The Other Stress Test (For Bankers)

There is nothing you can teach Wall Street titans regarding the timing of news flow.  Stephen Friedman, the former head of Goldman Sachs, resigned last night as chair of the New York Fed’s board, after committing essentially a rookie error.  In December/January, he traded the stock of a company (Goldman) overseen by the NY Fed, while helping to pick a new head of the Fed (formerly from Goldman), and presumably being aware of other potentially nonpublic information regarding bank rescues (benefiting Goldman both directly and indirectly).  The real error, given the Federal Reserve System’s incredibly lax rules on potential conflicts of interest at this level, was failing to disclose this information to the NY Fed – they learned it from WSJ reporters and that cannot have been a good moment.

If you have to resign, pick your time of day carefully, and Friedman is obviously advised by the best people in the business.  I’m looking at the hard copies of four newspapers.  The news of his departure does not make the front page of the NYT (not even the small stuff at the bottom) or the front page of their Business Day section.  There is nothing on the front page of the FT or Washington Post.  Even the WSJ only manages three paragraphs on the front page, before sending you to look for p.A10.  (It was on cnn.com from 5:55pm last night, together with his resignation letter.)

I haven’t checked who first broke the news, but Friedman’s resignation was of course the major development of yesterday.  The bank stress test results were hard-baked a long time ago, and almost all the icing on that cake had already been leaked.  But the stress test for bankers is still underway.

The idea of a stress test, of course, is to see what goes wrong under pressure.  We do this for banks with hypothetical scenarios, but when you go to see the cardiologist you need to step on a treadmill and actually get your heart rate up.  The stress test for bankers is very relevant for thinking about our future financial system in three ways:

  1. We are now seeing how they behaved during a boom, both in terms of compensation system and insider-type transactions.
  2. We can see what happened during a crash and attempted recovery; part of which is about massive taxpayer provided subsidies (do the bankers even have the manners to say thank you?) and much of which is about tilting the playing field towards pre-provision earnings (for which Jan Hatzius of Goldman has the most eloquent exposition).
  3. Most interesting, of course, is how bankers think.  They regard themselves as entitled to outsized compensation that encourages excessive risk taking.  They think that insider trading rules apply to other people.  And they are convinced that only they – and their friends – are capable of running government in boom or bust (or in ways that boom leads to bust, at which time you buy low and then recover through large implicit support from the government.)

Really what we have seen over the past two years (a great Freudian slip from the Comptroller of the Currency on NPR last night) is a stress test of our bankers.  If you think they basically did fine, then we can go about our business with essentially the same financial system that has developed in the last couple of decades.

If you have concerns about how they behaved and the potential consequences of such behavior down the road, then we need to talk further.  The banks passed their stress tests, in part because these were designed by bankers and people friendly to bankers (we could also think about how our regulators have done over the past two years).  But are the bankers passing their stress tests?


Originally published at the Baseline Scenario and reproduced here with the author’s permission.

5 Responses to "The Other Stress Test (For Bankers)"

  1. Anonymous   May 8, 2009 at 3:57 pm

    This is all a prelude to mass mergers. These things will be packaged and reshipped just like the loans they made. http://www.newsy.com/videos/u_s_banks_survival_stress/

  2. Guest   May 8, 2009 at 4:43 pm

    So Citi, Goldman, BAC and JPM own Obama no less than they owned Bush.I’m shocked. SHOCKED, I tell you.

  3. Guest   May 10, 2009 at 10:16 am

    Thank you Prof. Johnson for bravely writing this piece. I hope that more people pick up this thread and write an indepth report about how bankers and military industrial complex run this country making a mockery of both democracy and free market economics.

  4. Guestew   June 19, 2009 at 12:14 am

    我是个嘴硬心软的女孩,讨厌被伤害,可是我会选择默默的自己承受.我是个很容易相信人的女孩,喜欢的人说什么好听的话我都会相信.我是个容易满足的女孩,生活中一些小事情就能让我很感动.现在的我很独立可以一个人吃饭,一个人逛马路,一个人喝下午茶,一个人静静的呆在家里,可以什么也不做对着电脑发呆,可以几天不睡觉之后再可以把自己弄到很累然后倒头就睡.以前的我听不得别人骂我,现在的我笑着听别人骂我,其实我很讨厌这样.以前的我经常忽视关心我的人,现在的我习惯了被我关心的人忽视.以前的我心里难受会说出来,现在的我会往肚子里咽.以前的我讨厌别人和我争共享,现在的我可以慢慢去忍受.以前的我存有一丝乐观,现在的我只有悲观的想法.以前的我……

