Households Are Still Deleveraging. Or Not.

Calculated Risk reviews a David Leonhardt New York Times article and notes:

In addition, household debt as a percent of income, remains very high and household deleveraging is ongoing. That is why so many companies identify their number one problem as “lack of customers”…

The picture looks like this:

How much deleveraging is left remains a mystery.  Just to the pre-2000 trend, or even farther?  Or is the process pretty much over?  Steve Matthews at Bloomberg recently wrote a story full of anecdotes and quotes from those who believe we are very far along on the deleveraging story.  Some examples:

…“The financial situation of the household sector has improved far faster and far more than everyone thought it would two years ago,” said James Paulsen, chief investment strategist for Wells Capital Management in Minneapolis. “People are still locked into the view that consumers are facing record burdens, and they are not. There has been a change that is sustainable and durable.”…

…“The household deleveraging process is much further along than is appreciated,” said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody’s Analytics Inc. in West Chester, Pennsylvania. “This is evident in the rapid improvement in credit quality. ‘Zombie consumers’ is a mischaracterization of the state of the American consumer.”…

… Dean Maki, chief U.S. economist at Barclays Capital Inc. in New York, says the growth in credit reflects an underlying optimism, part of a virtuous cycle. As a Fed economist in 2000, he published research that concluded “high debt burdens are not a negative force” and the debt-income ratio isn’t reliable in predicting spending…

The picture that tells this story is this:


Household financial obligations – the ongoing service costs – have plunged since the beginning of the recession.  By this view, it is not the level of debt relative to income that should be the concern.  Instead, we should be looking at the cost of financing that debt.  And that cost steadily decreased since the 1980s as interest rates fell, allowing households to steadily increase their debt levels while financing costs were constrained.

For me, I can see both sides of this story, but keep coming back to this chart:


If household are trying to deleverage their way back to a net worth position of 470% of GDP, I imagine the period of deleveraging is only just beginning.  Consider years of cutting debt while hoping asset values rise sufficiently to pull you out of the post-bubble hole – all the while a mediocre economy ensures building assets is difficult at best.

But aside from the deleveraging question, another takeaway from the last chart always rattles in the back of my head: It sure looks like asset bubble-induced surges of net worth were critical in maintaining full employment during the past decade.  And we aren’t coming close to filling that hole with other spending.  Which is why we keep getting this picture:


and this picture:


This post originally appeared at Tim Duy’s Fed Watch and is reproduced here with permission.

One Response to “Households Are Still Deleveraging. Or Not.”

JPBulkoMBAJuly 19th, 2011 at 7:13 am

Yeah, we're screwed! However, to jump-start the American economy, I've written a proposal that describes a mechanism through which we can fund a massive number of new business ventures by tapping the financial power of Wall Street to create jobs on Main Street. This approach ramps up employment quickly and puts money directly into the hands of the people who need it now: the consumers (whose spending represents 70 percent of GDP). This enormous financial turbo-boost to the economy will reinvigorate economic activity and quickly return the eight million jobs lost during the Great Recession. The purpose of this mechanism is to take a private-sector proactive approach to address the expected long-term high unemployment problem.

You can read the proposal ("A Modest Proposal to Save the American Economy: Entrepreneurial Blitzkrieg as Job Creation Vehicle") and its companion piece ("The 75 Percent Solution? A Moral and Economic Imperative to Create Good Jobs NOW!") here:

Joseph Patrick Bulko, MBA

Most Read | Featured | Popular

Blogger Spotlight

Richard Wood Richard Wood

Richard has published papers on wages policy, the taxation of financial arrangements and macroeconomic issues in Pacific island countries. Views expressed in these articles are his own and may not be shared by his employing agency. He is the author of How to Solve the European Economic Crisis: Challenging orthodoxy and creating new policy paradigms