EconoMonitor

Nouriel Roubini's Global EconoMonitor

The Coming US Consumption Bust: 12 Reasons Why the US Consumer is in Serious Trouble and Faltering

It is by now clear that the shopped-out, saving-less and debt-burdened US consumer is on the ropes and that there will be a significant and persistent contraction of real consumption for the next few quarters. About a dozen separate negative headwinds – to be described in detail in this note – are now hitting the US consumer while the positive effects on consumption of the tax rebates are already fading away.

That rebate boost was supposed to stimulate consumption until august of this year instead after a recovery of retail sales, real personal spending and consumption in April and May real retail sales and real personal consumption spending have fallen already in June and July. So consumers stopped consuming in spite of the tax rebates instead of spending such rebates (so far only 30% of them have been spent). This suggests that real consumption will certainly fall in Q3 and will continue to fall for a while into the middle of 2009. Real consumption did not fall in the 2001 recession and you have to go back to the 1990-91 recession to see a single quarter of negative consumption growth.

Why will consumption keep on falling for quite a while? There are at least a dozen separate factors explaining why we will now see a sharp and persistent fall in real consumption:

- US consumers are shopped out and saving-less; the low savings rate of the US household sector fell almost into negative territory as the positive wealth effect of rising home prices – until 2006 – led to overspending. Now a retrenchment of consumption and rise in savings is necessary

- Home prices are now falling and therefore households cannot use their homes as ATM machines – like until 2006 – and borrow against it to spend more than their income. Recent studies suggest that the wealth effect of housing on consumption is large, larger than previously estimated (closer to 12-14 cents on the dollar rather than 5-7 cents on the dollar)

- Home equity withdrawal (HEW) that peaked at $700 billion in 2005 is now down to about $24 billion (practically zero). And financial institutions are sharply cutting back on outstanding home equity loan obligations. Thus, borrowing against housing wealth is now collapsing. Even with moderate estimates of HEW effects on consumption (25 cents on the dollar rather than the 50 cents on the dollar estimated by Greenspan and Kennedy)

- There is an additional wealth effect of the stock market on consumption; and with major indices down almost 20% from peak this is an additional effect.

- The increasing credit crunch is spreading – based on various surveys – from subprime to near prime and prime mortgages, to home equity loans and now to credit cards, auto loans and student loans. So the price of credit/borrowing is rising while its quantity is falling and this will reduce the ability and willingness of households to borrow to spend.

- Debt ratios for the household sector are high and rising: the debt to disposable income ratio for average US households has increased from 100% in 2000 to almost 140% today.

- Not only debt ratios are high but debt servicing ratios are high and rising for households given the reset of interest rates to higher levels on mortgages, credit cards, autos loans, student loans and other consumer credit.

- Even after the recent fall in oil and commodity prices from their peaks such prices are about 50% higher than a year ago and 300% higher than six years ago. For any given income, rising oil, energy, transportation and food prices implies a reduction in real disposable income that erodes purchasing power. And lower income households have a larger share of their consumption basket going to food, energy, heating, transportation and gasoline; this the rise in commodity prices erodes their purchasing power more than for higher income individuals.

- Nominal and real wage growth has been anemic in the last few quarters and slowing down over time. Thus, real incomes – especially for workers – are not rising significantly.

- While GDP growth in Q2 has been robust (3.3%) the other measure of output – on the income side rather than on the demand side – that is the Gross Domestic Income (GDI) has been very weak (growing only 1.9% in Q2 and falling relative to Q2 of a year ago). So measures of income growth – and not that the gap between GDP and GDI has been rising over time for complex statistical reasons – suggest very anemic income growth that is bearish for consumption.

- Consumer confidence is sharply down and close to levels we have not seen since the two 1970s stagflation episodes.

- Now the last factor – job generation – that was supporting consumption in spite of the headwinds described above is faltering: employment in the private sector has fallen for 8 months in a row; and overall employment (including public one) has fallen for 7 months in the row). And other indicators of the labor market suggest persistent and continued weakness.

The 12 negative headwinds described above are significant and persistent while the only positive factor supporting consumption – the $100 billion of tax rebates – was temporary to begin with and failed to boost consumption even over the horizon (through all of Q3 of 2008) over which it was supposed to have an effect: consumption started to fall in real terms already in the latter part of Q2 (in June of 2008). And with consumption being 70% of aggregate demand the effect of such a fall in consumption (until at least Q2 of 2009) on GDP growth will be more severe and persistent.

Thus, expect to see a contraction of GDP in quarterly figures already in Q3 of this year and all the way until the middle of 2009. Since the US recession started in Q1 of this year (based on the five indicators used by the NBER) the 18 month U-shaped recession will be a W-shaped recession given the blip in GDP in Q2 following the tax rebates and an unsustainable improvement in net exports. So we will observe a double-dip W-shaped recession.

The improvement in net exports is not sustainable because the view that the rest of the world would rescue the US from a recession through a boom of US exports is now challenged by two major factors: the US recession is spreading to all of the G7 and almost all of the advanced economies (representing 55% of global GDP); and since US exports are the imports of Europe, Japan, Canada, etc. the fall in these economies will slow down their imports of US goods. Second, the recent strengthening of the US – as the G7 are slumping into a recession – will reduce the improvement of the US trade deficit.

A shopped-out, saving-less and debt-burdened US consumer is now stretched like never before, at its tipping point and starting to falter and contract spending. Since we have not seen a fall in consumption – even for a single quarter – for the last 18 years the effects of this sharp retrenchment of US consumption will be severe and cause a protracted and sharp US recession, at least a 18 months recession rather than the 6 months recession predicted by a delusional economic consensus.

211 Responses to “The Coming US Consumption Bust: 12 Reasons Why the US Consumer is in Serious Trouble and Faltering”

GuestSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 4:16 pm

Speaking of “off-topic”, blogs and other such stuff, there was an enigma that made Microsoft richer (and Mr Gates), quicker. This was the illegal copying and distribution of Microsoft O/S and other software. If it had not been for this phenomena, I wonder where Microsoft would be today? Be careful what one wishes for and don’t discount that which comes your way too easily.Yes, the arguments consisting of the reasons why, present sometimes interesting debate but more oft are slow, historical and boring. The reasons (of this global economic collapse, that comes without any doubt at all) are well known; what the discerning reader / poster avidly seeks are new insights from the belly of the beast; as you all well know, the bowel and all that hangs off it, consists of as many neurological responders as that which is commonly referred to the brain; the latter being that unused portion of the human anatomy, which you learnt about in high school botany while disecting that frog). The course of evolution is, of course:) to raise stomachs to brains; it’s only basic physics really.Ho humPeterJB

mammonSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 4:24 pm

It is obvious from the Professor’s cumulative analysis shows that the Hyperdebt Strategy of the United States is not sustainable from an economic point of view. However, we must incorporate the possible geopolitical factors that may bring foreign money to the United States, even though we are technically not running a fiscally sound budget of any kind. There seems to be a series of geopolitical events emerging in the periphery states:Georgia,Poland,Czech,Moldova,Afghanistan, Pakistan, Thailand, North Korea, Nigeria.The North Koreans feel agrieved by some failure of a promise and are set to rebuild the nuclear structures they destroyed. The Pakistan political situation is fluid and there have be attacks into Waziristan by USspecial forces. NATO seems to be on the attack in Afghanistan. The Russians are getting ready for another cold war. The Central Asian States that are members of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization areless receptive to American Bases. There are more that I will not bore you with. The gist of my argument is that Capital seeks safety and Capital Flight from conflict areas is slowly accumulating. The low yields in treasuries are testament to this. Also look at the UNFAO projections of food shortages for 100 million people in the Underdeveloped Countries. The world is moving towards instability and that creates a definite economic event. We must realize that the size of our military, our strategic control of our continent, and Europe and Japan’s dependence on the American military umbrella are indirect economic factors, that we don’t incorporate into our economic analysis. These are just as important as our Enormous Trade Debt and Humoungos Current Account Deficit. When push comes to shove, the credit crunch takes second position to who can control the Sea Lanes fromthe Persian Gulf to the rest of the World. Whoever controls the access to energy resources controls the financial world indirectly. My point is that the financial world does not exist in a vacuum, and we must acknowledge this.

Mick G.September 3rd, 2008 at 4:34 pm

Add to Roubini’s 12, the uncertainty of an election year, which creates wait ‘n’ see paralysis; plus, the wild card of a war breaking-out in any number of oil-important places, plus the posibility that inflation might not be under control, plus the possibility of large bank or i-bank failure(s). oy vey!

SoftwarengineerSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 4:43 pm

NOT TO WORRYWe’ll just infuse economic stimulus checks again, that will prevent [delay?] the economic collapse.

GloomySeptember 3rd, 2008 at 4:43 pm

Nouriel,Great post. In addition, the torrent of coming bank collapses should really strike fear into the hearts of consumers, decreasing consumption markedly. Nothing seems to capture the imagination of the public quite like a long line at an FDIC closed bank. Plus bank closings will not be orderly as the FDIC doesn’t have the resources to close 700 banks over the next year or two (5-10 banks per week).

GuestSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 4:57 pm

Speaking of the modern day genius of advanced mathematics, those authors and masters of the algorithms that scam consumers in their telco and broadband bills, priests that run Physics in superstition and creative dogma, bullsh&%, ghosts out of bottles, spirits, binge drinking and seat sniffers, and the myth that all those such persons and their delusions about Wall Street and Hedge Funds – er, what was that one that Greenspan bailed? More PhD’s than any other organization? – we, of course, we must bail them out (with public funds).. and other related nausea: (“insanity laughs the loudest”) LOL”New York-based Ospraie told investors yesterday it will close its biggest hedge fund after losing 38.6 percent this year on bad bets on commodity stocks. Holdings in natural gas-related companies made up almost a fifth of Ospraie’s investments at the end of June, before the commodity’s price dropped 41 percent.”@ Mish”bad bets”???????????? Oh dear.Now what about this incompetence thingy, leaving stupidity out for the moment.US lost in Iraq, in Afghanistan, Georgia, well, hell, the rest of the World… more US ships steaming to Georgia under the admirable (pun intended) guidance (ho ho ho) of that bunker creeping megalomaniac, big dick… add – US total economic collapse anytime in the next few weeks – denial raging across the World as those of the Exxon Valdez grasping at the free smokes continue to row their Nation (that which once was) to nowhere in lulu land.Expect the Dow to rise tomorrow folks…Its a joke:-) and its on ————> YouLOLHo hum (indeed)PeterJB

GuestSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 5:04 pm

“Hyperdebt Strategy of the United States”With absolute respect for your post I must take task and exception with the term “Strategy” you used in the context of the above extract. How can stupid have ‘Strategy’? Sorry, this term is incorrectly used and positioned here, immho, as is evidenced… shrieks of laughter (SOL) and no cigar.;-)>Ho humPeterJB

GuestSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 5:12 pm

Now we can talk of incompetence:”Russia becomes the 8th largest holder of United States public debt.Russia has moved into 8th position in the list of holder of US Public debt according to Russia’s Finance magazine. Russian holdings of U.S. Public debt total $65.3 Billion, or approximately 2.5% of American Public debt.First and second positions belong to Japan and China with holdings of $583 Billion and $503 Billion respectively. Other nations and groupings with represented in the ten largest holders of American public debt include the United kingdom, oil exporting nations (as a group), Brazil, Caribbean banking centres (as a group), Luxemburg, Hong Kong (separate from China) and Norway. “http://www.russiatoday.com/business/news/29810Of course this item comes from Russia so you are directed not to read anything into it:Ho hum SOLPeterJB

carmelusSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 5:12 pm

The recession is here but I think the aftermath is taken as granted, but the us gdp growth will be very under potential as the debt burden will have to be unwind for many years as creditors will be reluctant to lend to a country that looks like a banana republic.

AnonymousSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 5:19 pm

I agree with mostly everything the Prof says, so can someone explain the amazing recent strength of the retailers if the US consumer is in such trouble? Look at the charts of WMT, TGT, HD and the RTH. Even Sears (SHLD) is strong! These chart patterns do not indicate that this country is weak in any way.Anyone have answers for this?thanks

GuestSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 5:24 pm

Written by mammon on 2008-09-03 16:24:26″The gist of my argument is that Capital seeks safety and Capital Flight from conflict areas is slowly accumulating.”I agree with your comment. If my preferred candidate Obama should win and help bring peace and a working relationship with a better part of our world, the dollar would no longer have this flight to safety.My point is I see no good outcome.Also,price to earnings ratios of U.S. stocks has risen to more than 25. When will market participants react?hlowe

Uncle Billy's Moving To AntibesSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 6:37 pm

Using Prof. Roubini as my baseline is englightening, because I’ve become even more bearish than him. Let’s just cut to the chase: 20 years of ice-caps melting, Avian Flu, Global Depression, Warfare & Genocides, proliferation of organized crime — in other words, just more of the same.

mammonSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 6:49 pm

@ guest 17:04:55 todayThere is a reason I stated Hyperdebt Strategy. Secretary of the Treasury Rubin began to perceive the famous “glut of savings” that was caused by the Central Bank accumulation of dollar reserves after Asian Crisis and figured that this could be channeled to the U.S. for productive use.The problem is that it was not channeled for productivity and was wasted on financial speculationin inflated assets. Greenspan also stated that the “glut of savings” was a cause of the money flow into treasuries and GSE debt. Just because a strategy caused unintended consequences does not mean it is not a strategy.I do agree that it was a foreseeable consequence that the financial Masters of the Universe would pounce on the glut of savings and try to corner the Mortgage Market of Securitization that used to be the realm of the Savings and Loan Industry. They took the idea to the ultimate unregulated extreme, and here we are sitting on the largest Ponzi pyramid in history!@guest 17:24:01You caught the essence of my comment! This World Instability is a nighmare and a Dollar Crisis would also be a nightmare. We are now in a “fork in the road” with no good destinations.

AnonymousSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 7:17 pm

Any idea about commercial real estate? I am holding the ultra short real estate and getting crushed in the short term. Any idea of if I am right waaay too early or just dead wrong?

AnonymousSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 7:42 pm

Anonymous on 2008-09-03 19:17:30 – Any idea about commercial real estate? I am holding the ultra short real estate and getting crushed in the short term. Any idea of if I am right waaay too early or just dead wrong?I think it fair to say as a whole, this group (we) did not consider the ferocity with which the status quo would hang on by it finger nails. You name it: stock market, bond market, precious metals, and just a dribble of bank failures. But just wait for a couple more months. After the election, my guess (for what it’s worth) is that the damn will burst.

PhilTSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 8:13 pm

@ Mick G. on 2008-09-03 16:34:21

Add to Roubini’s 12, the uncertainty of an election year, which creates wait ‘n’ see paralysis; plus, the wild card of a war breaking-out in any number of oil-important places, plus the posibility that inflation might not be under control, plus the possibility of large bank or i-bank failure(s). oy veh

Click 4 article: U.S. offers $1 billion to bolster Georgia If not functional => http://iht.com/articles/2008/09/03/europe/cheney.phpBest...

GuestSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 8:23 pm

anon above,if i told you, youre going to lose 30-60% of your investment value and that the probability of the outcome is about 80-90%, plus the time to recover the losses will take at least 5 years, what would you do?thats why the rumours (e.g.Lehman) are so effective, its not like they carry much weigh, its just what people wanna hear..

farmboySeptember 3rd, 2008 at 9:42 pm

Anonymous on 2008-09-03 19:17:30 – Any idea about commercial real estate? I am holding the ultra short real estate and getting crushed in the short term. Any idea of if I am right waaay too early or just dead wrong?I am on the other side of that trade. I guess I am stupid for picking up some of the REIT’s at a 13% dividend.Some of the low interest rates are starting to trickle through. Recently got a 4% 6 year loan for solar panels (Hat Tip Medic). And it wasn’t part of a state or federal loan program. Just an unsubsidized loan from a major bank.

GuestSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 9:46 pm

Why believe your LYING eyeshttp://wakeupfromyourslumber.blogspot.com/2006/02/why-believe-your-lying-eye_113912330468729378.htmlWhen you can believe the LYING media, instead.

The nation’s unemployment rate dropped to a 4 1/2 year low [and] employees’ average hourly earnings climbed to $16.41 in January, up 0.4 percent from December.Are these people on crack? Don’t they read the news?* Ford lays off 25,000,* Kraft cuts 8000 jobs,* Dell hires 5000 in India,* GM trims $4B from budget,* Visteon shifts resources offshore,* OfficeMax closes 110 stores,* Toys R Us closes 75 stores, lays off 3000And this list is by no means exhaustive!Either these people are hopelessly stupid, or they think that WE are.”The economy fired on all cylinders in January,” said economist Sung Won Sohn, president of Hanmi Bank.”There’s no question we’re getting back to better days for job creation,” said Ken Mayland, economist at ClearView Economics.Payrolls grew by 193,000 in January, up from 140,000 in December.Yeah, right. Tell that to the 24,175 applicants who were turned down by Wal-Mart last Friday!

The amount of job applications at Wal-Mart is referred to here, among other places:Wal-Mart gets 25,000 applications for Evergreen Park storehttp://www.chicagobusiness.com/cgi-bin/news.pl?id=19286

The new Wal-Mart Stores Inc. location opening Friday in suburban Evergreen Park received a record 25,000 applications for 325 positions, the highest for any one location in the retailer’s history, a company official says.

Above article attempts to spin the large amount of job applications to something positive but I think it is indicative of the sad state of the U.S. economy rather than the greatness of Wal-Mart as an employer.

GuestSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 10:46 pm

guest 2008-09-03 22:28:44,a lot of other stocks are in YoYo mode too…relax.. anyway why quote MBI and ABK, better mention Bearstearn

AnonymousSeptember 3rd, 2008 at 11:19 pm

Regarding the 25K applications to the Evergreen Walmart near Chicago, the article contiues with: “That incredible number of applications shows the community thinks Wal-Mart is a great place to work,” Mr. Donath (area Manger) says.” I doubt the “community” thinks Walmart is a great place to work, just that it’s becoming the ONLY place to work.

StuartSeptember 4th, 2008 at 12:02 am

Wait for this Friday. The birth/death model adjustment will likely blow you away, well over 100K added. Result, it’s that time of the year just before elections that yes, jobs will be materially higher, possibly close to 0 lost. With the recent GDP figures amongst many others, I really am expecting this. It seems the pattern these days. Very much aware that sounds incredibly cynical, yet the more counter-intuitive the figure is, the higher the probability is of actually seeing it in the headlines. Add to this, a drop in the unemployment rate. Watch for it.

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 4:41 am

I haven’t mentioned fraud yet, have I?:From the BBC: “Two former Credit Suisse bankers have been charged with fraud for allegedly deceiving clients over the value of debt tied to sub-prime mortgages. Julian Solov and Eric Butler are accused of selling “auction-rate securities” on the pretense they were as safe and risk-free as cash.In reality, they were backed by high-risk investments and generated large commission payments for the duo.”Did you also note that recent IMF loan to Georgia? Now, IMF loans usually take a few years to organize (so that everyone in the loop er, almost everybody, gets his / her cut), yet this one seemed to take butt a few days! Guess its good having neocons in places of influence?Never mind George will pardon them.ho humPeterJB

QUODD.comSeptember 4th, 2008 at 7:24 am

If the consumer is on his deathbed, please explain the amazing strength of the retailing stocks.I really don’t understand.(look at RTH, WMT, TGT, HD, SHLD, etc…)

StuartSeptember 4th, 2008 at 7:36 am

When analyzing retailing stocks, you need to distinguish staples vs discretionary items. Walmart for example derives a tremendous amount of its profit from food and gasoline sales. As well one further needs to separate (a) impact of foreign exchange (b) domestic vs international business. Too often these distinctions are missed in the headlines. Whether deliberate, because it’s not “pumpity” news or whether by shear laziness is a matter of conjecture.

randySeptember 4th, 2008 at 8:18 am

Please forgive me. I agree with all NR has said here which he has said many times both here and in the media. What I want to know is ……is it really going to matter to the markets???? So far, it has not……TPTB have done very creative things to keep the markets from tanking more than a token few hundred points MAX! Then, they pump the media from multiple directions to goose things back up. Unless we have a cataclysmic event that shakes peoples mindset, I think this will continue for years. Remember, TPTB have shown they will do whatever it takes to keep the markets from tanking.NR keeps saying this will happen and that will happen. well. what if TPTB change the rules of reporting (like they have done in the past). The average investor will never know the truth.I would like to see what NR has to say about these things from this point of view.

randySeptember 4th, 2008 at 8:55 am

I just read that Bill Gross at PIMCO says the US gov should “open it’s balance sheet” and buy assets that private investors don’t want. Is this guy on crack? Why in the world would the USG want to do that?Maybe it’s so PIMCO and Bill Gross don’t lose their asses due to their huge position in F&F bonds. Why is it that this guy gets a full page on Bloomberg to tout his line of BS and Karl Denninger over at market-ticker can’t get one paragraph? The MSM is not fair. Bubblevision again…..feed the sheeple. I’m sick of it.

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 9:13 am

what ever happened to separation of state and church?http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080903/ap_on_el_pr/cvn_palin_iraq_warUnited States sent troops to fight in the Iraq war on a “task that is from God.”hope American will not be so XXX by voting for Republican candidates. This is nuts. America will be doomed if church extremists are elected into office.

randySeptember 4th, 2008 at 9:24 am

don’t get me wrong. I’m sure we are all worried about our financial position. I just don’t think Gross should get the Bloomberg soapbox to spout off unless others with dissenting views get the same. It seems everyone is trying to keep the bubble inflated instead of doing what is right. Let the “free” markets deal with it.

randySeptember 4th, 2008 at 9:30 am

that means bear stearns…..should have failed…If they were worth it..someone would have bought them………..F&F shit or get off the pot. are they backed by the USG or are they private enterprises. You can’t have both without getting where we are now. Concerning the chinese, japanese, and russian investments in F&F bonds, let ‘em fail. They bought ‘em knowing they weren’t covered by the USG. Shit happens. Yes, there is going to be some financial pain……However, because of all crap that the fed and treasury have pulled in the past year, we are going to suffer a biiger meltdown sometime in the future. I don’t know when. I guess it might just be a massive devaluation of the dollar exercise. I don’t know.

randySeptember 4th, 2008 at 9:32 am

I’m currently reading the book “the creature from Jekyll Island” about the creation of the federal reserve. It is a very interesting read and I will post a summary when I’m through. It’s 600 pages and I’m half way there…..:>

Little SaverSeptember 4th, 2008 at 9:46 am

Written by Guest on 2008-09-04 09:37:32US stocks in free-fall!Don’t worry, must be God’s will if we may believe the Palin-Bush types. He must have some supreme purpose with this fall, perhaps a thorough cleansing of the politico-economical system?:)

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 9:58 am

Standard & Poor’s announced yesterday that the spread — or the difference between the rate for a Treasury instrument and a corporate bond of equivalent maturity — on speculative-grade bonds widened to 796 basis points, outside the 775 to 790 basis point range these issues have traded within for most of the year.Signs used to advertise additional details on for sale signs are seen as Jacques Brevery puts out signs May 27, 2008 in Miami, Florida.Spreads on securities rated triple C, the bottom rung of the credit-rating ladder, just hit a five-year high. The speculative-bond spread, according to Diane Vazza, head of global fixed income research at Standard & Poor’s, is up from 757 basis points at the end of July and 366 basis points a year ago.Meanwhile, spreads on investment-grade debt have also widened to 283 basis points, 88% higher than the five-year moving average and 39% above the beginning-year level. The spread on investment-grade debt through August was 272 basis points, versus 165 basis points in the year-earlier period.Spreads are important because they indicate risk: The wider the spread, the more risk associated with the corporate bond, and the costlier it is for companies to issue debt. Rising credit spreads are just as damaging to corporate America as higher taxes, and are confounding efforts by regulators to supply liquidity to banks and borrowers.

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 10:03 am

Looks like 11,300 is the “no go” zone for the Dow. Watch it carefully-if it gives, this could be a Dow down 400 day!

FFSeptember 4th, 2008 at 10:21 am

Looks like a global sell-off in everything with money going into the USD (and Treasuries) and the YEN! Are the boys still intervening in the currencies?

PhilTSeptember 4th, 2008 at 11:15 am

@randy on 2008-09-04 09:30:16

that means bear stearns…..should have failed…If they were worth it..someone would have bought them…

Towards your point as well as other postings with the same frustration, this article was published on Aug. 28, 2008. The Bear Stearns issue is alluded to near the end, but the first part of the article concerning the currency and metals markets is also relevant to posts in previous threads.From MISH: Conspiracy Theory PsychologyOR => http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2008/08/conspiracy-theory-psychology.htmlBest

MedicSeptember 4th, 2008 at 12:14 pm

Professor,Great post. You are correct in your call for the demise of the US consumer. I have the fortune of working with people in all income brackets and here is what I hear them talking about on a daily basis:- The lowest earners are tapped out. Not only do they not have money for things they don’t need, they have difficulty buying groceries. One co-worker has now become a borrower of cash on a regular basis from other employees. She borrowed $20 from me not long ago for gas money to get home after work. She is among the worst off – she’s stressed, broke and depressed. She and her family are in serious trouble.- The middle earners have cut back. They have invested in pellet stoves, wood stoves and various other alternatives for heat this year. Some have ceased investing in retirement plans to keep more cash in their pockets. Many have made cuts in entertainment spending, dining out and frivolous purchases. For now, just the necessities are being bought.- The high earners are different. While some have made adjustments to their lifestyles, many have thus far been immune to the pain. They have no idea about people who are struggling at the bottom. A few of the docs I work with are still taking several expensive vacations, but they have cut back on length of stay. That’s their impact though – so far. Prices at the pump have not moved the high end folks to buy smaller cars, nor have many of them jumped into alternative energies. Many are looking, but not in a hurry to change anything just yet. These are the folks who still have access to credit.All of the above categories will be affected by the demise of the credit industry.The high earners who have access to easy / cheap credit will have to become more creative like those below them. They had better have money on hand, or they will become just like the rest of us. The middle earners know they can cut more, but have some idea left of a lifestyle they want and have been reluctant to give it up completely. The low end folks will be the ones who bear the largest painful brunt of this disaster.The talking heads can bloviate all they want. I am down here, knee deep in reality, and I can see what is happening. The view from down here is very different than the view they see. I doubt they talk to the little people, so for them, life isn’t really that bad…….yet.

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 12:27 pm

It is all about oil! Oil has caused the high food prices and higher inflation. Higher inflation will lead to lower p/es on the stock market. Headline inflation is rising but core inflation is low. What does this mean? RAISES ARE NOT MATCHING PRICE INCREASES! I got out of the S&P at 1390 on 4/18 simply because oil was at an astronomical $118!Now S&P is at 1248 and oil is a still at a high $108!

FFSeptember 4th, 2008 at 1:29 pm

Why is the USD (and Yen) showing such strength today? One would think the dollar would weaken with such a large market sell-off. Flight-to-quality? LOL.

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 1:38 pm

Nouriel hasn’t justified his claim for US improvement after a “recession”. How does Nouriel reconcile his timeline for the erosion of BW2 with a double-dip “recovery”? This consumption contraction is near term but inflation a persistent and longer term problem.The collapse of dollar hegemony will be devastating blow. Energy constraints and financial chaos will weaken the US position and eventually the US military. Nouriel does not believe US can sustain its reach for more than a “couple decades”, but does he expect China, Russia, Venezuela, Iraq, Iran, etc. to wait that long?So either his position on US recovery is incoherent or he needs to fill in more details.Darkie

randySeptember 4th, 2008 at 2:04 pm

@ guest:..Thanks for the rudent baer post about Marc Faber’s comments. good one@ PhilT: Thanks…I read Mish at Global econ everyday. I don’t agree with him that the markets are not being manipulated. I thin they are.Thanks for all the tips/ideas. Now, why is the fed letting the market drop +300 today? where is the PPT? will they show up about 3:30?If the market drops > 500 points today, I’ll begin to believe we might see the crash everyone has been predicting.

AlessandroSeptember 4th, 2008 at 2:13 pm

@randyMish doesn’t say markets are not manipulated, all he says is that real manipulation is done in the open: “surprise” rate cuts, “surprise” naked short bans, Ponzi scheme after Ponzi scheme organized by the government (SuperSIV, alphabet soup FED facilities, stimulus checks, etc.). Manipulation is massive and is there for everyone to see.

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 2:37 pm

“The one longer-term trend Faber appears to have the most confidence in is the “long gold/short the DJIA” trade that has been working, despite the recent pullback, since 2001. Over the intermediate term he is a looking for what can be described as nothing less than a US stock market crash, perhaps by the end of this year.”

GloomySeptember 4th, 2008 at 2:44 pm

THE SINKING SHIPSept. 4 (Bloomberg) — The U.S. government needs to start using more of its money to support markets to stem a burgeoning “financial tsunami,” according to Bill Gross, manager of the world’s biggest bond fund.That’s right throw some more lead on that (soon to resume) sinking ship, the US dollar. Gross is looking for a bailout for his bond funds, and he and the rest of the crowd with their hands out will get what they want. But be careful what you ask for, you might get it. He and the rest will get their requested bailouts and our countries currency will appropriately sink in the process as we enter the netherworld called hyperinflation. Down we go, down we go….

