congealing on a rotting log is an apt illustration of what we have done wrong.cougar

PeterJBDecember 1st, 2009 at 1:48 pm

Speaking of Keen, with emphasis- er, mine:(the numbering system I also introduce, Yes, for emphasis)1. The only sensible course is to reduce the debt levels.As Michael Hudson argues, a simple dynamic is now being played out:debts that cannot be repaid, won’t be repaid. The only thing we have to do is work out how that should occur.2. Since the lending was irresponsibly extended by the financial sectorto support Ponzi Schemes in shares and real estate,it is the lenders rather than the borrowers who should feel the pain–whichis the exact opposite of the bailout mentality that dominates governments around the world.3. Unfortunately, it will take a sustained period of failuresby conventional policy before unconventional policies,like deliberate debt reduction, will gain political traction.Implementing them will require both a dramatic change of mindsetandprobably also a widespread changing of the political guard.http://www.debtdeflation.com/blogs/Debtwatch 41Ho hum

DesiLurkerDecember 1st, 2009 at 2:05 pm

@cougar_wI believe that was sarcasm directed towards the (unsubstantiated) Abiotic oil theory & business as usual crowd in general.

MorbidDecember 1st, 2009 at 2:41 pm

Cougar,I liked the Supernova/Hypernova connection you made regarding the production of GOLD. Perhaps a Black Swan event is forth coming that will help us in this regard. Of course if it is too close the GRB (Gamma Ray Burst) will muck out all life on the planet; but hey, gold isn’t cheap is it?

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 3:26 pm

I don’t think the appearance on the list which places Bernanke on #1, Obama on #2, and Bill Clinton on #6 does any honor or justice to prof. Roubini. I would be ashamed to be among such “thinkers” if I were him.

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 3:36 pm

We have entered the century of transition, decline, contraction—choose your favorite word.It is the century of limits.And we must learn quickly to get by with less—ultimately, much less—of just abouteverything—in order to live within those limits.It is a tough message. But it’s the truth, and somebody has to utter it.I guess it’s our job, because we are the ones who have shown up.http://heinberg.wordpress.com/2009/11/10/210dilemma-denial-aspo-2009-address/

AnonymousDecember 1st, 2009 at 4:23 pm

Japan had an advanced civilization when European and neo-European monkeys were swing from tree to tree using their tails. I think the Japanese will be around a while longer.

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 6:16 pm

Right, poor prof. got sandwiched among a bunch of people laden with leprosy. Getting sandwiched among people like Grantham, Schiller, Whitney, David Rosenberg, etc., would have been nicer.

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 6:36 pm

That’s not the truth at all.Our autistic economics wastes half of everything.It can be fixed, and easily.I wish heinyberg and his nazi-loving eugenicist pals would STFU.

AnonymousDecember 1st, 2009 at 7:17 pm

YEEEhaaaatime for a showdownhttp://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601039&sid=ahD2WoDAL9h0Dec. 1 (Bloomberg) — “I just wrote my first reference for a gun permit,” said a friend, who told me of swearing to the good character of a Goldman Sachs Group Inc. banker who applied to the local police for a permit to buy a pistol. The banker had told this friend of mine that senior Goldman people have loaded up on firearms and are now equipped to defend themselves if there is a populist uprising against the bank.I called Goldman Sachs spokesman Lucas van Praag to ask whether it’s true that Goldman partners feel they need handguns to protect themselves from the angry proletariat. He didn’t call me back. The New York Police Department has told me that “as a preliminary matter” it believes some of the bankers I inquired about do have pistol permits. The NYPD also said it will be a while before it can name names.

Wild BillDecember 1st, 2009 at 8:26 pm

It’s amazing how those who are the most guilty live in fear of retribution, yet they lack the ability or will to modify their actions. Dostoevsky was right.

gAntonDecember 1st, 2009 at 8:41 pm

Two Peas In A PodWhat can we learn from Dubai and from Bubblemaster Bernanke’s desire to classify all FED economic transactions as TOP SECRET?First, Dubai. Although the general govermental reaction that the Dubai fiasco is a tempest in a teapot is probably correct, what happened very well illustrates how integrated and unstable the global economy is. The global economy is a house of cards, and all someone has to do is open a window or door unexpectedly to let a breeze in, and the show will be over.Secondly, why is the Bubblemaster so against transparency? Is it because he is afraid that the good news he is hiding would cause excessive exuberance and overstimulate markets? I think not! It’s NOT a case of “know ye the truth, and the truth will make you free”–it’s a case of “know you the truth, and the truth will make you run for the exit”.

