Its official – Spain and Portugal will need to be bailed out soon. How do I know? In one of my favorite TV shows, Yes Minister, the all-knowing civil servant Sir Humphrey explains to cabinet minister Jim Hacker that you can never be certain that something will happen until the government denies it.
So check out this article in Tuesday’s Financial Times:
Spanish and Portuguese leaders, with reinforcements from Brussels, are fighting a rearguard action to convince investors that there is no need for further eurozone bail-outs after the €80bn-€90bn ($109bn-$122bn) rescue agreed for Ireland at the weekend.
“Absolutely not,” said Elena Salgado, Spanish finance minister, when asked in a radio interview on Monday whether Spain needed help from the European Union. “Spain is doing everything it has promised to do, with tangible results.”
Portugal is regarded by bond market investors and economists as next in line for a rescue after the bail-outs of Greece and Ireland. But José Sócrates, Portuguese prime minister, was adamant that there was “no connection” between the Irish rescue and Portugal’s problems. “Portugal doesn’t need anyone’s help and will solve its own problems,” he said, insisting that the country had a clear strategy to cut its yawning budget deficit.
Was Sir Humphrey exaggerating? Perhaps, but I do remember that Dublin was pretty adamant just a week or so ago that there would be no restructuring of Irish debt.
The truth is we didn’t need the denials to know what was going to happen. Everything we are seeing in Europe has a great deal of historical precedence and events are unfolding very much according to the standard script. I think it is pretty safe to make the following predictions:
- Greece will be forced to default and restructure its debt, and the restructuring will come with a significant amount of debt forgiveness. The idea that it can grow its way out of the current debt burden is a fantasy. Remember that when countries are in conditions of financial distress, they face systematic disinvestment and capital flight, and as a consequence are never able to grow at anywhere close to the necessary rates – especially since any growth they do manage to achieve generally comes from additional fiscal spending, which simply runs up debt further.
- Greece will not be the only defaulter. Spain, Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Belgium and much of Eastern Europe will also face severe financial distress and possible default. History suggests that when a country is experiencing a solvency crisis, growth comes only after debt forgiveness, and many or most of those countries will also be forced into debt forgiveness.
- Political radicalism in these countries will rise inexorably as a consequence of rising class conflict. As Keynes pointed out as far back as 1922, the process of adjusting the currency and debt will primarily be one of assigning the costs to different economic groups, and this is never an easy or conflict-free exercise. Of course the less stable a government becomes as a consequence of this adjustment, the more likely it is to prefer very short-term solutions.* This Sunday, by the way, Catalans are likely to vote in an election in which the “current Socialist-led coalition government in Spain’s northeastern region will fall, a slap in the face for Spain’s prime minister, José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero,”, according to an article in Wednesday’s New York Times. There will be a lot more of this sort of thing in the next few years.
- So why not bite the bullet and just get it over with? Because the European banking system would not survive even the best-case restructuring scenario. As a consequence we are fated to witness several years of difficult economic adjustment while everyone pretends that these countries, under the right policies, can work their way through their debt burdens. What will really be happening is that European banks will aggressively rebuild their capital bases, with the unwilling help of the poor household sector, until they are sufficiently well capitalized to begin taking the write-offs. Only then will we recognize that some countries cannot repay their debts.
- As an aside the European junk-bond market might take off. With banks crippled in their lending activities, Europe’s financial markets will probably go through a process much like that which the US experienced in the 1980s. American banks at that time were unable to fulfill their traditional lending function as they struggled to clean up their LDC and energy loan portfolios, leaving the way open for the likes of Drexel Burnham to create a massive junk bond market. This process will be helped to the extent that European policymakers try to avoid paying for the adjustment by liberalizing bank-lending practices.