GLOOMYSeptember 4th, 2008 at 2:52 pm

DON’T YOU JUST WONDER WHY?A Market Decline in Search of a ReasonBy MICHAEL M. GRYNBAUMStocks on Wall Street plunged on Thursday, but few investors seemed to settle on one reason.A broad sell-off sent the Dow Jones industrial average down about 300 points in late afternoon trading — the index’s worst performance since June — hours after the government reported that the number of Americans filing for unemployment benefits unexpectedly rose last week.But the sharpest declines came nearly two hours after that report was released, a lag that rarely occurs in today’s overheated financial world. The other financial news of the day, including a $2.50 drop in the price of oil, would usually cheer investors. So what gives?“I’m trying to answer the same question,” Steve Sachs, who directs trading at Rydex Investments, said.http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/05/business/economy/05stox.html?_r=1&partner=rssyahoo&emc=rss&pagewanted=print&oref=slogin

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 3:04 pm

First the Asians blackmail Treasury to backstop Fhoney & Freaky…Then Pimco’s Gross blackmails for add’l banking system bailouts…Strong hands to take from weak hands. Weak hands? taxpayers, retail investors, small fry. Heart of the Republic to be ripped out to feed the hyenas and ravens of Wall Street. Just watch! Financial tsunami!! — one way or the other it is coming. Large bank failures or taxpayer revolts…it is gonna get ugly before it gets remarkably bleak.http://www.cnbc.com/id/26547623

GLOOMYSeptember 4th, 2008 at 3:06 pm

MORE ON GROSS FROM NAKED CAPITALISM”The US simply does not have the resources to perform a rescue operation on the scale Gross envisions. If we were to attempt it, the scale of borrowing required would push Treasury yields up, undermining (more likely, more than completely reversing) whatever benefit there was from spread reduction. We’ve already seen a some interventions not producing some of the hoped-for benefits. The Fed had clearly hoped that its pushing down of the short end of the yield curve would provide some relief to fixed mortgage rates. Instead, they’ve gone up.”http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2008/09/bill-gross-says-nothing-is-going-up-so.htmlI disagree on one point. The US may not have the resources, but we are going to do it anyway, because not doing it would be political suicide for TPTB. Hyperinflation is coming. Depend on it.http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2008/09/bill-gross-says-nothing-is-going-up-so.html

PhilTSeptember 4th, 2008 at 3:17 pm

@randy on 2008-09-04 14:04:39I think that Alessandro has interpreted MISH precisely. For the sake of clarity, I believe that in his attempt to explain the Psychology of Conspiracy Theory, MISH has made the case that many people confuse conspiracy for manipulation. The JPM/BSC example, allows MISH to further implicated denial and subsequent need for blame in the whole warped process.Here is an excerpt:Of course there are conspiracies and manipulations. I have listed many of them.Blatant Manipulations* Term Auction Facility TAF* Primary Dealer Credit Facility (PFCF)* Term Securities Lending Facility (TSLF)* SEC rule changes options expiration week* Selective enforcement of naked shorting rules* Discount window changes in options expiration week* Shotgun marriages arranged by the Fed* The bailout of JPMorgan / Bear Stearns…So, people take credit for everything that goes right, regardless of how lucky they might have been, while absolving themselves of blame for everything that goes wrong, no matter how convoluted a theory it takes to do so.Cheers!

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 3:20 pm

AHhh, now this is the kinda headline that will make people scream! FoxNews:Breaking News >> Dow Plummets 345 Points On Disappointing Economic News

PhilTSeptember 4th, 2008 at 3:22 pm

(cont’d) from MISH

Thus, Bear Stearns is an example of an outright conspiracy, with public perception twisted a complete 180 degrees from reality! The Bears Stearns manipulation happened in plain sight and people still got it wrong as to what happened and why.

PhilTSeptember 4th, 2008 at 3:37 pm

@Medic on 2008-09-04 12:14:32… The high earners are different. While some have made adjustments to their lifestyles, many have thus far been immune to the pain…Can you please supply your quantitative definition of high earner?Looking forward…

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 3:38 pm

Speaking of “Be Careful What You Wish For”BY CHRIS PUPLAVAFor those interested in the dollar/precious.http://www.financialsense.com/Market/wrapup.htm“The US dollar has been in a secular bear market since 2002 and we are currently seeing a cyclical bull market counter trend bounce as the rest of the global economies recouple with the US, which is likely being discounted in the currency markets currently. As foreign central banks bring down their interest rates they will near the end point of their easing as our central bank did earlier this year. The point when foreign central banks end their easing programs and our Federal Reserve may even raise interest rates to combat inflation will likely be discounted in advance in the currency markets, and mark the next leg down in the secular dollar bear market.”

devils advocateSeptember 4th, 2008 at 4:11 pm

Bill Gross is one of the most respected financial experts in the worldChina is buying USA bonds – so what’s left?Keep it simple:the US Government buys stocks and real estate and F and F and Banks Too Big To Failthe guaranteed support of the US Govt will obviate the need to do soall assets will bottom and rise!

steveSeptember 4th, 2008 at 4:36 pm

pretty clear that you better have your selling shoes on, regardless of what asset you are talking about. bull moves in $ and treasuries may take longer than we think. the 30 year has been carving out a distribution top for 5 years now. once it’s over, it’ll really be OVER!

GloomySeptember 4th, 2008 at 4:37 pm

BANK CHECKMATE?This may have been the biggest bomb of the day. Maybe the time has finally come when banks will no longer be able to find money. Supportive of this notion is the Wells Fargo debt offering that was done today at over 10%.”Pimco’s legendary bond investor Bill Gross said during “Street Signs” Thursday that his firm would be staying out of any and all bank offerings for the foreseeable future.Banks the world over have raised $400 billion in capital, Gross said, and may need to raise much more. The problem, though, as yesterday’s $1.5 billion preferred offering at Wells Fargo [WFC 29.67 -1.34 (-4.32%) ] showed, is that the institutional buyers are full, leaving only small investors to pick up the slack.As Gross said, “There’s only so many billion and a half small investor bank capital deals that can be done from this point forward.”So if Fannie Mae [FNM 6.42 -0.90 (-12.3%) ], Freddie Mac [FRE 4.95 -0.43 (-7.99%) ], Citigroup [C 18.30 -1.31 (-6.68%) ] and Merrill Lynch hold offerings to raise capital, Gross and Pimco will be sitting them out.This puts Henry Paulson and the Treasury Department in position to have to act. Washington has been holding on any kind of bailout, hoping that buyers like Gross will keep struggling banks afloat. But by refusing to take part, Gross, the biggest bond buyer in the world, is in effect calling the Treasury’s bluff.”http://www.cnbc.com/id/26547623

MedicSeptember 4th, 2008 at 5:32 pm

@ Phil T;I include mainly the physicians in this category – and bear in mind that many of them have spouses who are also physicians or nurses – but our average base pay is close to $150K. Throw in a nurse’s wage and a little OT and the range is $200-$300K which is excellent money here. Some have adjusted their expenditures, but not out of necessity.

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 5:51 pm

Did I mention stupid?It seems that big dick (cheney) has a strategy a’fore he leaves office and that is total middle east, south-west Asian and sub-continent instability with what he t’inks is russia on its back foot. Add to this multi-big-time telco mergers(re) blessed by alfred e pneumen:) of what-me-worry fame and fotune and you septics as well as we foreinors, appear to be, in. for some turbulent times; drones abound – keep you battery out of your handphone and dig deep into the earth as you ain’t invited to thum big-deep-bunkers of the elite (ensuring the continuance of civilization) – Ho ho ho – SOL.Now big-dick thinks russia’s credibility at stake but I say, ‘big dick, you and your lot have the proven integrity of a fleet of vegetarian sharks and wethinks that Mr. Putin has more integrity, credibility, prowess, skills in the various spectrum of the socio-economic arenas than you lots of burnt out rats ever considered possible’.Now McCain lady running mate obviously talks to God too, just like George – Wow, the USA is now the favoured race – how convenient. Did the septics misplace the Semitics of Israel and thereabouts – then thar ‘chosen folks’? Or, is it just all the same game?Project for the New ‘Merican Century (PNAC) eh? Big dick should have been Pope!SOLHo hummmmm – we are now agoin towards resonance..PeterJB

mammonSeptember 4th, 2008 at 6:23 pm

@guest 2008-09-04 17:51:43SThe last entry is the funniest entry I have ever seen!We need a little humour! Thanks! Very imaginative andactually quite true! You have proven that art(humour) is what makes life worth living. I personally don’t take the world seriously all the time. Your special dialect is endeering!Sometimes you can get away with saying a lot more truth when you use humour! My complements to the artist within.(I am still laughing)

PhilTSeptember 4th, 2008 at 6:52 pm

@MedicThank you for supplying that number. I believe that your post taps on very relevant socio-economic issues, and the following excerpt from your earlier post has inspired the questions that follow:

The high earners who have access to easy / cheap credit will have to become more creative like those below them. They had better have money on hand, or they will become just like the rest of us.

Concerning the high earners for a moment, how leveraged (on average) do you think they are?Are we talking 2-SUV’s for the husband/wife plus 1-2 more for the teenage/college age kids, plus the private school tuition, etc. type of life?{I am not sure of the geographic domain that you are referencing. I assume USA, but not a Tier 1 metropolis.}I am also wondering if the folks that you categorize in the middle earners segment actually have greater positive cash flow than the higher earners, and if access to credit facilities is actually working against the higher earners?Best…

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 7:09 pm

Pete, i agreeweall gonna be burnn soon, only roaches will survive, an i aint refering to insectshttp://www.russiatoday.com/news/news/29904U.S. pushes through radar plans despite opposition in Czech RepublicThe U.S. is to deliver the first funds to the Czech Republic for the construction of its controversial radar base at the end of this month according to reports in Czech media, The radar is to be linked to a missile base planned to be built in Poland. However, the majority of the Czech population remains opposed to the U.S. plan.The country’s Deputy Foreign Minister, Tomas Pojar, will visit the United States shortly to discuss security co-operation.On the 40-year anniversary of the Prague Spring, when communist Warsaw Pact troops rolled their tanks into the Czech Republic to violently suppress the country’s liberalisation, the Czech people are very conscious of the parallels.They regard the U.S. missile base on their territory as yet another invasion by a foreign power.

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 7:16 pm

“What will you guys do if:”A) Obama is elected president : WHY HIM? BUT WE MAY CHANGEB) McCain is elected president: WHY HIM ? BUT WE ARE STABLE

GLOOMYSeptember 4th, 2008 at 7:22 pm

SAY ADIOS TO BRETTON WOODS IIChina’s Central Bank Is Short of CapitalBy KEITH BRADSHERHONG KONG — China’s central bank is in a bind.It has been on a buying binge in the United States over the last seven years, snapping up roughly $1 trillion worth of Treasury bonds and mortgage-backed debt issued by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.Those investments have been declining sharply in value when converted from dollars into the strong yuan, casting a spotlight on the central bank’s tiny capital base. The bank’s capital, just $3.2 billion, has not grown during the buying spree, despite private warnings from the International Monetary Fund.http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/05/business/worldbusiness/05yuan.html?_r=1&partner=rssyahoo&emc=rss&pagewanted=print&oref=slogin

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 7:47 pm

Is there some sort of a multi-government operation going on pushing some currencies up (and some down) and oil down?

StuartSeptember 4th, 2008 at 8:40 pm

Wow. The Chinese really were that gullible and stupid. They’re only figuring this out now??http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/05/business/worldbusiness/05yuan.html?_r=3&oref=slogin&ref=business&pagewanted=all&oref=slogin

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 8:47 pm

Stuart,they are telling US they want out (gotta read between the line).. IT IS OVER…of course they knew the impact, they were willing to participate as long as it benefitted themNow the joyride is about to end

MedicSeptember 4th, 2008 at 9:19 pm

@ Phil T;The average higher income folks are about what you have assumed – perhaps for different reasons though. One physician I know has nearly $200K in student loans and another owns three homes in another state that may soon become “jingle mail” homes. Yet another is a staunch conservative and has money in the bank, owns his home and is thoughtful about expenditures.As for the middle folks (of which I am one), cash flow is tight. I have one vehicle I own and one I make payments on, some debt and a reasonable mortgage, but my wife and I had another conversation tonight about where we can cut to save some money. We have already stopped dining out, buying things we don’t absolutely need and we are driving MUCH less than we used to in order to save on gas.We do live in the Sates – in Maine.

PhilTSeptember 4th, 2008 at 9:48 pm

@ MedicThanks for your candid reply. The demographic that was/is in my mind was articulated well by Prof./Dr. Roubini in July => American Un-Beauty: The Crisis of the Suburbian (McMansions and Gas-Guzzling SUVs) Way of Life :When I read your initial post in this thread combined with other sentiments and observations that have been offered here and in previous threads, I wonder about the behaviors and lifestyles that a significant number of people/families/consumers do not want to or see the need to scale down or outright abandon, and what the total economic impact of that existence will be on those who do not/have not engaged in this exuberance/delusion.There have been many (valid) comments about Wall Street being the bastion of denial/hubris/etc. It seems that this behavior is not exclusive to Wall Street. Which came first…?I hope that Prof./Dr. Roubini finds this to be a point worth evaluating in a future post.Be well …

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 10:06 pm

@Guest on 2008-09-04 19:47:40From Chuck Butler in the Daily Pfennig a few days back:”Finance officials form the U.S., Japan and Europe, in mid-march drew up plans to strengthen the dollar following troubles at Bear Stearns.” The story which originally appeared in Nikkei English News went on to report that: “the intervention designed by the U.S. Treasury Dept. Japan’s Finance Ministry and the European Central Bank, called for the central banks to purchase dollars and sell euros and yen, with Japan providing the yen needed for the currency swap if the greenback’s value dropped significantly.The three groups, which considered making an emergency statement through G-7, did not stipulate a specific exchange rate for the potential intervention, nor did they detail the amount of money to be used. So… Now we know! There was no way the dollar turned on a dime like that without something like this happening… The fundamentals are so anti-dollar strength, and yet the dollar was gaining strength… Well, we know that the Bank of Japan has a treasure chest of yen that they have collected over the years… And they have an even bigger treasure chest of dollars (most of it held in dollar denominated Treasuries), but now they have even more dollars! I bet they are just happy as pigs in slop to own all these dollars!”

