This will be a short but simple post, to clarify some fundamental misunderstandings about the purposes of laws, regulations, and codes of conduct in society.
Laws do not prevent crimes. We can legislate all the criminal laws we want, but there will still be bank robberies and drunk driving and murders. We pass laws not to prevent these acts from taking place, but rather, to make sure their is a very high cost to committing them.
In fact, we legislate criminal laws for three broad reasons:
1. Let people know exactly what is acceptable and unacceptable behavior.
2. Punish people who violate these norms.
3. Remove the dangerous people from society for the protection of everyone else.
We create corporate regulations in order to effect similar broad policy purposes:
1. Inform companies what is unacceptable economic behavior.
2. Punish corporate management who violate these norms.
3. Remove dangerous economic behaviors from society.
By economic behaviors, I refer to any impact a company has in the broader economy. This ranges from externalities such as pollution or financial risk to pushing the entire global economy to the abyss.
When it comes to laws, there is always a trade off: My freedom ends where your nose begins. Anything I do that threatens your health, safety or general well being is fair game for criminal laws; Anything a corporation does that threatens these same things is fair game for regulation.
There is a nefarious group of corporate cronies who abuse the word “Freedom.” They employ the word to mean curtailing everyone else’s freedom. They seem to believe Freedom is a license to behave recklessly, to endanger third parties, to risk the economy.
It is not.
The sooner we recognize these simple truths, the faster this society will be heading in the right direction. I suspect that the longer we delay recognizing these truths, the slower our economic recovery will be.
This post originally appeared at The Big Picture and is posted with permission.
2 Responses to “Laws Don’t Prevent Crime, They Punish It”
LAWS MAY NOT PREVENT CRIMES, BUT THEY DO DETER THEM TO AN EXTENT. THEY HAVE A ROLE TO PLAY IN BUILDING A CIVIL SOCIETY. THE MAJORITY TRIES TO ABIDE BY THEM, ONLY A MINORITY BREAKS THEM. THEY ARE NECESSARY TO BUILD AN ORDERLY SOCIETY. A LAWLESS SOCIETY WOULD BE WORSE OFF THAN A LAWFUL SOCIETY.
So let me see if I have this straight. Laws don't prevent crime, but regulations can "(r)emove dangerous economic behaviors from society." So all we have to do is eliminate the legislatures that enact laws and leave society in the hands of bureaucrats who can remove dangerous behavior by writing regulations. I don't know whether to be amused or angry at such sophistry.