- Several countries, most notably Spain, will be forced to choose between giving up sovereignty to Germany, suffering extremely high rates of unemployment for several years, or giving up the euro. They will almost certainly choose the third option. There are still a lot of people who say giving up the euro is “unimaginable”, but that just shows a weak imagination. I especially remember in 2000 Domingo Cavallo dismissing the stupidity of foreign investors who imagined Argentina might be forced to suspend payments and devalue the peso – which it did in late 2001. More recently, on April 30, Cavallo warned Greece: “Don’t even think of abandoning the euro, whether temporarily or definitively, because that will provoke a financial catastrophe in Greece and various other countries in Europe.” Now there’s some useful advice, especially when you consider the huge surge in growth and the fall in unemployment Argentina experienced after it devalued.
This has been said before, but in a way this crisis is the European equivalence of the American Civil War. Once the dust finally settles Europe will either be a unified country with fiscal sovereignty firmly established in Berlin or Brussels, or it will be fragmented with little chance of reunion.
Part 2. Will Beijing raise interest rates to combat inflation?
The big concern in China now is rising inflation. The market is obsessed with fears over what steps Beijing will or will not take to combat rising prices. Beijing has already hiked interest rates, raised reserve requirements, imposed price freezes, and is reportedly going to tough out the existing lending quotas. Beijing may even throw in the towel and declare a “new normal.” According to an article in Wednesday’s South China Morning Post:
Beijing is likely to raise next year’s official inflation target and tighten monetary policy, state media said Wednesday, amid expectations for consumer prices to continue rising.
The Central Economic Work Conference, which is expected to meet next month, will probably hike the government’s annual inflation target to 4.0 per cent from 3.0 per cent this year, the China Business News said, citing an unnamed source. The conference is the most important economic policy making event of the year and gathers top Chinese leaders, usually including President Hu Jintao and Premier Wen Jiabao.
As I mentioned in an entry last month, it was going to be very hard for the banks to stay within this year’s RMB 7.5 trillion quota, and there was a real question about whether or not the regulators were going to enforce the quota. On Tuesday evening the PBoC even announced that it was going to face challenges in controlling the lending pace for the rest of the year. Separately, Tuesday’s Bloomberg had an interesting article on the subject:
China’s biggest banks are close to reaching annual lending quotas and plan to stop expanding their loan books to avoid exceeding the limits, according to four people with knowledge of the matter. Industrial & Commercial Bank of China Ltd., Bank of China Ltd. and Agricultural Bank of China Ltd. are only extending new loans as existing ones get repaid, the people said, speaking on condition of anonymity. Lenders are also cutting holdings of discounted bills to make room for longer-term debt, they said.
Tuesday’s People’s Daily is suggesting that next year’s loan quota will be below this year’s:
Financial institutions forecast that the new bank loan scale will reach between 6 trillion yuan and 7 trillion yuan in 2011. Although the figure is lower than the 7.5 trillion yuan of new bank loans for 2010, its upper limit will possibly reach 7 trillion yuan. This is mainly associated with the loans to be allocated to reserve projects.
I am very skeptical that they will be able to reduce the loan quota next year, especially if trade tensions worsen, which I expect, but I did notice that there was sort of an “out’ in the PD article:
Furthermore, a certain amount of new loans should be extended in order to ensure continued economic growth and structural adjustments in 2011.
On the subject of interest rates there was also this article in Bloomberg about concerns that interest rates would rise:
China’s benchmark money-market rate rose to the highest level in almost seven weeks on speculation policy makers will lift borrowing costs again after raising lenders’ reserve requirements last week to tame inflation.
China’s central bank adviser Xia Bin said the nation should further tighten monetary policy next year due to the pressure of excessive liquidity at home and abroad, the Shanghai-based Oriental Morning Post newspaper reported yesterday. The People’s Bank of China said Nov. 19 it would lift the amount of cash banks must set aside as reserves by 50 basis points from Nov. 29. A press official at the central bank, who refused to be identified, declined to comment.
“Future rate hikes and inflation-curbing measures are now more adequately priced in but the bias for higher rates will remain until the next rate hike materializes,” said Delphine Arrighi, a Hong Kong-based strategist at Standard Chartered Plc. “We still see another 25 basis point interest-rate increase by the end of this year, and another three increases, all of 25 basis points, within the first half of next year,” she said.