GuestSeptember 4th, 2008 at 11:28 pm

Randy: “Bill Gross is more worried about his financial position that anything else IMHO.”No kidding. There was a time when it was worthwhile to read what Bill Gross had to say. That time is gone. Now all he’s doing is talking his own book. And if that totally screws up America – apparently he doesn’t care.Comment: “Looks like a global sell-off in everything with money going into the USD (and Treasuries) and the YEN! Are the boys still intervening in the currencies?”Foreign investors are dumping Fannie and Freddie, and buying US Treasuries. Fannie and Freddie are doomed, and countries that invested billions in their bonds will lose their shirts. By the way – that’s also part of the motive for the intervention to boost the dollar. If the dollar sinks and the GSE bonds tank, then countries like China take enormous losses. So it’s a game they’re playing.Trouble is … the central banks are now a long way behind the curve. They can’t stop the system from going insolvent.PeteCA

AchesonSeptember 4th, 2008 at 11:56 pm

Yep-the American consumer will stop spending exactly when it can’t find a credit card to charge it on. Seems “on the ground” that it’s starting to happen. Once everyone is completely maxed out, they will spend nothing. The idea of actually and finally paying for anything has been largely erased from the American mentality. Bon temps roulez

JLCSeptember 5th, 2008 at 1:16 am

@ GLOOMY on 2008-09-04 19:22:10Thank you very much for that link. Remember MA’s cryptic post a while back about trouble brewing in a “high savings” society that was going to get very ugly?Sounds like there is big trouble in China. The central bank needs capital? The stock market has done a cliff-dive. Their economic indicators are suddenly worsening. This is going to get interesting.Regarding the possibility of them dumping Treasuries or agencies in favor of higher yielding assets I think they are on the horns of dilemma. They have to do it very slowly and quietly or they put their export based economy and remaining dollar holdings in jeopardy. Besides, where else are they going to put their money? Stocks? Real Estate? Wealth is being destroyed left and right. In my opinion there is no true safe haven. However, I would enjoy it very much if they decided to dump dollars for gold . . .Regarding the strong moves in the dollar and yen: there is a lot of deleveraging going on. The yen carry trade is unwinding again – investors (hedge funds) who borrowed yen at insanely low interest rates (and dollars also at low interest rates) to invest in higher yielding stocks or currencies are unwinding their trades. They are selling their FX, commodities, and stocks and buying Yen (and dollars) in order to unwind the trades. When the stock market heads north again the Yen will weaken and give way to the underlying strong dollar momentum.It is interesting that the Swiss Franc has not strengthened along with the Yen, as has been the recent correlation.

P1AQLSeptember 5th, 2008 at 1:28 am

randy on 2008-09-04 08:55:34 asked:

Why is it that this guy gets a full page on Bloomberg to tout his line of BS and Karl Denninger over at market-ticker can’t get one paragraph?

Give Bill some credit. He’s trying to help you NOT cut off your own nose.It’s great to get Bill’s vote on RTC II (like Larry and I’ve been asking for) and sad to see that Hank is waffling. He should have been asking lots of quesions to the GSEC’s shareholders by last weekend and prevented the panic sell-off.HANK, WHAT ARE YOU THINKING? The dollar has bottomed as I predicted. The Gold and oil specs are licking their wounds with the 20% sell-off.As I said to to Rich H, May the USD be with you! AND, Hope you got yourself an ARM just like Greenspan recommended. It’s the life jacket that you’ll need to fight the black swan of deflation. Otherwise, see you on the street as I pass you by in my ‘Alpha’ romeo that Europe will auction off for the price of a Nano!Cheers to USA! Cheers to Alpha! Cheers to the USD!Print First Ask Questions Later (P1AQL).

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 1:29 am

well makes you wonder aint it…with the colossus problem we are facing now, we are still not (OFFICIALLY) in a recessionwhy the heck was it so much easier to get into 1 previouslyyou guys have wondered about that? is it taboo to discuss??

P1AQLSeptember 5th, 2008 at 1:34 am

GLOOMY on 2008-09-04 19:22:10 wrote:

The bank’s capital, just $3.2 billion, has not grown during the buying spree, despite private warnings from the International Monetary Fund.

@Gloomy, don’t worry, the USD reserves will come into play. This is going according to script. The merchantilist Chinese will fight Renminbi appreciation tooth and nail to ward off a revolution – they’re good at that. This means the GD will appear at your favorite ‘Bad’ in Europe. Europeans doubtless will enjoy the spa, since they’ve already lost their shirt! Europe is toast.Best,P1AQL.

Little SaverSeptember 5th, 2008 at 2:16 am

Written by P1AQL on 2008-09-05 01:34:42:Europe is toast.Some in Europe may be toast like those Alpha buyers that mimicked the reckless American consumer behavior as described above in “the 12 Reasons Why the US Consumer is in Serious Trouble and Faltering”.The others are doing rather well. Perhaps, some of them will have to change from Mercedes-Benz to one of the many fuel-efficient cars available in Europ, but that wouldn’t be a big problem, I guess. Not so many foreclosures in Europe due to less reckless consumption behavior. Many of them prefer a modest joy of living above the meaningless shop till you drop mentality that an obtrusive industry is trying to feed them up with. Less debt slaves in Europe, I think. Most of them will continue enjoying their modest morning toast without worries about the Wall Street greed and failure.

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 3:07 am

hah, BBC science segment indirectly explainswhy the stock market has not crashi like this quote the most LOLOn the deck of the Estonia ferry, which sank in the Baltic Sea in 1994, one man smoked a cigarette. Others sat in groups, doing nothing, as the water surged onto the ship.http://news.bbc.co.uk/today/hi/today/newsid_7575000/7575407.stmFighting for survivalBy Amanda RipleyAuthor of The Unthinkable: Who Survives When Disaster Strikes – and Whyexcerpt;Period of disbeliefOur disaster personalities are not, in fact, anything like our normal personalities. Strong men can wilt, and neurotic women can suddenly become bold and purposeful. Everything changes.We know that in all kinds of disaster, from ship wrecks to burning buildings, the brain tends to go through three phases: denial, deliberation and the decisive moment.The first phase may be the most important one to know about in advance. Survivors of fires, terrorist attacks and shipwrecks have all told me how incredibly powerful this period of disbelief can be.On the deck of the Estonia ferry, which sank in the Baltic Sea in 1994, one man smoked a cigarette. Others sat in groups, doing nothing, as the water surged onto the ship.The most common response in most disasters is not panic, but rather the opposite.Most of the people who died on 9/11 had no chance of survivingOur first instinct is to normalize the situation – to come up with wildly creative and reassuring explanations for why smoke might be creeping across the ceiling or why oxygen masks might have dropped from the airplane ceiling.In the World Trade Center on 11 September 2001, about 1,000 people took the time to shut down their computers before evacuating.On average, people waited six minutes before beginning to leave. Once they entered the stairwell, they descended at the rate of about one minute per floor – twice as long as engineers would have predicted.There are reasonable explanations for why we respond to threats this way, most of them rooted in our evolution.And we can dramatically improve our response and train our brains to do better. But understanding how we actually behave is the first step.Once we know we tend to move in slow motion, we can learn to push through that phase and get out faster. Buildings and planes can be designed to help us understand what is really happening more quickly – and get to an exit.It is time to move past the hackneyed disaster narrative – where we simply gape at the loss and then blame government or God alone for our suffering.It is time to accept that regular people matter, and work intelligently to make ourselves more resilient.

AlessandroSeptember 5th, 2008 at 3:10 am

P1AQL: “The merchantilist Chinese will fight Renminbi appreciation tooth and nail to ward off a revolution – they’re good at that.”What is China economy falters for real? The yuan will not look so strong after all. It might even… fall?And what will the PBoC do in that case? Sell dollar reserves, that is reserve are made for, be sold to prop up a currency.Do you get the base of the dumb USDCNY monetary cycle?Weak USDCNY -> China buys tons of USDCNY -> Chian buys treasuries with dollars -> dollar rates fall -> USDCNY even weaker -> iterateNow look at it in reverse: strong USDCNY -> china sells tons of USDCNY -> China sells Treasuries -> dollar rates shot higher -> USDCNY even stronger -> iterateGuess where the rate of your ARM loan would be headed?

P1AQLSeptember 5th, 2008 at 4:00 am

@Alessandro on 2008-09-05 03:10:09:I am sorry but I didn’t understand. By USDCNY do you mean USD/CNY i.e. 6.8445?http://finance.yahoo.com/currency/convert?amt=1&from=USD&to=CNY&submit=ConvertDoes weak USDCNY mean lower than 6.8445? i.e. a weaker dollar? If that’s so, then China will buy more dollars to offset CNY appreciation. Agreed that China will then buy treasuries with dollars. What does ‘dollar rates’ mean? Only the 10-year bond yield will fall. i.e. LONG end of the dollar yield curve will fall.I assume that a strong USDCNY will mean higher than 6.8445 i.e. a stronger dollar. But this is exactly what the Financy Ministry in China wants – to continue with the exports engine! Why should they sell USDCNY i.e. sell dollars? Why would they want to kill the exports engine by selling dollars?Not convinced? Read the latest GEF post where they’re banking on property appreciation of all things to stave off a hard landing!http://www.morganstanley.com/views/gef/index.html#anchor6880Please clarify if I misunderstood.P1AQL.

P1AQLSeptember 5th, 2008 at 4:20 am

Alessandro on 2008-09-05 03:10:09 asked:

Guess where the rate of your ARM loan would be headed?

Once you’re done with the fixed rate tenure of an Hybrid ARM, you’re on a floating rate – could be a spread to short Term Treasury products such as 1 year CMT i.e short end of the curve. The Fed has reasonable control over the short end of the curve. So if Ben prints like nuts by buying up lots of short term FI products to target an ULTRA low Fed Funds rate, rates on now floating ARMs would remain low.http://mortgage-x.com/general/indexes/cmt.asp and navigate to “1-Year Constant Maturity Treasury index “. I quote:

This is the most widely used index. Roughly half of all ARMs are based on this index. It’s used on ARMs with annual rate adjustments. It is also referred to as the 1-Year Treasury Bill

P1AQL.

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 4:42 am

Speaking of the most powerful weapon that humanity can offer for evolving civilization:From: John Mauldin and Investors InsightUnder: Solzhenitsyn and the Struggle for Russia’s SoulBy: George FriedmanPlease note: extract”Imagine a Soviet Union not ruled by thugs and incompetents. Imagine Russia ruled by people resembling Solzhenitsyn’s vision of a decent man.”SOoooo, I say, imagine any country not ruled by thugs and incompetents! Imagine government made up of decent men – for a change!What more can I say?Ho humPeterJB

AlessandroSeptember 5th, 2008 at 4:44 am

@P1AQL”By USDCNY do you mean USD/CNY i.e. 6.8445?”Right.”What does ‘dollar rates’ mean? Only the 10-year bond yield will fall. i.e. LONG end of the dollar yield curve will fall.”All US rates, long and short, have benefited (have been lower than they would have otherwise be) from the buying binge of foreign central banks over the last several years.”a stronger dollar. But this is exactly what the Financy Ministry in China wants – to continue with the exports engine! Why should they sell USDCNY i.e. sell dollars? Why would they want to kill the exports engine by selling dollars?”Look further than that. If China slows down for real the yuan may easily fall more than government official would like and that might even ignite a flight of the monster speculative capital out of China, making the fall faster. Remember that China needs to buy natural resources and they secured huge dollar denominated contracts (i.e. dollar future liabilities). If the dollar goes up they will meat their dollar liability by selling dollar assets.Contrary to what seems your belief economy is about real stuff. Paper counts only marginally.

AlessandroSeptember 5th, 2008 at 4:53 am

P1AQL: “The Fed has reasonable control over the short end of the curve.”Has it?”So if Ben prints like nuts by buying up lots of short term FI products to target an ULTRA low Fed Funds rate, rates on now floating ARMs would remain low.”So Ben has the power to raze the US financial system to ashes with hyperinflation. So what? Will he do that to save the ARM burdened homeowners? Your call.

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 5:09 am

I suggest that y’ll pray for global warming this winter…September 4, 2008 (LPAC)–Today, Lyndon LaRouche pointed to the fact that the cracking point politically will be when people, especially in the northern states, have to sign contracts for heating oil. In the past people could get credit for one year based on their equity. However, now in the northern states, the number of people qualified to get a loan to heat their homes in the winter is collapsing.LaRouche stressed that you have to look beyond “this week” into coming weeks. “The guy in streets doesn’t think ahead. But in the coming weeks there will be a qualitative change in the perceived situation. This is going to hit hard in October.”Current estimates are that the national average price of heating oil will be $4.35 a gallon this Fall and Winter, with a typical house easily using 1200- 1500 gallons through the cold months in the Northeast and Midwest.”Ho humPeterJB

P1AQLSeptember 5th, 2008 at 5:13 am

@Alessandro on 2008-09-05 04:44:15 wrote:

If China slows down for real the yuan may easily fall more than government official would like and that might even ignite a flight of the monster speculative capital out of China, making the fall faster. Remember that China needs to buy natural resources and they secured huge dollar denominated contracts (i.e. dollar future liabilities).

I find this contradictory. Why would China buy more natural resources if China slows down? Why would there be ‘a flight of the monster speculative capital’ if China has huge reserves and surpluses to boot? It just doesn’t make sense. The very reason the Asian tigers built up large reserves was to avoid against the black swan of capital flight that the Koreans experienced in the Asian Financial Crisis.I am sorry for harping on this but I can’t find one good reason why China would be offended by a highly depreciated yuan. The Finance Ministry cares less about inflation than growth, the exact opposite of what the Central Bank in China wants.P1AQL.

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 5:16 am

SOL ;-0>Speaking of algorithmic scamming by Telco’s and the like and Australia.Appears the Australia Ombudsman TIO has been receiving so many complaints, so rapidly and with such perversity that this office is screaming for a huge increase in staff and funding… it cannot cope!Apparently the Telco’s nation-wide have decided to feed and have accelerated themselves into a sated frenzy on the public.In Australia you can get telephone bills without having a telephone or buy A$500 credit in phone calls for it to disappear with 20 minutes…It a time to feed – er, dividend time.Ho humPeterJB

AlessandroSeptember 5th, 2008 at 5:45 am

P1AQL: “I am sorry for harping on this”No problem.”Why would China buy more natural resources if China slows down?”They will not buy ‘more’ than today, they just have to buy what they need. They have to pay for oil in dollars as per the contracts they signed.”Why would there be ‘a flight of the monster speculative capital’ if China has huge reserves and surpluses to boot?”That’s the point: “trade surplus”. Why China has an aggregate trade surplus, because other countries have an aggregate trade deficit with it. What is the West goes into a recession and people realize they don’t need all those 54″ flat screen on credit?Read it again. Chinas trade surplus come from stuff sold oversees on credit coming from China itself.You were speaking about buyer strikes, right? Where does the trade surplus goes in the event of a buyer strike? Ooops!