  5. dd   June 22, 2009 at 11:53 pm

    イケメン出会いお金持ち出会いイケメンお兄系出会い医者出会い弁護士出会い社長出会いサクラなし人妻熟女セフレセレブ割り切り無料出会い逆援助お金持ちお兄系医者メル友素人出会いギャル出会いOL出会い大人向けご近所出会いジャンル別無料出会い気軽な出会いまじめ出会い不倫チャット掲示板出会い女性専用恋愛専用結婚前提出会い攻略おすすめ出会い登録なし直アド直メ安心出会いフリメヤラセなし人気出会い写メ付きナース出会い真剣出会い出会い近所北海道出会い青森出会い岩手出会い秋田出会い山形出会い宮城出会い福島出会い茨城出会い千葉出会い東京出会い栃木出会い埼玉出会い群馬出会い神奈川出会い新潟出会い長野出会い山梨出会い岐阜出会い愛知出会い静岡出会い三重出会い富山出会い石川出会い福井出会い滋賀出会い奈良出会い京都出会い大阪出会い和歌山出会い兵庫出会い愛媛出会い香川出会い徳島出会い高知出会い鳥取出会い島根出会い広島出会い岡山出会い山口出会い大分出会い宮崎出会い鹿児島出会い熊本出会い福岡出会い佐賀出会い長崎出会い沖縄出会い写メ出会い素人写メ人妻写メエロ写メ巨乳写メ熟女写メロリ写メ女子高生写メイケメン写メJK写メ素人投稿タダ出会い出逢い無料えっちなし登録なし出会い出会い比較無料出会い比較出逢いランキング人妻出逢い熟女出逢いセフレ出逢いセレブ出逢い割り切り出逢い出逢い無料逆援出逢いイケメン出逢いお金持ち出逢いイケメン専門彼氏募集彼女募集恋人探し恋愛恋愛したい人妻専門熟女専門セフレ専門セレブ専門割り切り専門恋愛セックス浮気友達友達募集メール友達友達募集掲示板リア友ヒマ友暇つぶし女友達男友達女友達募集男友達募集友達作り方トモダチ北海道メル友青森メル友岩手メル友秋田メル友山形メル友宮城メル友福島メル友茨城メル友千葉メル友東京メル友栃木メル友埼玉メル友群馬メル友神奈川メル友新潟メル友長野メル友山梨メル友岐阜メル友愛知メル友静岡メル友三重メル友富山メル友石川メル友福井メル友滋賀メル友奈良メル友京都メル友大阪メル友和歌山メル友兵庫メル友愛媛メル友香川メル友徳島メル友高知メル友鳥取メル友島根メル友広島メル友岡山メル友山口メル友大分メル友宮崎メル友鹿児島メル友熊本メル友福岡メル友佐賀メル友長崎メル友沖縄メル友メル友探し携帯メル友メル友真面目エッチメル友メル友チャットSM募集SMクラブSM出会い童貞出会い40代メル友童貞卒業まじめメル友ゲイメル友メル友30代メル友エッチメル友恋人メル友高校生メル友50代童貞メル友サイトメル友募集掲示板写メメル友女性メル友熟年メル友メル友えっち素人素人無料素人娘素人投稿写真素人SM素人セックス素人素人掲示板中高年メル友優良メル友写メ付きメル友ギャル素人不登校メル友うつメル友受験生メル友出会い習い事料理教室出会いクリスチャン結婚在日コリアン出会い家出家出泊めてプチ家出素人Hナンパ素人家出掲示板ナンパ出会い素人無料掲示板素人レズナンパ素人画像家出神待ち家出神様募集結婚できない結婚情報結婚相手家出サポート結婚相談結婚紹介結婚掲示板チャットルームツーショットチャット初心者チャットチャット無料結婚掲示板プチ家出掲示板家出少女チャットアダルト家出出会いHチャットプロフプロフィールご近所検索ご近所掲示板ご近所メールプロフHプロフ画像プロフ援助プロフ写真ご近所恋愛プロフ掲示板写メ投稿写メ友写メ掲示板写メ画像直アド出会い無料直アド直アド掲示板セフレ人妻セフレセレブ無料写メセフレ募集盗撮写メセックスフレンドエロヌード着エロ18禁