crgordonDecember 1st, 2009 at 8:50 pm

G,I read the first half of the article and then skimmed the second half in order to find how his views support you comment of “nazi-loving eugenistic pals”. What in specific caused your strong reaction? Or is it prior knowledge of the author that triggered the comment? Otherwise it is difficult to understand your reaction

RalphDecember 1st, 2009 at 8:56 pm

I don’t that the US stock market need “burst” as such. As long as they print enough money every asset class can go up in nominal terms, even stocks.That is not to say there can’t be corrections, there certainly will be those; but that is very different to a bubble collapse in scale. After a correction, as long as money keeps being printed, the stocks can go higher again.

RalphDecember 1st, 2009 at 9:18 pm

The Bible says that “the wicked flee though no one pursues”Such is the nature of fear. Yet still they insist there is no need for salvation.

RalphDecember 1st, 2009 at 9:22 pm

I don’t understand the obsession with the stock markets as a measure of anything; other than how much money they can print.Print enough money, and even a stock market without fundamental support goes up.This is a monetary phenomenon in a speculative market, very little to do with earnings or valuations.

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 10:04 pm

John Gault’s continuing fictional story of a currency collapse.In Part V, John the construction manager, decides pack heat and the “United States Information Agency” hastaken over the broadcast news and talks up Investing in the “New America.” There is the DollarCard andFEMA registration. John goes to work only to discover the building on fire and the boss dead. HisCCW license was banned and carried weapons are confiscated.The Day the Dollar Died Part V – A New Day of Economic Justice for Allhttp://johngaltfla.com/blog3/2009/11/29/a-new-day-of-economic-justice-for-all-the-day-the-dollar-died-part-v/In this segment the bank holiday remains in effect, FEMA takes over broadcast news,gangs attack small towns, police are assigned to protect banker homes, Yuan rises 2:1over the dollar. General Electric files for bankruptcy…The Day the Dollar Died Part IV – Arrogance of the Godshttp://johngaltfla.com/blog3/2009/11/25/arrogance-of-the-gods-the-day-the-dollar-died-part-iv/The Day the Dollar Died Part III – I Have Been to the Fields of Gettysburghttp://johngaltfla.com/blog3/2009/11/22/i-have-been-to-the-fields-of-gettysburg-the-day-the-dollar-died-part-iii/The Day the Dollar Died Part II – American Hangoverhttp://johngaltfla.com/blog3/2009/11/19/american-hangover-the-day-the-dollar-died-part-ii/The Day the Dollar Diedhttp://johngaltfla.com/blog3/2009/11/18/the-day-the-dollar-died/

GuestDecember 1st, 2009 at 11:52 pm

prior knowlege, yes. he keeps very creepy company behind the curtains, but few are aware of who he connects to.

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 4:49 am

Yes, you are correct! :-) I was going to point out that it was sarcasm, but thought that I’d tipped my hand well enough. Sorry, I didn’t mean to mislead anyone (never my intention).There’s actually a fairly humorous (or perhaps scary, depending on your perspective) segment in Dr. Albert Barlett’s presentation where he mentions that some politician (was it Jack Kemp?) stated that if we ever ran out of copper that we could make some.I don’t think that anyone should reside in public office who doesn’t understand simple/fundamental physics!

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 4:52 am

Thanks for the laugh! :-) This does, however, bring up some very important points, and that’s the impact of time on processes. The quicker that something occurs the more violent it tends to be.

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 4:54 am

And was Japan then the nation state that we now know it to be? Uh, duh!The POINT, is that the organizational structure of Japan is starting to disintegrate (as is with most other nation states). This doesn’t mean that there won’t be people living there.

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 4:59 am

WHY CAN’T PEOPLE FOCUS ON THE MESSAGE!You are creepier yet, for pouncing all over something without providing any reasoning at all!

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 5:01 am

Well, if their aiming ability is anything like their ability to do actual, honest work, then no one needs to be afraid!

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 5:05 am

Well, to be fair, and believe me, I have no good feelings about these people, opening up and telegraphing their intentions, even IF they were pure and noble, would expose them to sabotage (think of cold war type stuff). What’s happening is that power is being reshuffled. The US is looking to transfer some of this control (yes, believe it or not) in a manner that is going to maximize its returns (deal now or end up having it taken by entities that have zero sympathy). Just playing devil’s advocate…

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 5:09 am

Oh, let’s weep for the loss of a fiat currency…A LOT of people are going to be pretty upset that their plans/bets didn’t pan out. Those playing nice will continue to get screwed. But in the end, when there’s nothing but rusting hulks of consumerism and its industry, only the basic fundamentals of life will provide any real value.