Last month I said I doubted Beijing’s resolve to hold firm on the loan quotas, just as I doubted we would see much action on the interest-rate front, but it seems increasingly likely that the hawks are going to win this argument. So are interest rates really rising, and if so will it matter?
The answer to the first question is: No. Inflation this year is rising much faster than interest rates, which have only managed a 25 basis-point hike. It will take at least 200-300 basis points, probably a lot more, just to bring real deposit rates back to where they were earlier in the year.
As for the second question, I am not sure raising rates will reduce inflation at all. On the contrary, in China they may actually increase inflation. I know this is going to seem pretty controversial – how can raising rates make inflation worse?
Bear with me. In the US, I think, most of us agree that raising interest rates is anti-inflationary, but why? I would argue that it reduces inflationary pressures primarily through three channels. First, raising interest rates makes it more expensive for consumers to borrow money to finance purchases.
Second, because most Americans save in the form of stocks, bonds, and real estate, rather than bank deposits, higher rates are associated with declining asset prices, and so Americans feel poorer. This (the “wealth effect”) causes them to reduce their consumption. Finally, raising rates reduces investment and so raises unemployment, further reducing consumption by increasing uncertainty and lowering household income.
In other words raising interest rates in the US puts downward pressure on prices by reducing demand. But will raising interest rates reduce demand in China?
I am not at all sure it will. Take the first of the three effects. Excluding mortgages (whose pricing reflects other concerns) there is very little consumer financing in China, so increasing its cost is not likely to have much effect. You might argue that it will affect demand for automobiles, where there is some financing, but this is a small part of the consumer basket and most of the inflationary pressure is anyway on food prices.
What about the wealth effect? Here raising rates may actually be counterproductive. The vast bulk of Chinese savings is in the form of bank deposits, and China’s artificially low interest rates are effectively a major hidden tax on household income, as I have argued many times before. In this case raising the deposit rate is like reducing taxes, and this is hardly likely to reduce demand. On the contrary, by raising disposable household income it will actually raise household consumption, although this may take several months before it is significant.
Finally what about the effect on investment and employment – will raising rates cause unemployment to rise? Maybe, but with real lending rates so low, perhaps even negative, and with the credit risk on much of the lending effectively socialized, the mechanism by which interest rates regulate lending does not work in China they way it does in the US. What limits credit growth in China is primarily the new lending quota, not interest rates, and perhaps not even reserve requirements. Interest rates themselves are likely to have little impact on the amount of lending – at least in the formal banking system, but in the informal banks, where there is no financial repression, it might. Anyway I am very skeptical that the State Council will let rates rise enough to let rising unemployment bring down demand.
In a funny way, then, rising inflation creates its own resolution in a financial system that is severely repressed. As inflation rises, real interest rates decline. This reduces real household income and so reduces demand. It also reduces the real borrowing cost for manufacturers, and so supply rises. In my opinion this is the main reason why countries with severely repressed financial systems can accommodate rapid monetary growth and low inflation, as China has for most of the past two decades.
This doesn’t necessarily mean that inflation won’t be a problem in China next year. Many things affect inflation besides the monetary response. My point is not that thanks to financial repression China can never experience inflation, it is merely that raising interest rates might not be nearly as effective in combating inflation as we might otherwise think and may even be counterproductive.
My former student and Shenyin Wanguo associate, Chen Long, after he saw the early version of this piece made a strong counter-argument that one of the consequences of inflation and negative real deposit rates is that households are reducing deposits and rushing to anticipate consumption – i.e. buying stuff now that they don’t really need as a store of wealth. This drives up consumption today, albeit at the expense of consumption tomorrow, and in that sense it may add inflationary pressure. Hiking interest rates, Chen Long pointed out, may reduce the incentive to do so. He is right, of course, but it is not clear that this effect outweighs the wealth effect.
While financially repressed systems are very good at combating inflation, this comes with a cost – overinvestment and low household consumption. Already we are seeing household deposits flee the banking system and much of this money is going to end up fueling even more asset bubbles. Meanwhile the value of Chinese savings continues to drop, making Chinese feel poorer and so reducing their consumption.
