EconoMonitor

Nouriel Roubini's Global EconoMonitor

Are Asian Central Banks Still Behind the Inflation Curve?

The spike in food and commodity prices has pushed inflation in Asia to record levels since late 2007. Asian central banks, however, initially abstained from hiking interest rates due to fears of contagion from a U.S. slowdown. Instead, countries like India, Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines and Vietnam opted to fight food and fuel inflation using non-monetary policy measures like price controls, export restrictions, subsidies and reduction in import tariffs.

image001.jpg

 

Price caps were imposed on commodities like steel, coal and cement; utilities, transport and other public services. Export restrictions or bans were laid on staples like rice, wheat and corn as well as on oil products such as crude, palm and edible oil. In some cases, a minimum export price or export tax was imposed while import duties were also slashed on several food and oil products. Many countries subsidized (and continue to) food, edible oil and fuel, thus veiling the actual inflationary pressure in the economy. India also banned futures trading in food and non-food commodities while Indonesia cracked down on hoarding and smuggling to neighboring Asian countries. Malaysia raised electricity tariffs and provided rebates for the poor while Vietnam cut govt. spending on infrastructure projects. Thailand implemented a $1.3 bn fiscal stimulus package which included tax cuts on gasoline and subsidized utilities and transportation to cushion consumers from inflation.

China and India also used alternative monetary measures such as raising commercial bank reserve requirements. To contain currency depreciation and import inflation, South Korea, Thailand, India and Philippines intervened (and still are) heavily in the FX market. But as the surging subsidy bill threatened to worsen fiscal balances, countries like India, Malaysia and Indonesia rolled back subsidies. However, this further aggravated the price pressures (apart from causing serious political backlash and strikes by workers facing eroding real wages), thus pushing inflation to decade-highs and even to double-digits in Vietnam, India, Philippines, Indonesia (See Figure 1). The un-weighted average Asia (ex-Japan) interest rate stood at 6.69% as of July-end, and inflation at 10.16%, resulting in a negative real interest rate of 3.47%.

image004_10.jpg

image006_640.jpg

 

 

 

As prices continued to accelerate despite aggressive fiscal measures, Asia realized that inflation and negative real interest rates posed a greater threat to their economies than a developed world slowdown. Hence, it was not until May that most central banks began raising interest rates, taking policy rates to all-time high levels (See Figure 2).

image004-2.jpg

 

 

While India, Vietnam and Indonesia have pursued aggressive or continued tightening, the Bank of Korea hiked rates only in August to slow the won depreciation and its attendant import inflation. China, which hiked rates in 2007 and subsequently relied on other measures to dampen liquidity and respond to supply shortages, saw inflation fall despite negative real rates. Meanwhile, those most vulnerable to a U.S. slowdown – Malaysia, dollar-pegged Hong Kong and Singapore have stayed away from tightening to support growth since they believe the oncoming global slowdown will itself help alleviate commodity inflation.

image010_02.jpg

The correction in commodity prices since mid-July might point to a possible peaking of inflation in 2H08 (especially in Malaysia, Singapore, Vietnam). In fact as global crude prices started easing recently, Malaysia and Vietnam reversed some of the past fuel price hike. These trends might tempt Asian central banks to loosen interest rates ahead in order to aid growth as exports are taking a hit from the global slowdown. Such a policy stance might also be called for to alleviate the slowdown consumer spending and investment caused by inflation and recent monetary tightening. Some countries might also be concerned that rising interest rate differential would keep attracting hot , thus exacerbating the domestic liquidity and inflation situation.

image012_02.jpg

However, this should be a temptation best to ignore since second-round price-effects are now emerging via inflation expectations, wage pressures, and high input, transport and production costs, especially in countries like India, Indonesia, Singapore, Vietnam. While commodity prices might ease in the coming months, they will nevertheless remain elevated so that inflation will continue to pose a risk for most countries. Moreover, apart from global factors like food shortages and oil shock, economies like India, Indonesia, Vietnam, Malaysia have faced inflationary pressure owing to strong credit growth, domestic demand and fiscal spending. Ignoring these dangers of price spirals and inflationary expectations could threaten Asia with stagflation that can have detrimental effects on the Asian currency and equity markets.

7 Responses to “Are Asian Central Banks Still Behind the Inflation Curve?”

samSeptember 13th, 2008 at 10:38 am

dare I say I am first. It doesnt make me feel any more special. why do some of you chomp at the but like pavlovian dogs? So I am first, but am still in much economic hardship.

samSeptember 13th, 2008 at 10:42 am

I personally dont give a hoot about Asia. They are the winners. Whats happening here in the the USSRA is beyond frightening. I will be surprised if we make it another year without all the walls falling in on us. The FED, a private corporation is now in control. Does not give me the warm fuzzies at all.

ptmSeptember 13th, 2008 at 2:00 pm

This is so weird. NR had another post above this post and the first commenter was, of all people, John Ryskamp (sp?) I had to leave to run an errand, and now NR’s post is gone!?!

GuestSeptember 13th, 2008 at 10:56 pm

I am sorry, I missed your point. Are you saying that a critical response left by John Ryskamp (sp) caused NR to remove his post? If so, please explain the salient points to me. I am genuinely curious about this subject.

AnonymousSeptember 14th, 2008 at 9:01 am

Is it just me or are the graphs quite blurry and tough to read? Maybe need to sharpen them or brighten em up.

GuestSeptember 16th, 2008 at 9:45 pm

Do you think the growing weakness in the U.S. will lead other Asian countries to ease policy rates? china is the first to do so, and has the cover of falling inflation? Will others follow?

international tradeMay 28th, 2011 at 12:00 pm

Comfortably, the blog post is during truthfulness a hottest on this subject well known subject matter. I agree with ones conclusions and often will desperately look ahead to your updates . Saying thanks a lot will not just be sufficient, for ones wonderful ability in your producing. I will immediately grab ones own feed to stay knowledgeable from any sort of update versions. get the Work done and much success with yourbusiness results!