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 5:54 am

@ P1AQL on 2008-09-05 05:13:36With respect to Alessandro, I have to agree with your question since China has heaps of that US funny stuff to get rid of: -BUT, as I posted some time back, I strongly suspect that all is not right in the Central Government [of China], or, I believe that there is some internal crisis / division / ? happening; whatever, China is now an unknown! This unknown concerns me very much and I think that whatever it is, it will soon appear.I also suspect that it may not be viewed as favourable to the USA.Ho humPeterJB

MedicSeptember 5th, 2008 at 6:22 am

@ Phil T;I am also curious as to the tipping point of people and their idea of lifestyle they wish to maintain. My wife and I have discussed the difference between lifestyle and survival and have planned for the worst as fast as we could while still trying to maintain some semblance of our perceived lifestyle needs. I’ll spare the other regulars here my story again, but briefly we have: moved away from oil heat (1100 gals/year) by installing a pellet stove large enough to heat our home and purchased our best guess worth of annual pellets which now sit in my garage; we have installed a solar domestic hot water system; we have cut back on monthly expenses we deemed unnecessary such as TV & cell phone; we purchased a large chest freezer and have begun buying in bulk (enabling lower costs and fewer trips to the grocery store); and we have stopped traveling as much as we had in the past – many family and friends are 100 miles away and we used to see them every 1-2 weeks, but now see them 1/2 as much.The thing is that reality set in with us early on. Too many people I know still have no idea what lies in front of us – they truly are blissfully ignorant – but they will know soon enough. I agree with Peter JB’s thought about home heating oil breaking the back of the poor this winter in the northern states. Quite frankly, I expect the Emergency Room I work in to be busier and flush with any number of minor complaints just so some of the poorest have a place to go and be warm.Lifestyles. They will change quickly when survival becomes the reality.You have become a welcomed visitor here. Elevation of the conversation is never a bad thing.Best to you,Medic

Little SaverSeptember 5th, 2008 at 7:37 am

U.S. Payrolls Fell 84,000 in August; Unemployment Rate at 6.1%http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aqO7vRxRSJ_4&refer=homeThat’s a clear signal, methinks.

MedicSeptember 5th, 2008 at 7:56 am

And the numbers are doctored by the government, no doubt, to make them look better than they are. Unemployment may be closer to 12%. All the lipstick in the world won’t make this pig any prettier……Watch out. That’s reality about to bite you in the ass.

P1AQLSeptember 5th, 2008 at 8:08 am

Game of Chicken?@Alessandro, thanks for the link on Korean Won problems.————————————————@All and Prof. Roubini,It would interesting to discuss game theory. Bill has asked for ‘new balance sheet’ support. Alternatively, can capital be raised by liquidation of some ‘other sovereign balance sheet’? After all, some of the sovereign wealth funds have been just saving and not putting reserves to productive use since they don’t have investment banks to match investors with entrepreneurs.Now if the KDB does not help Lehman, how would the Koreans feel if there is no one later to support the Won? Politics drives Economics. Bear gave no quarter during the LTCM bail-out; it received none in return this time around. Lehman and KDB (and the Korean Won) seem to be in the same situation now.———————————————-@PeterJB, China has effectively outsourced central banking to the US. Witness the fact, that they used a blunt instrument of reserve ratios due to lack of central banking experience and expertise compared to the combination of repo rate and reserve ratio hikes undertaken by the Reserve Bank of India which has a long history of central banking given its British heritage.So I agree that with flaky financial institutional infrastructure, China will find it interesting if its economy hits a major bump. More like a Meteor hit?Enjoy the ride!Best,P1AQL.

J.W.September 5th, 2008 at 8:17 am

“Regarding the possibility of them dumping Treasuries or agencies in favor of higher yielding assets I think they are on the horns of dilemma. They have to do it very slowly and quietly or they put their export based economy and remaining dollar holdings in jeopardy. Besides, where else are they going to put their money? Stocks? Real Estate?”A good point. I’ve wondered this before, and I suspect that China has several “off-ramps” for their dollar assets. You’re right, they have to do it slowly so as to gradually transition their export-dependent economy to a big domestic demand-driven one, thus avoiding the blunder that sank Japan after the Louvre Accord in 1987– when the Japanese allowed their currency to appreciate too quickly without developing enough domestic demand, with Japan basically being played for a sucker by the USA with our own dollar problems. (Summary at http://blogs.ft.com/wolfforum/2007/02/history-holds-lhtml/ )I think the key is for China to make sure they get real, tangible goods for their savings and dollar holdings rather than worthless US Treasury documents. Several ways to do this:1. Ramp up investment of China’s savings into domestic infrastructure, education, technology, venture capital and environmental improvements. This is probably the best approach, though it’ll take a few years to get it fully ramped up.2. Commodities (fuels, minerals, precious metals)Inflation has hit different dollar-denominated commodities to varying degrees, and China could still use much of its dollar stash to soak up and store up at least some commodities that haven’t appreciated too much.In fact, if the price of oil really does plummet (due, say, to the presence of a globalized recession), then China would be very wise to buy up large quantities of oil and accumulate a decent-sized oil reserve while the price of low, and before it goes back up again. They’d be remiss not to do this and as always, the best time to prepare for a rainy day is when the sun is shining bright.3. Using China’s dollar-denominated stash to get real dollar-denominated assets in the USA and dollarized countries. Despite the Unocal flap, there’s ultimately not much that even hyper-protectionism could do to thwart Chinese ownership of some ships, ports, factories, mines, even land, since we depend on them so much. Also, Ecuador, Liberia, Panama and some other countries use the dollar, another place that China could shop for real goods depending on inflation levels. Plus, the yen and some other currencies haven’t appreciated too much against the dollar. China could indeed exchange many of its dollars for yen (in anticipation of yen appreciation) or get real goods with e.g. pesos, reals and rubles.China in any case needs to diversify a lot more. Hitching China’s economic wagon to the USA would be incredibly stupid at any point, especially now. They need to have their assets in multiple places.

randySeptember 5th, 2008 at 8:48 am

watch out everybody…………..almost the entire net is talking about all the bad things that are getting ready to happen to the markets……….we’re only down 40 points and showing some strength…..I have a bad feeling we are going to see green today!!!!!! That’s the kind of market we’re in!When Lehman actually thinks investors will buy the fact that they can “spin off” a company, off load the bad stuff they don’t want, maintain a stake in the “new” company (just in case it tuns around in the future), and this will cause their balance sheet to look so good that their share price will go up/????????? They must be smoking the same thing Bill Gross at PIMCO is.Only in the US.

randySeptember 5th, 2008 at 8:52 am

what we need IMHO is for the markets to really crash, for china, japan, and russia to say “no more” to buying the toxic crap from F&F and dump what they have on the market. This will begin the cleansing process the markets needs to begin to function rationally again.However, I do NOT think this will ever happen unless their is an exogenous event that is out of TPTB control like another terror attack, someone starts a war with IRAN, etc

AnonymousSeptember 5th, 2008 at 9:20 am

from silverseek.com forum by Argentum:”A post by HOG over at the BD forums:If you REALLY want to see where the price of gold/silver is going, just WATCH and do the OPPOSITE of what THE BIGGEST CROOKS on the planet tell you to do – Goldman Sucks!Goldman was SHORT over FIFTY THOUSAND CONTRACTS on the TOCOM. Goldman told people to SELL GOLD. Goldman has been COVERING THOUSANDS OF SHORTS and BUYING LONG. Just the OPPOSITE of what they told their investors.Don’t expect the REGULATORS to do a DAMN THING!Here is what Goldman did on the September 2 TOCOM session:Quote:In the September 2 session on the TOCOM Goldman Sachs COVERED an absolutely stunning 1,612 short contracts AND ADDED 351 LONG CONTRACTS to bring their long position to 1,049 contracts (a 50% increase in one session!!!!) and their net short position to 2,537 contracts (a 44% reduction in one session!!!). This is a NEW RECORD LOW for their net short position but beats the previous low by 1,963 contracts! This has absolutely astonishing implications for the gold market. GS is running for the hills.”

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 9:22 am

PPT! PPT! PPT! PPT! Dow should be below 11,ooo right now and odds are we go green today WHAT A JOKE. THe household survey showed a loss of 492,000 jobs last month!!! 492,000!!!

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 10:25 am

If China is still buying U.S. treasuries, I suspect that is not so much just because they “have to”, but because they are also concerned about large-scale imbalance.

lennySeptember 5th, 2008 at 10:30 am

I wonder if the quote about goldman going long on gold in a big way is accurate…is it possible for outsiders to see goldman’s positions?

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 10:32 am

I repeat: How does the collapse of BWII relate to an expected US recovery in 18 months? What about inflation and changed energy conditions?Is “Dr. Doom” too optimistic? The timelines don’t match up.Darkie

randySeptember 5th, 2008 at 10:38 am

I believe the markets will end green today. There is not enough pressure on the downside today. All this bad news and we’re at about 100 points down. I’ve seen that amount get wiped out in 5 minutes in the past.Mark my words………..we’re green today. Unless, of course, Israel bombs Iran or something……

randySeptember 5th, 2008 at 10:52 am

told you. There is no way in hell TPTB are going to let the DOW drop below 11k. Unless, of course, they have no control over it through the exogenous event I mentioned before. PPT is alive and well. GOD knows where the money comes from to continually buy the S&P indices to goose the markets.

randySeptember 5th, 2008 at 11:02 am

I’ve read that there are several primary dealers that the FED and the treasury “use” to place their orders in the markets. I would guess since Goldman pretty much controls the FED, that it’s Goldman and of course, JP Morgan. Did you know that JP Morgan himself was a front man for the Rothschild empire back in the day?

StevenSeptember 5th, 2008 at 11:07 am

May I ask the RGE panel how this recession is likely to affect the dollar vs. euro? Given that all areas are entering into recession but the ECB’s strict mandate is to fight inflation, would this not imply a renewed weakening of the dollar longer-term stoking further inflation? Also, we have seen how the SEC has intervened to prevent a further collapse in financial stocks, eg. the selective ban on short selling, presumably to facilitate re-capitalisation of desperate financial institutions. Could anyone comment on the sentiment that the oil markets are also somehow being manipulated to alleviate consumer pain in advance of the November election?Thank you.

AlessandroSeptember 5th, 2008 at 11:16 am

@Guest on 2008-09-05 10:54:11my take of Miss America’s take is that there’s no real coordinated effort, but many synchronized moves between big players that try to do the same moves all together, each one for his own benefit. He described is as “everybody going in and out of the pool at the same time”. You just need to know which pool is the next one. GS is the one of the heavy splashers (Hank anyone?) so the others naturally follow them.

SoftwarengineerSeptember 5th, 2008 at 11:22 am

MOB RULEIn America’s republic [banana?] the highly esteemed Congress and Senate with presidential veto; make all the indecisions for us and we keep electing the “do-nothings”.The result is uncontrolled population growth [that no Dem/Rep or media brainwasher mentions] and is clearly/scientifically the root cause of our current debt crisis. The baidaid solution: “give our organised crime bankers more bailout tax money welfare”.I know he doesn’t stand a chance to win, but I like his idea. How about we implement national initiatives to get bills through with “We the People” mob rule, as Dr. Nader suggests?It sure beats the current “The Mob” organised crime ruling things and lobbying brainwash control of our politicians.

randySeptember 5th, 2008 at 11:53 am

TPTB don’t disappoint. Green DOW.It really makes me sad to see that our country is so corrupt.I just recently read a great quote by one of our founding fathers….Thomas Jefferson: “I sincerely believe, with you, that banking establishments are more dangerous than standing armies; and that the principle of spending money to be paid by posterity, under the name of funding, is but swindling futurity on a large scale”

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 1:44 pm

I have been reading posts here for about 4 weeks. It seems like everyone on here thinks the world is going to end.I remember the 70′s and out here on eastern long island it was real hard finding a job. The gas lines were how we would spend an afternoon. And how many times since then that religious nuts have said that Armageddon was right around the corner.Even if the economy gets worst then what it is right now, so what ! Since the beginning of 2007 I have lost 2/3 of my income. I have made adjustments and now even have to make bigger ones for what looks like an even slower winter.There seems to be a lot of smart people on here, instead of crying why not start looking for ways to get out of this and think about the future. That guy peter bj is the most depressing person on here. Peter, try therapy

The RussianSeptember 5th, 2008 at 1:59 pm

Shocking news:Real US Housing Losses Are $6 TrillionActual losses in the US real estate market are much higher than what you have been reading in the newspapers recently. Using a combination of official government statistics and the most widely used index of housing values, we will demonstrate that the US real estate market has lost a total of $6 trillion in value in the last two years. We will show that an average house that was worth about $226,000 in 2006 is, once you adjust for inflation, down to a real value of only about $160,000. To put what a $6 trillion loss is into perspective, we will show that when all factors are taken into account, the two year drop in US real estate values is equivalent to wiping out the entire retirement savings of all 78 million Baby Boomers, and annual housing losses are close to the annual GDP of China. We will close by talking about how this national disaster creates major personal profit opportunities for people who can learn to look beyond the false number of nominal dollars and into the reality of how wealth is rapidly redistributed during times of economic turmoil.http://www.safehaven.com/article-11150.htm

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 2:06 pm

Guest on 2008-09-05 13:44:36Good news are for wimps only.Get a reality check yourself. Otherwise I can recommend Russian Standard Vodka, vely good!

The RussianSeptember 5th, 2008 at 2:12 pm

Russian Standard is fine, I always give it to my dogPS Russian shares got a bad hit last few weeks, even some not so poor guys must have lost a lot. Expect many more bad news on Russian economy soon

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 3:02 pm

P1AQL and Alessandro,1 important thing abt the dollar strength is the fake money created.. i m not sure if i understand it fully but my take is as follows :- by supporting the dollar/supress the yuan in the past, the foreign central banks have poured a pile of money/yuan (ie austrian call forced savings) into their banking system.. and via the fractional reserve banking, a pile of credit on top of credit is created…- the central bank will try to sterilise the liquidty (but according to Prof Roubini, in his May 2007 Asian paper, the sterilisation is hardly effective at all)- the incr in money and credit via the fractional resr system, feeds their domestic property/stock bubble.. the credit has been used up by long-term business start-ups, factories, grand property projects, bird-nest stadium, olympic party, etc..- now that USA has a credit crunch, the supply of dollars in the global system shrinks.. suddenly the process reverses…- global trade is slowing, upward pressure on yuan is reducing and there are simply less dollars in the financial system..- and now, their money supply is stalling, they are not pumping in as much yuan into their economy.. their fake “forced savings” is slowly reversing..- we always need more money to maintain the illusion and keep the bubble going, and this mechanism is breaking down.. capital will want to exit the bubble country, forcing them to defend their currency (selling dollars to buy up yuan), running down the yuan money supply further.. thus potentially crashing the economy…- with central bankers selling dollars why arent dollars collapsing? i suspect its becoz of the credit crunch.. the USA banks are shrinking the USD supply…Any views?.. this can be so bloody confusingmrskeptical

MarkSeptember 5th, 2008 at 4:24 pm

This just about sums up the lunacy (where are the fundamentals?):U.S. Stocks Advance as Rally in Banks Overshadows Drop in Jobshttp://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=apcAFrA5Cg.A&refer=home

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 4:29 pm

A funny comic at the big picture.Also, the latest with Volker and Shiller.Paul Volcker: Finance System is ‘Broken’Shiller: House Price Decline Could Be Worse than Depressionhttp://bigpicture.typepad.com/hlowe

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 4:35 pm

“That guy peter bj [PeterJB] is the most depressing person on here. Peter, try therapy@ Guest on 2008-09-05 13:44:36Mr. Guest: FYI and IMMHO, I am neither depressed nor am I intentionally depressing; I am indeed mostly happy and well balanced and my intention is to bring people out of Plato’s Cave so as to gaze on the magnificent future we could build en route to the stars.How?My attitude is focused on reality. I see things as they are. I do not believe that these elected and non elected ones are going to do me good en automata by making my everyday Xmas, nor do I believe that God is going kiss it all and make it better. No ughhamms here.God is indeed great and gives us all the equal opportunity to learn our lessons which cannot be learnt in warn, comfortable, dark and dank milieux wombs or suckling on the pap. However, being suddenly and unexpectedly, ripped off the teat and thrown out into the cold; raped, pillaged and generally and specifically removed from your preferred place of dreams and sweet candy, is depressing; which obviously you have yet to experience or perhaps most likely, consider.OTOH, in becoming human, ie sentient, or Homo sapien sapien, which scientifically you are described as being innately as, at least, potentially as, then the veils of ignorance are lifted and that kind, warm, gentle atmosphere is replaced with invigoratingly cool breezes, that bring the future and mental stimulation, good health and good cheer; IOW, tomorrow.I respect your rights to remain on the teat, but out here, is reality; it is good and indeed wonderful.Where ‘waiting to die sucks, like paying taxes for morons to kill people they have never met and will never know! This is your norm.No man can be trusted: This is humanity’s greatest strength.The denial of this fact is humanities greatest weakness.Ho humPeterJB

MedicSeptember 5th, 2008 at 5:02 pm

@ Guest on 2008-09-05 13:44:36See we told you he’s not depressing! BTW – Gloomy is our resident cheerleader, be kind.And to the guest who suggested I would be hunting moose soon……well I really don’t think that’s me. I do have relatives who fed large families only a generation ago by hunting year round – of course, they call that poaching around here.