In my opinion this is the real reason the PBoC wants to raise interest rates. They want to slow down the massive capital misallocation China is experiencing and they want to rebalance the economy towards consumption by increasing household wealth. But are they succeeding? Not really. It would take an awful lot of interest rate hikes just to bring real interest rates to where they were a few months ago. Chinese growth is getting more, not less unbalanced. But perhaps we won’t have to worry about inflation too much longer.
51 Responses to “Chinese Inflation and European Defaults”
1967706 beers on the wall.
Thanks for taking the time to debate this, I really feel strongly about it and love studying extra on this topic. If attainable, as you achieve expertise, would you thoughts updating your weblog with extra data? This can be very helpful for me.
It’s best to participate in a contest for among the finest blogs on the web. I will recommend this website!
I intended to post you the tiny note so as to give thanks yet again regarding the amazing things you have documented on this website. It was simply seriously open-handed with people like you to give openly all most of us would’ve advertised as an ebook to get some dough for their own end, precisely considering that you might have done it in the event you decided. These smart ideas also worked as the easy way to recognize that the rest have similar passion just like mine to see many more when considering this condition. I know there are lots of more fun periods ahead for individuals that read carefully your site.
You’re the best, always enjoy reading your content.
I had fairly recently started off a new site reading the very best gps watches nowadays. Have a look take a look at.
Some great elements on that theme will be brought up there.
Boa tarde companheiros, provavelmente disparar um torpedo de graÃ§a estÃ¡ cada vez mais trabalhoso devido a restriÃ§Ã£o das operadoras de telefone. HÃ¡ ainda os serviÃ§os que prometem entregar minha menssagem mas nem sempre chegam ao usuÃ¡rio final. Alguns como o Mundo oi e o Oi Torpedo funcionam mas e para as outras operadoras? E os que dizem que enviam e nada chega. Para onde estÃ¡ indo as meus torpedos? E para a Tim, Vivo? Alguma IdÃ©ia? Ou significa ter de pagar?. Desculpem, realmente estÃ¡ difÃcil achar serviÃ§os para mandar SMS barato.
היי חשבתי ךהודיע על אתר ברשת האינטרנט בנושא קידום אתרים בגוגל. באתר האינטרנט אפשרלצפות באינפורמציה העוסק קידום אתרים בגוגל.
Fashion Courses Online…
[...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]…
I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was great.
Does your website have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an e-mail. I’ve got some recommendations for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it improve over time.
Awesome work over again. I am looking forward for more updates!
When I initially commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get several e-mails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove people from that service? Thanks!
Full Moon Party Thailand…
[...]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[...]…
You lost me, friend. Come on, man, I imagine I get what youre saying. I’m sure what you’re saying, but you just appear to have forgotten that might be a few other folks inside the world who view this problem for what it really is and can perhaps not agree with you. You could be turning away much those who might have been lovers of this website.
That is great to take into consideration, you gave me some thing to consider on bus ride to house from my cousins. Will you be writing far more about this topic? FYI I tried your rss button and it didnt work. I will try again in a couple of hours. http://ejmbail.com/
This design is spectacular! You definitely know how to keep a reader amused. Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Fantastic job. I really enjoyed what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it. Too cool!
It’s not that I want to replicate your web-site, but I really like the style. Could you let me know which design are you using? Or was it tailor made?
Hi, I just ran across your weblog via Bing. Your viewpoint is truly applicable to my life right now, and Iâ€™m really happy I found your website.
Howdy just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let you know a few of the images aren’t loading properly. I’m not sure why but I think its a linking issue. I’ve tried it in two different web browsers and both show the same outcome.
היי אני רוצה להמליץ לכם על חברה בתחום מכירת רכבים המתמחה בשרותי טרייד אין לסוכנויות רכב ולקוחות פרטיים . באתר, אינפורמציה רבה המלווה בתמונות מכירת הרכבים ורשימה המתעדכנת יום יום עם הרכבים הנמצאים במקום ומיועדים למכירה.