Little SaverDecember 2nd, 2009 at 5:10 am

Number one:We are all Darwinians now — except in the strange parallel worlds of fundamentalist Christianity and state-guaranteed finance.Neither Cassandra nor Pangloss, Darwin surely deserves to top any list of modern thinkers, dead or alive.NIALL FERGUSONhttp://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2009/11/30/dead_men_walking?page=0,2

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 5:20 am

Just for documentation purposes:http://www.businessinsider.com/roubini-gold-has-topped-2009-6That’s from June 16, 2009. Price of gold was then $934/oz. Today it’s $1,210/oz. Roughly a 30% increase. We’re talking almost a 5 month span here; if there was to be any significant correction downward it would have happened by now: yes, it can still go down, but EVERYTHING will ultimately go down; as they say, it’s about timing; so, in this case EVERYTHING IS A BUBBLE!

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 5:35 am

People need to correct this misperception of what Darwin was saying. He was actually referring to species themselves evolving, not a fight within a specie. For more on this read Peter Kropotkin’s Mutual Aid.It’s environmental forces that ultimately place restraints on growth, thereby “weeding” out the weaker of the population, not necessarily within the population itself. One simple test: how many humans are there on the planet today? think that the sense of Darminian competition would have allowed this size? and, look around you, look at the people that are out there- obesity, diabetes, not something that necessarily shrieks vigor.

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 5:59 am

It’ll be interesting to hear Roubini’s rebuttal to this one:Roubini’s Bubbles Float on Flimsy Credit Source: Caroline Baum I think that Baum’s assessment is correct.Roubini’s early call on this was right, but subsequently his observations have tended to use standard analysis in what is surly an anything but standard economic situation. NOTE: because nearly ALL economic views fail to take into the improbability of sustained economic growth on a finite planet, I guess there really isn’t anything such as a “standard economic situation,” that is, if one were really trying to identify REAL problems and solutions…

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 6:08 am

Oh, but one thing that Baum mentions does raise an interesting question. Could it be that our inflation is really being exported to China? I thought that this is how it “generally” works? But, what would be different this time, is that China is taking and really running with it, and that when they trip and fall, which WILL eventually happen, that inflation is likely going to boomerang right back, in full force, at the US. It’s my theory that the US is trying to find areas to outlet this eventual inflation, trying to figure out how to push some of it elsewhere.At any rate, the world is awash in production. Production deflation will be with us for a long time. There won’t be any new big thing to pull the world’s economy upwards. Inflation/deflation, kind of like arguing over which site of the Titanic one should be on…

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 6:11 am

And if the Devil said to love God, you’d do what, hate God?Like I’ve been trying to stress, it’s the MESSAGE not the messenger! The political forces will try and get us to focus on the messenger so that they, the political forces, can hang on to power (not allow the regular man to find the way out from under their thumbs).

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 6:23 am

His message is as wrong as he is – and you would be able to see that if you knew what he’s really up to.His friends give away what he’s up to.The truth will piss you off before it sets you free.

blindmanDecember 2nd, 2009 at 7:52 am

global thinker? what does that really mean?individual thinker, group thinker, local ,regional, national, international, global,solar system, galactic, etc. , universal thinker.are we ready for global thinking / do we haveany institutional minds competent tothink globally or is fp justblowing smoke up our collective .. in attempt toglorify itself and its own agenda? using globalas a descriptor. ben ? number 1. allen greenspanwas number 1 , no?

blindmanDecember 2nd, 2009 at 7:57 am

@ obama speech 12/1/09″false reading of history”.is there any other kind of reading of history?what about the false writing of history andhow does one properly read that? another top “global”thinker smearing lipstick on a pig, perhaps a universalinstitutional imperative?

blindmanDecember 2nd, 2009 at 8:49 am

sen.charles schumer (d- n.y.)” to commit troops to a war is the most solemnand profound decision a president or legislatorcan be asked to make. i’m going to weigh carefullythe president’s words.”newsday, 12/2/09..everything with these politicians is “solemn” upto and including giving taxpayer money to billionaireswho then turn the money around and give it back to thepoliticians to tell us how difficult and solemn theircowardly decisions and lives have become. to financiallybenefit from sending brainwashed children to kill far awaystrangers is not profound or solemn. it is manifestly unjust,opportunistic and cowardly. to know it and continue it isevil. hence the charade of constantly being surprisedand caught unaware, constantly suppressing real inquiry intowhat has happened and how it happened, repeating historyunlearned, censuring opinion, force feeding ignorance tothe youth and their temporary guardians ( parents ).the only solemn thing politicians do is fund raisingfor their reelections and they are profoundly aware of it.vietnam cubed, here we come. what a shock! unforeseeable,unimaginable. censure the details please, we should not haveto see it. after all global thinking does not require thatyou see these type of things. in a word, or two.. no heart.