London BankerSeptember 5th, 2008 at 5:19 pm

@ MedicYour post suggesting that the ER might fill up with people seeking warmth reminded me of the real reason Britain has so many pubs. Until Thatcher most houses in the UK did not have central heating. As late as the 1970s only about 30 percent of homes had central heating. The pubs were essential to the community as a warm place to gather and socialise in the days before central heating and television in the atomised individual home.Perhaps a sharp and lasting recession which puts heating fuel out of reach for many will promote the revival of pub culture. Worse things could happen. Pubs built communities, shared culture, common cause.

AlessandroSeptember 5th, 2008 at 5:35 pm

OK, i forgot two important pieces of market manipulation: the rumor forge and the advance whisper.Treasury Is Close to Finalizing Plan to Backstop Fannie, Freddiehttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB122064650145404781.htmlNow somehow the financials rallied like crazy on the day we get the 6,1% unemployment figure. Now I understand.

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 5:44 pm

“This bright new system, this practice in the United States, this practice in the United Kingdom and elsewhere, has broken down. Growth in the economy in this decade will be the slowest of any decade since the Great Depression, right in the middle of all this financial innovation. It is the most complicated financial crisis I have ever experienced, and I have experienced a few…Changes are going to have to be made” to the global financial system.”-Paul Volcker, former Federal Reserve Chair, 1979-87Allow me, for just one moment, please, to scream out loudly, that the most dangerous moment in the whole socio-economic game is rapidly skidding across the tracks to a corner, near ——–> You.”Changes are going to have to be made”.My Warning: Age old words Yes, but necessary words to consider for that which certainly will come and soon.Whankers and bureaucrats and politicians, all of which were once categorized under one class termed “Priests” (” a most troublesome group”) circa 4 millennium before present, will now tend to KILL, LIMIT, CONTAIN and otherwise destroy the spirit of man by bringing the global economic, financial and monetary system, ie the free-market economy, under their most tiresome, boring and grey (I hope you get my point, here) and incompetent control in applied superficial “black-holed” (where the Sun don’t shine any more) economics where nothing moves and everything is taxed until do us Part, er, death.This situation must be avoided! At all costs!Fixing the current system merely needs some minor fundamental changes as I have already outlined whereas giving Ben or Hank or George and that ilk, free reigns to preside over decades of depression will be like burning off, that which has already been razed, to ashes!We need to go forward so dump Obama and McCain, the FedRes and the CB system and let’s move on:”To Infinity and Beyond”. Your mileage will vary”.Vivre la Revolution ;-) >Ho humPeterJB

MedicSeptember 5th, 2008 at 5:58 pm

@ LB;I was just over at your post again – love to type WEANI!I am a bit concerned about some of our old and poor here if the winter is severe. Money (even for many not on the bottom) is tight and a decision between heating and eating is one that could become common. In normal years, the government has underfunded programs for heating assistance – this year, they are already talking about being short on funds and high on requests.I still hold to my thought that families will be coming together under a single roof out of necessity. Perhaps the pub is not such a bad idea. I will let you know after my parents move in:-)Medic

PhilTSeptember 5th, 2008 at 6:10 pm

@ LB

Perhaps a sharp and lasting recession which puts heating fuel out of reach for many will promote the revival of pub culture. Worse things could happen. Pubs built communities, shared culture, common cause.

Additionally, Sweat Lodges might accomplish the same altruistic points and provide health benefit!@ MedicThank thank you for your kind words earlier … as far as the Moose comment goes … it seems that many have O.D.’ed on Palin !Cheers !

AnonymousSeptember 5th, 2008 at 6:27 pm

The best response I’ve heard to Palin’s speech:Jesus Christ was a community organiser. Pontius Pilate was a governor.

AlessandroSeptember 5th, 2008 at 6:34 pm

@mrskeptical

- by supporting the dollar/supress the yuan in the past, the foreign central banks have poured a pile of money/yuan (ie austrian call forced savings) into their banking system.. and via the fractional reserve banking, a pile of credit on top of credit is created…

To be more precise FCBs have printed tons of money and have poured it in the hands of the exporters (indirectly via the FX manipulations). The exporters have then channeled the money into the banking system. BTW this is the modus operandi of a CB, print money and give it to a friend so he can buy more than it produces. The friends usually are banks, but in the case of FX-manipulators they are the exporters.Be careful, this produces inflation (lots of it), but not forced savings.

- the central bank will try to sterilise the liquidty (but according to Prof Roubini, in his May 2007 Asian paper, the sterilisation is hardly effective at all)

All FX sterilized-interventions are completely ineffective long term. Since you cited the Austrian economics it should be easy to see why: keeping the output of an economy fixed (or growing) the only long-term way to lower the value of a currency is growing its supply, that is, printing more of it.As an additional mid-term strategy the FCBs also hold the dollars they acquire in the FX and “invest” them in “safe” bonds like treasuries and agen… ok, let’s say just treasuries. This is nothing else as a deferred payment denominated in dollars. This is only a mid-term scheme because you can’t accumulate FX reserve forever. Even if China is attempting to prove the contrary.This is where forced savings come in. The FCBs are printing moeny (i.e. stealing wealth from every worker and saver) and lending it to the US. The wealth is forcibly saved from Asia and transferred to the US under the promise of future wealth.

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 6:41 pm

Lets review…Bear Stearns/JPM takedownpanic rate cutsnew Fed loan facilitiesfiscal stimulusHomeowner bailout billdodgy economic reportingFNM&FRE explicit bailout packagePresident’s working group on financial marketscurrency interventions, carry-trade swingsquickening boom/busts in commodities, energy, retailunparalleled market swingsforbearance by FDIC, SEC, FASB, and most regulatory bodies amounting to corrupt complicityrumours pushing financials higher officially sponsored. Rumours of failures, insolvency, firesales are to be prosecuted and officially quashed.Directed buying by hedge, public, retirement, collective funds counter market trend.These are the only factors which have affected equity trade to the upside. Little real business related, long-term fundamentals point to appreciable future gain.We are in a hyperdrive casino with distracting sideshows to cloak what is imminent. Sovereign default. The USA will renege on its debts. The LEHs, DSLs, MERs are just the minor royal chess pieces insulating the King. But the King is dead. Long live the King.

RedCreekSeptember 5th, 2008 at 7:24 pm

The British Museum in London has a great exhibition on Hadrian, who became emperor of a decaying Rome and went to give it temporary revival – one of the things he did was withdrawing his troops from… Iraq.A Continental European newspaper recently wrote an article about the exhibition and compared Rome with the USA and Hadrian with Obama.See http://www.britishmuseum.org/whats_on/all_current_exhibitions/hadrian_empire_and_conflict/videos_about_hadrian/hadrian_a_new_emperor.aspx

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 7:31 pm

Just a brief thought:Does it not say a lot for “The Science of Economics” when it appears from economists across the globe, all or most giving public their opinions, that none appear to be able to agree, from any point of view, that the USA is in recession; is not in a recession and, a definition as to that which is actually a recession?This is today’s science at its very best, methinks.I think we should all face it: Economics as it is practiced, is a farcical sham, in terms of it being a “science”.More like: “In God we Trust”. Hence all them “Priests” and that dogma (waiting to run over by the karma:).Ho humPeterJB

snsSeptember 5th, 2008 at 8:06 pm

from NYTimes!:BREAKING NEWS 9:01 PM ET: Government Preparing Plan to Seize Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, Officials Sayholy crap

JPSeptember 5th, 2008 at 8:25 pm

@ Anonymous on 2008-09-05 18:27:06The best response I’ve heard to Palin’s speech:Jesus Christ was a community organiser. Pontius Pilate was a governor.That’s funny – but going one step further…Jesus Christ was crucified by the Governor. Jesus went to heaven, the Governor went to hell. Some Jesus supporters wrote a book about it that was a fair and balanced accout of the whole event that has gathered quite a following.

AfASeptember 5th, 2008 at 8:28 pm

WARNING shorts!Prepare yourselves for your periodic squeeze next week! The F&F bailout will be coming in small doses, to be administered when needed.Best Regards.Signed: TWCBN

London BankerSeptember 5th, 2008 at 8:31 pm

Holy crap, indeed!But privately, senior officials have been critical of top executives at the companies, particularly Freddie Mac. They have raised concerns about major risks to taxpayers of a bailout of companies whose executives have received huge compensation packages. Mr. Syron, for instance, collected more than $38 million in compensation since he joined the company in 2003.The Chinese and other holders of Fannie and Freddie debt are going to be more rigorous in future, and very much more sceptical of executive claims to outsize compensation not matched by outsize performance.

GuestSeptember 5th, 2008 at 9:16 pm

Alessandro,Thanks for the detailed explanation..But what i have trouble understanding or convincing myself is – why suddenly the USD is getting more valuable?.. is it simply becoz of the credit crunch leads to a shrinking amt of dollars despite all the fiscal and bailout problems of the USA treasury?..Or is it just short-term money flow of the deleveraging process?mrskeptical

AnonymousSeptember 5th, 2008 at 9:19 pm

@ mrskepticalA small war here, a riot there, an assassination somewhere else, and pretty soon you got a flight to quality. Look back at the 70s and 80s. We’ve seen this playbook before.

MedicSeptember 5th, 2008 at 9:41 pm

Is it just me, or am I now on the hook for like, I dunno, six trillion F&*@ING Dollars! Holy God I don’t believe in……Is anyone outside the US accepting new immigrants? We have skills….could be very useful…..my wife is cute….anybody? Hello?

AfASeptember 5th, 2008 at 10:06 pm

@ mrskepticalI agree on this with Mish’s explanation. It is not much that the dollar is strengthening, but it is the euro and other currencies that are weakening. Traders were betting Europe and the rest of the world would decouple from the US giving much strength to the Euro. Now that it became apparent that the world would not escape a global recession and that the Euro and other currencies are overpriced. That, in addition to the unwinding of short USD/ long commodities trade. Not sure however which is the triggering cause.

2centsSeptember 5th, 2008 at 10:08 pm

@ Medic on 2008-09-05 21:41:28The US Emmigration Dept. has informed me that you are free to leave as soon as you pony up your portion of the US forecast debt which stands about 70 – 80 Trillion! Once the money and paperwork are processed you will have 20 min. in which to exit this great land.Ohh, I get the pellet stove!

P1AQLSeptember 5th, 2008 at 10:47 pm

Mr Skeptical on 2008-09-05 15:02:25 wrote:

capital will want to exit the bubble country, forcing them to defend their currency (selling dollars to buy up yuan), running down the yuan money supply further

Mr. Skeptical, I am not sure the above sequence applies to China (because of its military power); but it might apply to other export merchantilist models. A China slowdown will help in not encouraging much needed fresh dollar capital to enter China.So I believe that the Finance Ministry (Chinese Govt), to continue to promote employment and remain politically relevant, will force exports on the rest of the world much like the British Empire. Therefore, any yuan depreciation will only make them happy.With such a huge takedown in credit, the USD would have emerged the king anyway. The Fed has been the first to recognise the problem while the ECB continues to strangle Europe. Take a visit down to the the Inland Empire in California or Miami-Dade to see the magnitude of the problem.P1AQL.

P1AQLSeptember 5th, 2008 at 11:00 pm

Medic on 2008-09-05 21:41:28 asked:

Is anyone outside the US accepting new immigrants? We have skills….could be very useful…..my wife is cute….anybody? Hello?

In most countries outside the US, they take accident victims to the hospital in taxis. You have skills that nobody needs outside the USA (they don’t value life) but the nearest is taxi driving while simultaneously giving CPR.I recommend that you talk to the hard working immigrant taxi drivers in New York City. They will give you first hand information about these great nations and the fantastic compensation for taxi drivers there who also double up as Medics.After you’ve left, we’ll need an H1-B visa to get one of those super quants (read high tax payers) from Tsinghua or IIT to pay up for getting the benefit of access to an ambulance in 90 seconds flat.Cheers!P1AQL.

GuestSeptember 6th, 2008 at 12:35 am

Medic on 2008-09-05 21:41:28

Is anyone outside the US accepting new immigrants? We have skills….could be very useful…..my wife is cute….anybody? Hello?