You lost me, friend. I mean, I imagine I get what youre indicating. I recognize what you are saying, but you just appear to have overlooked that you will find some other persons inside the world who look at this matter for what it truly is and might not agree with you. You may perhaps be turning away alot of folks who might have been lovers of your website.
Great write-up, I am a big believer in leaving comments on blogs and forums to let the blog writers know that theyâ€™ve added something worthwhile to the world wide web!
Great blog post, I’ve bookmarked this page and have a feeling I’ll be returning to it frequently.
Can I just say what a relief to seek out somebody who really knows what theyre talking about on the internet. You definitely know how to carry a difficulty to gentle and make it important. Extra individuals have to read this and perceive this side of the story. I cant believe youre no more well-liked since you positively have the gift.
I feel that may be an enchanting aspect, it made me think a bit. Thank you for sparking my thinking cap. Every now and then I am getting so much in a rut that I simply feel like a record.
The ideas you provided allow me to share extremely precious. It turned out such a pleasurable surprise to get that looking forward to me while i awoke today. These are constantly to the issue and to understand. Thanks a large amount for the valuable ideas you’ve got shared the following.
Hola! I’ve been reading your site for some time now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Humble Tx! Just wanted to say keep up the great job!
It’s not that I want to copy your web page, but I really like the layout. Could you tell me which theme are you using? Or was it tailor made?
I’m speechless. This can be a very good blog and really attractive too. Great work! That’s not actually a lot coming from an beginner publisher like me, but it surely’s all I could say after diving into your posts. Nice grammar and vocabulary. Now not like different blogs. You in reality realize what you?re talking approximately too. So much that you made me want to explore more. Your blog has become a stepping stone for me, my friend.
Excellent read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing a little investigation on that. And he really bought me lunch because I located it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch!
Great page…keep up the good work!
Greetings! I’ve been following your weblog for a while now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Austin Tx! Just wanted to say keep up the fantastic job!
That is excellent to know, you gave me some thing to consider on walk to home from my job. Will you be writing a lot more about this topic? FYI I tried your rss button and it didnt work. I will try once more in a few hours. http://bailbondsreview.com/
היי, רציתי להעלות לכל גולשי האינטרנט בקשר ל וובסיטט עם מאמרים בדבר קידום אתרים בגוגל וגם מנועי החיפוש.
Have seen and heard about such an insect for the first time. I really like knowing about various types of insects and animals. The life cycle of the insect shared in here seems to be very interesting. Will look forward to more such interesting posts.
Great job, It’s posts like this that keep me coming back and checking this blog regularly, thanks for the info!
Exceptional info thanks
Hi, I just found your web site via yahoo. Your viewpoint is truly relevant to my life currently, and Iâ€™m really delighted I discovered your website.
I’ve also been thinking the exact same issue personally lately. Delighted to see an individual on the same wavelength! Nice article.
Do you know that one can possibly put an end to shameful blushing? Find out how to put a stop to blushing with no need of medical procedures.
Good work, thanks for the awesome blog post. I’m having troubles subscribing to your blogs feed. Thought I’d let you know
I am speechless. It is a very good blog and very engaging too. Nice work! That’s now not in point of fact so much coming from an beginner publisher like me, but it’s all I may just say after diving into your posts. Great grammar and vocabulary. Not like different blogs. You in point of fact know what you?re talking approximately too. So much that you just made me wish to discover more. Your weblog has turn into a stepping stone for me, my friend.
Chocolate malt on hot day = happy Andy|AndrewKroll|
very nice post, i certainly love this website, carry on it
Thank you for another fantastic blog. Where else may one get that kind of knowledge written in such an ideal way? I even have a presentation that i’m presently working on, and i have been searching for such information instead.
Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results. If you know of any please share. Cheers!
Your current positions continually possess many of really up to date info. Where do you come up with this? Just declaring you are very imaginative. Thanks again
Thanks for your Post! It was very helpful.