EconoMonitor

Don't Shoot the Messenger

Italy Enters Recession, But When Will It Leave?

According to preliminary data from Italy’s national statistics office ISTAT this morning Italy’s GDP fell 0.3 percent in the second quarter compared with the first three months of the year and was unchanged year-on-yearTechnorati Profile(ie there was zero percent annual growth). Final data and a detailed breakdown for the second quarter will be released on Sept. 10, however from the basic details that we have now it is clear that Italy’s economy is proving unable to lift its head in the face of the increasinglt difficult global conditions since despite the fact that first quarter, GDP rose 0.5 percent quarter-on-quarter, the annual increase was only 0.3 percent, and in the last quarter of 2007 the economy also contracted (by 0.4%). A fuller exploration to the background to Italy’s present predicament can be found in my earlier RGE European EconMonitor post – Italy’s Economy On The Ropes (Again).italy+one.jpg

European Central Bank President Jean-Claude Trichet stated yesterday that economic growth was expected to be “particularly weak” in the third quarter after ECB policy makers left borrowing costs at 4.25 percent, so it is not unreasonable to anticipate a second consecutive quarter of negative growth in Q3, and hence in all probability Italy is now in recession.

italy+2.jpg

If we look at what indications we do already have for the third quater, Italian consumer confidence in July slumped to the lowest since 1993, when the country was also – we should note – in quite a sharp recession following abandonment of the EMS. The Isae Institute index fell to 95.8 from 99.9 in June. In November 1993, the 26-year-old index hit a record low of 95.4.

italy+3.jpg Italy’s manufacturing sector contracted for the fifth straight month in July, posting its weakest performance in over six-and-a-half years, according to the results of the latest Markit/ADACI PMI survey. The Markit Purchasing Managers Index dropped to 45.3 from June’s 46.9, sinking further below the 50 divide between growth and contraction.

italy+five.jpg

If we look at the seasonally adjusted output index we can see that Italian industrial output has been dropping almost continually since the November/December 2006 peak, and we might well ask ourselves the question, with energy prices up where they are, when will this index ever rise again abover the late 2006 peak?

italy+seven.jpg

The Italian services sector purchasing managers’ index also in fell in July, to a seasonally adjusted 45.6 in July from 48.5 in June. So the contraction in services continues, and even accelerates into the third quarter of the year.

italy+six.jpg

And Italian retail sales declined in July for the 17th month in a row. The seasonally adjusted PMI for retail sales was at 38.2, up slightly from the 36.3 shocker registed in June. As with industrial output, we might like to ask ourselves when it will be, with Italy’s ageing and destined to contract population, that retail sales will ever expand again? Exports are no the only real way for Italy to get growth, but with the competitiveness problem that Italian industry faces this is proving to be something of a Herculean labour.

italy+four.jpg

Public Spending Cutback?

Earlier this week Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi survived a confidence vote in parliament over plans to raise taxes on oil companies and reduce salaries for mayors and public employees in a bid to balance the budget by 2011. Italy currently has a debt to GDP ratio of around 105% – way above the official EU limit of 60%. Italy is commited to at least achieving the common target of a balanced budget by 2011, but this looks to be fraught with difficulty to me, given Italy’s very poor economic performance and all the negative headwinds going forward.

Berlusconi managed to clear this particular hurdle this time round without too much difficulty, since his allies in the lower house of parliament helped him through what turned out to be a very comfortable vote of 312 to 239 and approved the necessary amendments to current legislation, and then passed the entire package 314 to 230.

The budget increases the corporate income-tax bracket for energy companies to 33 percent from 27.5 percent and raises taxes on oil and gas inventories. Banks and insurance companies also will pay more. Finance Minister Giulio Tremonti has called the measures “Robin Hood” taxes.

On the spending front, the government plans to cut city, town mayor and local administrator salaries by 20%. It is not clear how much of this is serious and how much “window dressing”, but since the government estimates that budget cuts at ministries will generate savings of 9 billion euros ($13.9 billion) next year, the salaries of more than a few mayors and public dignataries must be involved.

The broader economic policy outlined in the budget aims at boosting revenue and cutting spending by 36 billion euros over the next three years. Even with these cuts the deficit is expected to widen to 2.5 percent of gross domestic product this year from 1.9 percent last year, largely as a result, of course, of the current recession.

Now, if the Italian government are serious about this, and we will need to watch and wait to know since past performance is far from reassuring, then it will leave us with the clear possibility going forward of seeing an Italy with negative GDP growth in full years 2008, 2009 and 2010, since the little average underlying net growth that Italy does manage to achieve these days will largely be undermined by cut-backs in government spending and the impact of continuing high energy prices on export growth.

Italy+long+term+GDP.jpg

So the big question is: are the Italian people ready for three consecutive years of falling living standards and cuts in everything, or is Berlusconi going to have trouble holding his coalition together?

Comments are closed.