They might accept your wife but not you, ha ha:-)

GuestSeptember 6th, 2008 at 1:45 am

Down the Rabbit Holehttp://www.europac.net/externalframeset.asp?from=home&id=13906

In recent months, investors have been unjustly chastised for their lack of consistency. In truth, they have an unblemished record of drawing the wrong conclusions. Last week’s 2nd quarter GDP report provides the freshest evidence of market cluelessness.In its report, the Commerce Department stunned economy watchers by showing a 3.3% annualized increase in 2nd Quarter GDP. The robust growth apparently wrong-footed those expecting further recessionary signals, lent further strength to the current dollar rally, and encouraged previously cautious investors to take another look at U.S. stocks. The strong number also bolstered claims by the Bush administration and the McCain campaign that a recession is primarily a psychological phenomenon. These conclusions would be at least quasi-logical if they were not based on a complete misreading of the report.Without raising an eyebrow on Wall Street or in the press, the GDP deflator, used in the report to downwardly adjust GDP to account for inflation, was shown at just 1.2% annualized…. the lowest deflator in ten years. In other words, to arrive at a 3.3% growth rate, the government assumed that inflation is running at a ten-year low! In contrast, the latest reading on consumer prices (CPI) in the second quarter shows year-on-year inflation running at a 5.6% rate, a seventeen-year high! In fact, for the second quarter, the same time period measured by the GDP deflator, prices actually rose at an even faster pace of 8.0% annualized. How can it be that inflation is simultaneously running at a seventeen-year high and a ten-year low? Welcome to the Alice in Wonderland world of government statistics.You would think that this statistical bombshell would raise the hackles of the press. Think again. Not only did the hawk-eyed media completely miss the story last week, they have totally ignored our subsequent attempts to show them the light (with the exception of the N.Y. Post’s John Crudele – who has long suspected a ruse). Although none of the reporters we spoke with could explain why inflation could run at a 10 year low and a 17 year high at the same time, they did not deem the anomaly sufficiently noteworthy. Having been ignored by reporters, I then tried the opinion pages. Unfortunately the piece that we prepared on the subject was rejected this week by all the leading national newspapers.Reporter Michael Mandel did note the head scratcher on a Businessweek blog posting last Friday. As a partial explanation he pointed out the CPI measures the prices of what we buy, and the GDP deflator measures the prices of what we make. Although this certainly sheds some light, it offers no real explanation. Excluding imports and exports, both measures are determined by the same forces, and should move in relative harmony. If anything, the costs of what we make should be outpacing the costs of what we buy. Producer prices are now rising faster than consumer prices (the latest annual reading of the Producer Price Index ‘PPI’ being 13.2% annualized from the 2nd quarter), which helps explain why corporate profits have fallen drastically. In addition, from July 2007 through July 2008 (the latest data available) import and export prices have risen 21.6% and 10.2% respectively. In other words, no matter what numbers you use, the 1.2% GDP deflator simply doesn’t add up.I have often argued that government statics are dubious, particularly those related to inflation. But here is an example where they are not even consistent! If we simply use second quarter CPI to adjust nominal second quarter GDP for inflation, the number would have registered a 3.5% annualized decline.Such horrific GDP numbers are much more consistent with the anecdotal recession evidence that Wall Street and Washington want us to ignore (confirmed by today’s weak jobs report which included the unemployment rate spiking to 6.1%, a five-year high). However, with Orwellian propaganda, our government fabricates GDP growth out of thin air without the smoke and mirrors traditionally required for such an elaborate illusion. All that is required is to put out ludicrous statistics and hope no one notices. Given that this strategy appears to be working, expect future government numbers to get even more outrageous. After all, if they can get away with this, they can likely get away with anything.

kilgoresSeptember 6th, 2008 at 2:44 am

Looks like the Russians are having some stock market troubles of their own, thanks in part to the conflict with Georgia:http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/06/business/worldbusiness/06ruble.html?ref=businessNew York TimesSeptember 6, 2008Big Summer Sell-Off Hits the Russian Stock MarketBy ANDREW E. KRAMERMOSCOW — Russia’s stock market is suffering its worst correction in nearly a decade as sliding oil prices, political attacks on private companies and instability after last month’s war in Georgia spook investors.On a bad day globally for stocks, Russia’s markets took an exceptional fall Friday. The Russian Trading System index lost 7.6 percent and recovered later to close down 4.45 percent after rumors circulated that the government would use state oil money to halt the decline. A Russian central bank official said the bank had sold large amounts of foreign currency a day earlier to shore up the ruble, which has fallen to its lowest level in about a year as oil and share prices decline.Stock analysts saw similarities between the current sell-off in Russian equities and the financial crisis of 1998, when retreating oil prices, a default on sovereign bonds and a devaluation of the ruble caused a 57 percent loss in the RTS market from the third quarter of that year to the next September. By contrast, the RTS index, which hit a record in May, has lost 38 percent over the comparable period.“The markets are now recognizing global growth has slowed significantly enough to effect cyclical commodity prices,” said Kingsmill Bond, the chief strategist at Troika Dialog bank. “It’s a global issue, but it’s being played out with greater ferocity here.”Unlike in 1998, the market drop has come as Russia’s real economy has enjoyed a trade surplus, an earlier surge in foreign direct investment, and $600 billion in gold and hard currency reserves.But Russia is vulnerable on two fronts: About 80 percent of the stocks in the RTS market are companies that produce commodities whose prices have historically been subject to boom-and-bust cycles, like Russia’s natural gas monopoly Gazprom and the steel smelter Severstal. And about half of the so-called free-float, or liquid portion of the stocks on the market, is held by foreign investors who are alert to political risk.On Friday, an 8 percent slump in the shares of Norilsk Nickel, the mining giant, underscored a plight typical of several Russian companies. While softening commodity prices are hitting producers the world over, in Russia’s case, a pernicious mix of infighting among some owners, complex alliances with the Kremlin, and a general elevation of political risk from the war have caused investors to think twice.Late last month, investors revalued Russian mining companies after the prime minister, Vladimir V. Putin, accused a large steel and coal mining company, Mechel, of tax evasion, causing its share price to collapse. The accusation rekindled fears that the government might be aiming to nationalize larger companies in the sector.Elsewhere, Gazprom, the state oil giant, lost 4 percent, to close at its lowest point in a year, and the state oil company Rosneft fell 2.2 percent.In the afternoon, Russia’s first deputy chairman of the Central Bank, Aleksey Ulyukayev, proposed spending a “small amount” of the National Wellbeing Fund, a new sovereign wealth fund set up in February to buoy the pension system, to invest in local markets after this year, Bloomberg News reported.While it could reverse a rout, economists say that any longer-term intervention by the Kremlin would corrode investors’ trust in the markets.So far this summer, the decline in the RTS has made it the worst performing major stock market in the world, according to a survey of 88 national equity markets monitored by Bloomberg News. The market had hit a record of 2,478.87 in May. In another measure, since the war broke out in Georgia on Aug. 7, the RTS has lost about $290 billion in paper value for Russian companies.

kilgoresSeptember 6th, 2008 at 2:53 am

Did anyone else notice how large the drops were on the European markets today? Geesh! Over 7% in the UK, over 4.5% in Germany, and over 6.3% in France. It’s starting to look like Asian market volatility there…SWK___BRITAINFTSE 1005,240.70–7.02%–395.90GERMANYDAX6,127.44–4.59%–294.86FRANCECAC 404,196.66–6.38%–285.94

AnonymousSeptember 6th, 2008 at 2:53 am

I Once Knew A Man From NantucketWho’s Country Went Bankrupt -Said ‘F–k It !’He Swam Out To SeaThe Madness To FleeWhen The Whole Banking System Kicked the Bucket

kilgoresSeptember 6th, 2008 at 2:56 am

Speaking of Asian markets – some of Friday’s closes:JAPANNikkei12,212.23–6.58%–860.64HONG KONGHang Seng19,933.28–6.25%–1,328.61CHINAShanghai2,202.45–8.13%–194.92Can’t wait to see what happens Monday after Sunday’s anticipated announcement of the takeover of Fannie and Freddie. Not to mention Hurricane Ivan, which appears to be on a course to strengthen, perhaps from its current Cat 3 status to a Cat 4, before heading into the Gulf of Mexico. Woo hoo! I’m starting to feel dizzy…SWK

kilgoresSeptember 6th, 2008 at 2:59 am

@ Anonymous on 2008-09-06 02:53:45I’m not a big fan of public vulgarity, but I did find that the classic “Nantucket” style of that limerick somewhat amusing…SWK

P1AQLSeptember 6th, 2008 at 2:59 am

AfA on 2008-09-05 23:47:14 asked:

Did you ever crossed the borders of New York State?

Yes. Perhaps you will deign to tell me why this question crossed your mind?P1AQL.

kilgoresSeptember 6th, 2008 at 3:12 am

@ P1AQL on 2008-09-06 03:07:06My bad…it IS 3:00 in the morning! Yes, those are weekly, not Friday-only figures. Still pretty significant drops, even for a 5-day period…”Sorry, sorry everyone.”"This is supposed to be a happy occasion. Let’s not bicker and argue about who killed who…”Alright. Time for bed now.SWK

kilgoresSeptember 6th, 2008 at 3:19 am

That’s more like it for Friday’s close:FTSE 100 – BRITAIN5,240.70–121.40–2.26%DAX – GERMANY6,127.44–152.13–2.42%CAC 40 – FRANCE4,196.66–107.35–2.49%Nikkei 225 – JAPAN12,212.23–345.43–2.75%Hang Seng – HONG KONG19,933.28–456.20–2.24%Shanghai Composite – CHINA2,202.45–74.96–3.29%Again, mea culpa. Apologies to all for late-night, early morning delirium.SWK

AlessandroSeptember 6th, 2008 at 4:22 am

Karl Denninger aka Genesis, a rock hard Republican voter, gets slightly upset at the Republican party. Can you blame him?

Republicans Proved Liars – Vote DemocratThat didn’t take long.The Republican Party adopted a platform that said:”At the same time, government action must not implicitly encourage anyone to borrow more than they can afford to repay. We support energetic federal investigation and, where appropriate, prosecution of criminal wrongdoing in the mortgage industry and investment sector. We do not support government bailouts of private institutions. Government interference in the markets exacerbates problems in the marketplace and causes the free market to take longer to correct itself.”You lied.”Fannie dropped $2.25, or 32 percent, to $4.79 at 5:50 p.m. in New York Stock Exchange trading after the Wall Street Journal said the Treasury is close to completing a plan to help the mortgage-finance companies. Freddie slumped $1.40, or 27 percent, to $3.70.The plan may involve a “creative use” of the Treasury’s new authority to pump capital into the companies as well as changes to senior management, the Journal reported on its Web site today, citing a person it didn’t name.”So you adopted a platform earlier this week which said you wouldn’t bail anyone out or support practices that involve unsustainable loans which is exactly what Fannie and Freddie have done over the last eight years.But by the end of the week, you have already, by the officials in your own party, who currently occupy Treasury and The White House, made clear that you are rank LIARS.Absolutely nothing in your platform – not your stand on foreign policy, not your stand on human rights, not your stand on trade, not even your stand on abortion and family values can be taken at face value.YOU HAVE JUST DECLARED THE ENTIRE PLATFORM TO BE ONE GIGANTIC DOCUMENT OF LIES.By extension, I must take every promise that McCain and Palin made at the Convention to be lies, when you are unable to avoid going back on your word for even one calendar week.Attention RNC – you have just lost my vote, and any person with more than two firing neurons in their head that votes for John McCain and Sarah Palin this fall is both certifiably insane and is voting for the intentional destruction of our nation’s financial security.If your party does not step in prior to this “fait accompli” being announced and squelch it, I will burn in effigy my Gingrich Speaker’s Gavel, make a Youtube video making clear how I feel about The Republican Party, and will be filing a party affiliation change Monday morning.That’s a promise.Foreign policy and military prowess is immaterial if you have no money; The Republicans have spent the last eight years practicing fraud and theft upon the public, and now, less than one week after saying that it was antithetical to the party principles your standard-bearers go do exactly what you said is unacceptable.Irrespective of what the “change” is you get from Obama (and how good or bad it might be) at least you’re being told up front what they’re going to do, instead of being lied to so blatantly that your party can’t even wait one week to go back on its word in a way that can bankrupt our children and grandchildren.Republicans disgust me.

http://market-ticker.denninger.net/archives/568-Republicans-Proved-Liars-Vote-Democrat.html

P1AQLSeptember 6th, 2008 at 5:09 am

Since I can’t sleep with all this action going on in the greatest credit event of our lives (and history anyone?), I must tell you I like the following line of questioning …

The executives were told that, under the plan, they and their boards would be replaced and shareholders would be virtually wiped out, but that the companies would be able to continue functioning with the government generally standing behind their debt, people briefed on the discussions said.

See http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/06/business/06fannie.html?_r=1&hp&oref=sloginAttention Fannie, Freddie shareholders: Shame on you for not being activist.You go Hank!P1AQL.

MedicSeptember 6th, 2008 at 7:14 am

Alright, after 5 1/2 hours of bad sleep and a 4 mile run this morning, I feel……yeah, no different. So let me pose this:Would it make sense for the dollar to rally Monday on the Fed actions? My instinct is to say of course not, but since TPTB have kept the smoke and mirrors up this long, I believe it to be a possibility.How about gold? Again, TPTB may be able to keep the smoke up for a short time, but my guess is that, as I have felt for some time, October is the big drop in the markets and the launch of PM as too many currencies start to lose too much value for investors.And hey, the RNC must be getting very concerned. I received and email yesterday (from someone who should have known better) questioning Obama’s funding. It claimed to be a column by Maureen Dowd of the NYT, but since it did not sound like her usually articulate prose, I checked and of course, she never wrote it. The column suggested that large amounts of Obama’s funding was coming from foreign governments and even terrorists. Sowing the seeds of fear is what they do better than anyone – now if only they had governed better than anyone……we might be talking about a better future for our kids than the lousy legacy we shall give them.

GuestSeptember 6th, 2008 at 8:12 am

Medic,..I think it has been priced in already..Also, i believe dollar rally has more to do with credit crunch than the state of the banking system..something along the lines of shrinking supply of dollars and increased demand for dollars…not sure if i m making sense.. havent really figure it out..MISH has stated many times, the banking system is bankrupt but yet he still believes in dollar’s rally..hmmm?..mrskeptical

GuestSeptember 6th, 2008 at 9:14 am

U.S. House Price Decline Could Be Worse than Great Depression, Economist Shiller Sayshttp://finance.yahoo.com/tech-ticker/article/53094/U.S.-House-Price-Decline-Could-Be-Worse-than-Great-Depression

Eight years ago, Yale superstar professor and MacroMarkets chief economist Robert Shiller famously called the top of the stock market in his book Irrational Exuberance. Then, a year before the housing bubble peaked, he predicted the colossal bust we are now experiencing.If you recognize Shiller’s name, it’s because the Standard & Poor’s/Case-Shiller home price indexes, which he developed with Wellesley College economist Karl Case, have become the nation’s most authoritative source for home price trends.In part one of my one-on-one with Shiller, we discuss the grim outlook for U.S. housing, which he tackles in-depth in his new book The Subprime Solution. Highlights of our first discussion include:* Home price declines are already approaching those in the Great Depression, when they plunged 30% during the 1930s. With prices already down almost 20%, it’s not a stretch to think we might exceed that drop this time around…. …

MedicSeptember 6th, 2008 at 9:27 am

Mrskeptical;I am not sure what he is getting at if he thinks a dollar rally will continue. How, or more importantly, why would someone invest in the US dollar that is now burdened with another 5.7 trillion dollars of potential (not yet realized) debt? Let’s be frank – even if there’s only %20 of F/F debt that is bad, that’s still 1 trillion plus that we are on the hook for. I’m not buying that crap, and I live here!This defies any and all logic. The market cannot go anywhere but down on Monday – but, as we have all seen in the past year, TPTB are very good at slowing down the out of control train. Let’s see if tehy have any tricks left………

K in TXSeptember 6th, 2008 at 9:31 am

Lots of good comments in this thread; thanks all. Too bad we can’t link documents somehow ’cause there are a couple of thoughtful multi-part explanations above that would really benefit from a flow chart of some kind.Medic, if you think you might leave maybe you should pursue a nursing license. In my research it appears that every developed country will happily take a nurse.