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 9:02 am

STOP BEING AFRAID TO GO LEARN SOMETHING, PEABRAINhttp://www.spunk.org/library/places/germany/sp001630/intro.htmlread it. read it all.and then don’t forget to google up hienybergand his “inexplicable” connect to the wicked virginia abernathythe enemy has outposts in your head, binky. don’t expect to go unchallengedwhen you post up the bullshit that peace and prosperity for all is impossible.

GuestDecember 2nd, 2009 at 9:58 am

Darwinism the ultimate excuse for greed and self-destruction, it’s the literalistic view on life or a man without a soul.

GMDecember 2nd, 2009 at 12:24 pm

I have a strong vision of a slow slow revolution upon us in this ‘united states’.This revolution is not about one state vs another. not about the east vs west. not about the north vs south.It is a revolution about stakes and shares. the haves and the have-nots. terrorism within.who gets to decide how freely future generations’ debts get spent today? who decides to print it to begin with?how will we fund medicare and social security? will MD’s settle for a 40k salary?congressional leaders have to better watch themselves as they may fall victims to unhappy Americans.How are sociologists and economists not sounding the alarm?Have we become so oblivious or maybe we just don’t care?

gAntonDecember 2nd, 2009 at 1:56 pm

The power hungry, bought-and-paid-for, market manipulating US politicians are voluntarily going to transfer some of their power? (to whom? to God?). Yeah, sure. What a surprise! Thank you for your insight.

GuestDecember 3rd, 2009 at 3:23 am

Oh, yeah, like calling me “PEABRAIN” (hm, sort of shows how your mind works, rather not) is going to motivate me to read your recommendations?I don’t follow Heinberg or anyone else. Why don’t you spend your time trying to get him jailed? Or, get professional help?

GuestDecember 3rd, 2009 at 3:27 am

I never said that the powerful were going to transfer their own power. The discussion was about what, as a nation-state collective, they were doing. My point is that the power of the US nation-state is being picked apart. I believe that your comment would be for the corporate entities (and I’d agree). You’d be thinking of the wrong person if you think that I think that power concedes without a fight…

GuestDecember 3rd, 2009 at 3:29 am

It may be the excuse, but it’s not the cause. Please refer to one of my posting here that mentions this (and refers ot Peter Kropotkin’s Mutual Aid).

GuestDecember 3rd, 2009 at 3:30 am

It may result in that, but the driver is plain old contraction (though this isn’t any run of the mill contraction).

gAntonDecember 3rd, 2009 at 7:45 pm

This Land Is Your LandThis land is your land, this land is my landFrom California, to the New York IslandFrom the redwood forest, to the gulf stream watersThis land was made for you and me. . . .In the squares of the city – In the shadow of the steepleNear the relief office – I see my peopleAnd some are grumblin’ and some are wonderin’If this land’s still made for you and me.

GuestRODNEY ENGARDDecember 4th, 2009 at 12:36 pm

READ YOUR ARTICLE IN GQ DEC 09. THERE IS POCKETS OF REAL ESTATE GROWTH. MY DEVELOPER IS STARTING NEW CONSTRUCTION JAN 2010 LIMITED VILLAS 12,HIGH END, WATER, MARSH AND SUNSET VIEWS. SUNSET BAY VILLAS ON HILTON HEAD ISLAND S.C. WILL KEEP YOU POSTED ON THE POSITIVE REAL ESTATE NEWS.

Most Read | Featured | Popular

Blogger Spotlight

Edward Hugh Don't Shoot the Messenger

Edward is a macro economist, who specializes in growth and productivity theory, demographic processes and their impact on macro performance, and the underlying dynamics of migration flows. Edward is based in Barcelona, and is currently engaged in research on aging, longevity, fertility and migration, and the impact of all of these on economic growth.

Economics Blog Aggregator

Our favorite economics blogs aggregated.