MedicSeptember 6th, 2008 at 9:45 am

@ K in TX;Thank you for the thought – I am actually already a nurse. I could not make a living in EMS – it pays poorly and is very hard on a body. I woke up one day and realized my body would not forgive me at 40 the way it had at 30 for what I put it through – plus the day I started my first job as a nurse, I doubled my income. I no longer work the streets – I am indoors these days – but I did learn a lot in my 10 years in the field and I am a better nurse now because of it.BTW – I am not really going anywhere. I am just spouting off because there are so few people in the world who understand. But you folks are a wonderful substitute for therapy, and I am happy to be here among you.Now, about that revolution………..

curiousSeptember 6th, 2008 at 9:45 am

Where is the U.S. Attorney General? I want federal indictments, jail time and renumeration of compensation for/from these thieves who have run fannie and freddie over the past decade. What a farce! JP Morgan as an adviser to the UST on how to “construct/manage” the nationalization?, hard to fathom. Look to see who profits from here. They are the crooks.

JLCSeptember 6th, 2008 at 10:00 am

And so the looting of Fannie and Freddie begins. When its all over, the prime assets will end up in private hands and the taxpayers will get stuck with the junk.

MarkSeptember 6th, 2008 at 10:36 am

Paulson Plans to Bring Fannie, Freddie Under Government ControlBy Alison Vekshin and Dawn KopeckiSept. 6 (Bloomberg) — Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson is preparing to announce plans to bring Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac under government control, seeking to halt the crisis of confidence in the companies that make up almost half the U.S. mortgage market.Full story: http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=azJ2NQoKxMnE&refer=homeSo, the fear that we’d feel after being pushed off a cliff would be defined by these bozos as a crisis of confidence! Pay no attention to gravity (fundamentals)!Won’t this tend to piss off the Chinese government?Mark

MaggieSeptember 6th, 2008 at 11:41 am

Guest on 2008-09-05 13:44:36It has become markedly more doomy here of late, but not all of us really live by that philosophy. I read this blog for its interesting links and insights. I’ve enjoyed the summer, camped, kayaked, and made love to my boyfriend; I live simply and with no debt; I still have a job; I still love life. Life is still good to me. I am not oblivious to the suffering of my fellow citizens, even though in this particular bright Western city the effects of the recession are felt dimly if at all admidst a sprawling panorama of half-built condominium towers. Even though I watch the unfolding economic events like any other bystander, with dismay and a touch of fear tinged with awe at the scale of the slide, life here goes on much like before. We cook dinners, play mancala or cribbage, watch movies, stroll in the sunshine, even take Friday night drives.Work, love, and friendship need to be cultivated and built more than gold reserves, wealth, and success in reading the financial future. The simple fact is all of us, rich and poor, will be affected by the decline of this empire. Even if the economy fails really spectacularly, even if we have food shortages, gas lines, and power outtages, people will continue to get up and work and help each other get through it. In spite of my acceptance of hard times ahead for the nation, I also know that we’ll muddle through it on the hundreds of thousands of local levels — in neighborhoods and blocks of streets. There is much comraderie to be found in community organizations as well as in old friendships.”Reality” is something a bit twisted and distorted on these blogs. Reality is found outside your door, not in electronic faceless exchanges of opinion or even fact. Reality is the face of your neighbor or lover or friend. Several posters here believe they have a bead on the future, but the future is wholly outside of our control. Accepting that allows one to enjoy the life given to us right here and now.

MarkSeptember 6th, 2008 at 11:46 am

If anyone is having problems getting all the comments to show up (blank or blacked out) I think that I’ve figured out a fix:Scroll to the bottom of the page and click on the Preview button. This will result in a warning that you need to provide a comment. Dismiss this and then scroll up and you’ll now see that all of the comments now appear.Perhaps this is only a problem for Firefox users (which I am one). Anyway, hope this is of some help to others.Mark

GuestSeptember 6th, 2008 at 12:25 pm

Maggie on 2008-09-06 11:41:55

“Reality” is something a bit twisted and distorted on these blogs. — Reality is the face of your neighbor or lover or friend.

Thanks for the pick-me-up but: 1)Summary of data on this forum for the last two years points to an impending economic collapse. 2)In all probability, it already has begun and it will reveal its full magnitude by the end of the year. 3)I look forward to another life-is-just-fine message and let’s-work-together message in January 2009. 4)Can you still be optimistic if you are convinced that your standard-of-living will be ~10% lower next year than it is this year? And lower yet by another ~10% the next year? 5)I will need another pick-me-up about this time next year when we routinely see people as they climb out of a garbage dumpster holding a prized half-consumed hot dog. 4)Yes, this forum is chock full of curmudgeons (e.g., PeterJB) and assorted old-farts that are horrified from a principled perspective, but they have protected their wealth and have little skin in the game. 5)Ignore the chaff, continue to enjoy the wheat, stay prepared!

Average JaneSeptember 6th, 2008 at 12:48 pm

So we taxpayers are now “officially” on the hook for Fannie and Freddie. I am absolutely incensed. Incensed.

MaggieSeptember 6th, 2008 at 1:39 pm

Thanks for the pick-me-up but: 1)Summary of data on this forum for the last two years points to an impending economic collapse. 2)In all probability, it already has begun and it will reveal its full magnitude by the end of the year.I have no quarrel with that. I know economic collapse is no longer an “if,” it’s a reality. In fact, I am personally more inclined to see the future as worse than what Roubini predicts. But I’m a novice and again, no one can really foresee the future, so much of which is wholly out of our control.3)I look forward to another life-is-just-fine message and let’s-work-together message in January 2009.Ha ha. Okay, true enough. I know what I wrote seem like so many platitudes, but there’s truth in the simplicity of not letting the two-dimensional view of economic havoc received on these blogs to actually color your ability to enjoy the three-dimensional reality of everyday life. So far, I have not yet found a regular poster on this blog who is homeless or living out of their car.4)Can you still be optimistic if you are convinced that your standard-of-living will be ~10% lower next year than it is this year? And lower yet by another ~10% the next year?Yes, as I live with no debt, still have a job, and can clothe and feed myself. I have it made.5)I will need another pick-me-up about this time next year when we routinely see people as they climb out of a garbage dumpster holding a prized half-consumed hot dog.Well, living in a large city, I have seen this for years, well before this huge unwinding of credit, spoiled fortunes, abounding foreclosures, etc. Actually, I’ve seen a huge increase in homeless ever since Reagon.4)Yes, this forum is chock full of curmudgeons (e.g., PeterJB) and assorted old-farts that are horrified from a principled perspective, but they have protected their wealth and have little skin in the game.Which is the ultimate irony, isn’t it? Those who are most taken by the idea of collapse are those who have the least to lose. Every now and then a true unfortunate will pop up here with a plea for advice, which is freely and generously given, yet the vast majority of posters here seem to be educated, affluent, and . . . afraid!5)Ignore the chaff, continue to enjoy the wheat, stay prepared!Amen!

KerkSeptember 6th, 2008 at 2:47 pm

There are times when it is useful to look at the basics, and it is certainly one of those times.It is imperative to understand the monetary system, what it used to be and what it is. It used to be a commodity-based system with gold and silver the only items the states could make legal tender. The Fed. gov’t had no authority to make anything legal tender per the 9th and 10th amendments – but that is circumstantial to the argument here. The point here is that a commodity-based monetary system, without fractional reserve lending, needs neither inflation nor deflation of the money supply to stay viable. It is what it is, and the people will be able to determine with a fairly approximate determination what the rate of expansion or retraction (in relation to goods and services) will be over time.However, with our current system, a truly faith-based fiat system, a certain entity must determine how much supply is appropriate. How can they determine it? Only by best guesses approximated by mathematical models or someother such methods. What potential limitation can be used? The answer appeared to be the creation of potentially harmful debt equal to the credit/money created. I am somewhat confident that at some point, the idea was that surely people would only incur debt for the purposes of investment (expansion of capital) versus for pure consumption. This would have the self-regulating effect of limiting the money supply. I can’t say for sure as I obviously wasn’t privy to the discussions involving the impetus behind the Federal Reserve.Nonetheless, the massive problem is that once the debt goes beyond a certain limit, the issue becomes so large that the only option becomes cascading defaults on a systemic scale or inflation(devaluation of the currency) on a scale where the effects become deleterious – to use a Mr. Greenspan term.Therein lies the problem. We’re apparently past that point, as a recent article in the WSJ noted – as originally proposed by Adam Smith.The answer goes back to the basics. It is faith-based. One has to convince the users of the system that everything is sound. In other words, there is no crisis. Sun Tsu wrote extensively on the principles to use in these circumstances. It is unequivocally about deception.Bernanke and Paulson have both said it is beyond a monetary solution. That relies on money/credit being created by fractional reserve banking. The problem is that there is too much debt. They have both said that fiscal policy is needed. That is a euphemism for more Fed Notes being created directly by the purchasing of more Treasury debt. They’ve done exactly what they said they were going to do with the conservatorship of Fannie and Freddie.Folks ask where the money comes from, and it is right there in plain sight. Either the expansion occurs from the fractional reserve side – monetary, or from the fiscal side. Monetary side is broken, so here comes the fiscal side.

AnonymousSeptember 6th, 2008 at 3:11 pm

@Alessandro on 2008-09-06 04:22:23Re: Karl Denninger aka GenesisAttention RNC – you have just lost my vote, and any person with more than two firing neurons in their head that votes for John McCain and Sarah Palin this fall is both certifiably insane and is voting for the intentional destruction of our nation’s financial security.It is probably too late. The right time was a few weeks ago, when the scheme was authorized (or maybe 4 or 8 years ago???).

AnonymousSeptember 6th, 2008 at 3:29 pm

Maggie you said it well. I went from 150,000 to less then 50 in under a yr . With it came many adjustments. I have two young boys and have been able to talk with them without bringing resentments. They have stayed happy and healthy and I now see that even if I have to cut more of what is left from the way we lived, everything will be great.I am 48 yrs old and own nothing but have everything because of our happiness.If the day comes that I need help with rent or food and have to go to those agencies that do that kind of stuff, well I hope I can still smile as I have been, and realize that it has all been a blessing because I have been forced to see what life is really about.If the u.s.a. is no longer the worlds leading power then so what. Flags are made of thread and if there is a need to stay warm that is the first thing I will burn.I have no money or wealth of any kind but I have my kids, myself and my brothers and sisters with a few good friends.Someone gave me 4 Yankee tickets for next week that are now selling for 1,500 a piece. My kids will have memories that will last forever of that game. Its moments like those that have no price as long as i can see their faces.I really do enjoy reading all this stuff but balance is good

AnonymousSeptember 6th, 2008 at 3:54 pm

Maggie you said it well. I went from 150,000 to less then 50 in under a yrWritten by Anonymous on 2008-09-06 15:29:13I went from 300k/year to 0 due to an accident and am not faring well at all. How can we speak to one another? I need your fortitide and optimism. I am having trouble holding on.

GuestSeptember 6th, 2008 at 6:40 pm

Speaking of trying to be prepared, I had just completed my first “Basic Personal Protection Course” which is code for “Shoot the SOB before he club/stab/shoots you.” Actually it’s a good course in the sense that you are forced to think about boundaries in society. What is the justification for protecting yourself? What are the legal issues in carrying a concealed weapon, its un-justified use, or the after-effects of justified use? For example, did you know that in some states if you just display a holstered weapon and grab the handle of the holstered gun, it can be considered a felony assault? Now think about all the TV/movies you have seen where a gun is brandished, each one is a felony in any state in real life!Anyway, a large part of personal protection is staying out of situations where someone can hurt you; and one does that by being alert and observant of their surroundings. A criminal selects the un-observant because they can gain an advantage through the element of surprize. Well, I am the AAA hyper type personality, so I consider myself pretty observant.As I said, I just finished class, and I decided to top off my gas tank with $3.50 gas before driving back to my small town, and BAM; There he at the front of my vehicle; “Hey Buddy, my car is out of gas…” The key to self-defense is to keep the stranger at least 20-30 feet from you so if they do make an aggressive move you can present your pistol. But not this guy, he was on me like white-on-rice asking if I would take him to his car where he would sell his tools for gas money. Wow, what a complete failure of personal protection. At least I did check his hands and pants for weapons before I said anything. I should have said no thanks and stood my ground. But instead, I said I did not want to buy his tools but I would give him $20 for gas! He gladly took my $20 and then asked if I had a gas can, but left when he sensed my irritation at the question.As to whether this was a “bad guy” or someone just “down on his luck” I do not know, but I got the feeling there will be a lot more of these types of encounters in the coming years.

K in TXSeptember 6th, 2008 at 7:45 pm

@ Guest on 2008-09-06 18:40:55Yeah, what can you do? I’ve been hit up for gas money a couple of times in the past. Once in a fast food parking lot and once in a pizza joint. It was a guy the first time and a youngish lady with kids the second.@ Anonymous on 2008-09-06 15:54:09Hang in there. It’s damn hard to go to nothing no matter where you start from. Speaking from experience it’s like your whole life blows up.It isn’t just having more debt and less stuff; less ability to purchase like you are used to (even the little stuff like your favorite brand of coffee) – though that is a difficult adjustment. What really stinks is the social isolation. Perhaps your experience has been better, but I found it impossible to maintain many ties once I was no longer able to afford to participate in regular social activities, modest though they were. And I feel sure that your self-image has taken a hit. Having to go to the county emergency room for medical care was a real low, not just because the experience itself was lousy, but because it was hard to accept falling so far.I survived unemployment for 2 years and had been living hand-to-mouth before then so could only fall back on debt as a way to squeak through. I sincerely hope that your injuries are such that you may recover and re-start a life that gives you a sense of self-satisfaction and community. In the meantime focus on the positive, sacrifice what you must, and salvage what you can.

Most Read | Featured | Popular

Blogger Spotlight

Edward Hugh Don't Shoot the Messenger

Congratulations to Edward Hugh whose EconoMonitor blog was #14 on CBNC's NetNet list of best alternative financial and economic blogs. Edward is a macro economist, who specializes in growth and productivity theory, demographic processes and their impact on macro performance, and the underlying dynamics of migration flows. Edward is based in Barcelona, and is currently engaged in research on aging, longevity, fertility and migration, and the impact of all of these on economic growth.

Economics Blog Aggregator

Our favorite economics blogs aggregated.